Complex games always existed. They're just becoming more mainstream. This is understandable. Boardgamers tend to fall into one of three camps:
1. The "let's see what happens" crowd. This group tends like to like games with a significant luck element. It includes coop type games that I tend to describe as "group vs deck" games.
2. The "social gamer". There is a strong social aspect in any boardgaming but for some it's clearly a priority. This group will favour lighter games and may not tend to play optimally or think too deeply about strategy.
3. The "board gamers". While this can still be social, this group tends to be more focused on the play and will try and optimize strategy.
So what's really happened in the last 20+ years is that group (3) has grown quite a lot. So-called "gateway games" 9eg Catan) were probably a huge factor in this. A natural consequence for this is that people develop an appetite for complexity. It starts to become much easier to absorb the complexity of these games.
For example, I've played probably half the games on this list and I would say that none of them are "heavy". There are a couple of "medium-to-heavy" but it can get much heavier than this.
As an aside, of the group Great Western Trail is my current favourite. Mombasa (by the same designer) never really grabbed me. It just seems a bit too abstract (eg by playing bananas you may get to move armies around. Or not).
To your last comment, I've played games that have a typical playing time of 4+ hours. 90 minutes is definitely in the medium (and maybe medium to heavy) camp.
I haven't played Legacy, because on principle I won't buy a game that can only be played a set number of times.
In conclusion, get off my lawn, I guess.
I'm not as familiar with pandemic legacy, but with risk legacy, by the time you play 15 games with 5 people, the cost per person per game play is very low. And it's very exciting.
You're missing out. I can think of two of my family's favourite games that break your rule, and my players are only seven years old. First would be Splendor (engine-building game with 5 different colors of tokens that you use to buy properties). Second would be Speicherstadt (two separate sets of tokens - 1 set that represent's the players Agents that you use to bid on contracts, shipments, and properties, and second is a set of color-coded tokens that arrive on shipments that you use to fulfill contracts).
These games are incredibly simple and can be explained in a few minutes. Simpler than Catan's tedious set-up process and annoying edge-case rules.
And, for an over-engineered game, I played Terraforming Mars recently. The textbook example of an overengineered game. You have tokens to track quantity and income of each resource, and there are a half-dozen resources. Add that to a board and shoebox of cards each with its own elaborate rules.
It was a lot to take in first turn, but I have to say: this was the most fun I've had playing in a long time. Every card was a new exploration of the interaction of the rules, a new twist. The game was brilliantly designed in that the well-structured board meant that managing income and quantities of each resource was never ever tedious (unlike the wargames of my youth).
I couldn't play that with my kids, but I enjoyed the hell out of it.
To me, the game's only flaw was the map - I felt like the Map of Mars was almost an afterthought despite how it visually seemed to be the centre of the game. For the most part the map could have been replaced with a couple of extra score-tracks (which would be consistent since it already had a fistfull of score-tracks).
Seriously, thanks!
The ones that endure are the simpler (e.g. "Ticket to Ride" and even "Settlers of Catan") games.
My favorite games are either very simple or designed to absorb complexity into familiar devices, like decks of cards and well-designed boards. And they thrive on a deceptively simple mechanic, a few difficult decisions, and a sense of urgency. Pandemic, Dominion, Ticket to Ride, 7 Wonders and Quadropolis come to mind. Each of these is clever, not just because it adds another "thing to keep track of," but because it asks you to do something that seems easy and is not.
I am speaking out of ignorance a little, though, since I haven't played many eurogames (and probably don't have the patience for any game that takes longer than 90 minutes).