News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by vowelless on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:20PM (#14464156)
Can someone give me pros and cons of this move (serious responses only)?

Thanks

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by davesque on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:23PM (#14464196)
I think the only way anyone could argue there are any pros is if they could convince me that Trump has a different long-term plan to address climate change. Unfortunately, all of his actions up to this point indicate that he doesn't have any such plan. I really wish people would stop trying to understand and rationalize this man's actions. He has no rational for what he does other than his own short-lived whims and the general selfishness and narcissism that underlies his world view.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by maxxxxx on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:29PM (#14464285)
That's a Republican orthodoxy, not just Trump. Climate change either doesn't occur, or if it occurs it's not man made, if it's man made nothing can be done. In any case, doing anything is job killing and anti freedom.

I think Trump himself doesn't care.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by optimuspaul on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:39PM (#14464419)
Seems to me that doing something would actually create jobs, but maybe not enough to offset those lost? Shortsighted is what it really is. Who cares if it's job killing if the alternative is civilization killing.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by MadSax on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:37PM (#14464389)
I don't think anyone argues that it doesn't occur, not even Republicans. The focus is on the extent of man's impact and what should be done about it. From the Republican point of view the alarmists have lost all credibility since about the 70s or 80s.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by giarc on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:38PM (#14464405)
Many large corporations have come out against this decision (P&G, Coca Cola, GE, FB, G, 3M, Dow etc). So if he's not doing this because of lobbying from them, why is he doing this? Lobbying from O&G companies? Or is it just pure ignorance?
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by creaghpatr on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:53PM (#14464592)
The vast majority of companies in America are not Fortune 500 companies. The companies you listed would benefit disproportionately from the agreement because smaller businesses would struggle to meet the cost of compliance without the global scale.

The number of American voters in those companies probably totals out to 2-3M tops, in a country of 350M.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by giarc on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:44PM (#14465130)
I guess my comment was more about the idea or common thought that governments are under the thumb of the large corporations (those with the resources for large lobbying firms). Therefore, if these corporations are against this decision, who is Trump doing this for? Polls have shown majority of Americans are in favour of staying in the agreement (although I haven't seen the numbers broken down by party lines). So what is his motivation? Ironically this was a campaign promise, and the American public voted him in, so for once a politician is keeping their promise.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by marcell on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:52PM (#14464582)
> Lobbying from O&G companies

Exxon Mobil's current and previous CEO were in favor of the Paris Accords. The previous CEO is also Trump's secretary of state.

> Or is it just pure ignorance?

There are vague claims that this will bring back manufacturing jobs, bring back oil coal jobs, etc. I don't know what the real reasons are, if any.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by mywittyname on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:41PM (#14465093)
I speculate that Exxon Mobile's executive team is in support of it for selfish reasons. I'm not authority, but I bet it's easier for them to operate in foreign countries when the corporation's country of origin is involved in an international treaty because they can more easily claim to be in compliance of the law.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by okreallywtf on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:41PM (#14464448)
That also assumes that whatever economic gains will be greater than the potential gains we could make by creating exportable renewable technology and the benefits of creating large numbers of sustainable energy jobs.

Then you have to account for the fact that as pollution (and therefore, CO2) is reduced, air quality improves, cancer rates decrease and all of the other health benefits related to airborn pollutants.

We are looking at an America without those things, or at least with renewables being adopted slower and with more resistance from the federal government than before.

I'm ashamed really, I'm especially ashamed by all the poor/middle class people who are actually proud of this just because it makes liberals and europeans unhappy.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by empath75 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:13PM (#14464812)
Trump's position amounts to hostage taking. Give us lots of money or we'll destroy the planet. It would be more honest if he did it with nukes.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:26PM (#14464230)
Thanks for clarifying the pros and cons of this policy without inserting any of your personal bias!
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by davesque on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:27PM (#14464261)
You're welcome.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by samsonradu on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:27PM (#14464252)
Well, not that I am defending him, but in his speech he said the deal is a burdain on the US industry while China and India are polluting as hell. This is something that might be factually right, but still not something to aspire to.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by mmilano on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:30PM (#14464297)
I watched the announcement w/o knowing much about it. He justified the decision by saying:

- We're paying 100b/year when other developed countries do not have to. - Spending on that is unaccounted for. - The impact will be (only) a 2/10 Celcius reduction in temperature by 2100 - The positive impact by 2030 is the equivalent of what China pollutes in 14 days.

Just stating what was said. I don't know which are facts.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by fudgie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:40PM (#14464427)
According to Michael E. Mann, in 2100 it's +4.5C with no action, +3.5C with just the Paris Accord, and +1.8C with ratcheting up. (https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DBQpulkWAAE2mrc.jpg)
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by sparkzilla on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:23PM (#14464919)
Would that be the 'Nobel prize winner' Dr Mann, who massaged the so-called hockey stick data leading to all this climate change/global warming hysteria in the first place? Hardly a credible source of anything IMHO.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by alayne on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:18PM (#14465851)
False. That is "skeptic" nonsense. Note the quotes around skeptic because I don't consider climate denialists true skeptics.

"Climategate" was reviewed extensively by numerous organizations and no wrongdoing was found. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_c...

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by sparkzilla on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:50PM (#14466131)
Dear oh dear. Using Wikipedia to support Climate Change denial denial? Ignorance is bliss I guess. This is a good overview I picked from a random search of the many issues with Mann's work re the Hockey stick, and his lack of professional integrity [1], which is even hinted at in the well-scrubbed Wikipedia page. Anyway there's a ton of easy-to-find extremely well-sourced information debunking the stick.

By the way, Mann was forced to stop calling himself a 'Nobel Prize recipient', after it was found out that he wasn't directly awarded the prize; it was awarded to the IPCC.[2]

[1] https://wattsupwiththat.com/2017/03/29/reflections-on-mark-s...

[2] http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/331738/michael-manns-fa...

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by alayne on Thursday June 01, 2017 @08:22PM (#14466356)
You posted a garbage book by a non scientist well known conservative climate denier. You are a crackpot and I don't have any more time for this.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by glup on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:30PM (#14465497)
cite your sources please
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by sparkzilla on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:38PM (#14465560)
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by scrollaway on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:24PM (#14464208)
Decent thread on it: https://www.reddit.com/r/NeutralPolitics/comments/6eey64/wha...

TLDR; the only positive argument you can make about it is that with the current administration, the pact wouldn't have been respected anyway so it opens the avenue for others things.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Mikeb85 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:31PM (#14464308)
It's not really about immediate pros and cons. The Paris accords don't actually hold nations to any sort of immediate reduction in CO2 emissions. They call for nations to start reducing their emissions in 2020, and progress to a final target in about half a century. Obama's pledge wasn't to even be realised until 2025.

Most nations are implementing various carbon taxes in an attempt to reduce emissions, the obvious is that no carbon tax means no additional tax on businesses and transportation. This could be considered an upside.

Downside? Who knows, the US never really implemented anything anyway, so practically nothing will change. Ultimately, potential issues will be global warming on a catastrophic level. Then again, that may happen with or without the US attempting to reduce emissions.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by throwaway-1209 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:05PM (#14464732)
Pros: the US was signing up for a _minimum_ of $100B/yr in foreign aid to help others implement the accords. When you're up to your ears in debt that's kind of stupid.

Cons: estimates say that the climate will be warmer by 0.3 degrees Celsius by 2100. Assuming estimates are in fact right (which they historically haven't been) this could have devastating effects elsewhere in the world.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by surveilmebro on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:22PM (#14464909)
For anyone taking this comment seriously: verify the numbers for yourself. The poster has given the lower bound of the confidence interval in positing that we will see 0.3C warming by 2100. The latest assessment puts warming at 3.7C (6.67F!) under the "Business as Usual" RCP8.5 scenario.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_Concentration_P...

Edit -- not to mention that climate models are quite good at reproducing the observed changes:

https://www.skepticalscience.com/Climate-Models-Show-Remarka...

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by throwaway-1209 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:59PM (#14465266)
That's if _everyone_ withdraws. That's not what's happening. 0.3 degrees is if the US withdraws but everyone else proceeds as planned. But we aren't even withdrawing per se. Immediately after announcing his decision, Trump also announced his willingness to re-negotiate the accords on better terms (by which I think he means not spending $100/B a year on something that other countries aren't even legally bound by).

And climate models predict things just fine as long as you pick the ones that are somewhat accurate in retrospect. That's not what prediction is. Prediction is when, like Al Gore, you say that in 15 years we'll all be underwater, and it doesn't happen. If you bet your money on the accuracy of the current models you will lose.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by surveilmebro on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:13PM (#14465376)
Complete nonsense on both counts. First of all, consider that the most visible public debate about this has centered on whether it is even possible to limit warming to 2C. Start by reading the two links I posted. If you would like to learn more, the IPCC reports are genuinely well written and accessible: https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/

I would hope that at least on HN we could all agree on a shared objective reality and the validity of the scientific method. Your claims sound like something straight out of a Heartland brochure.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by throwaway-1209 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:18PM (#14465420)
Further clarification, my bad: 0.3 degrees _greater_ warming if the US withdraws. Not 0.3 degrees total. The climate is warming, no one is disputing that. It's not warming anywhere near as quickly as models from 10 years ago predicted, though.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by kaybe on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:01PM (#14465725)
No, but that means we underestimated an energy sink, probably the ocean. That additional energy isn't going anywhere.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by pseudometa on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:26PM (#14464245)
On the pro side, Trump can say he followed through with a campaign promise. The accord was non-binding self-enforced, so from a day-to-day business impact, not much changes from regular Trump policy setting. On the con side, foreign relations will be stressed and global climate policy will be set without US corporate input (possibly a good thing?).
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by slededit on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:33PM (#14464329)
You need to separate the details of the deal from the goal its attempting to achieve. The deal itself limits the US more than other countries which pollute more in absolute terms, and results in wealth transfers to those countries (directly).

Given the relative wealth of the nation's involved I think the deal was fair. But that is a debatable point. The USA doesn't need this deal in place to limit its own emissions although its unlikely Trump would put much effort into it.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:32PM (#14464315)
The deal is unenforceable, very expensive, and most likely will fail. Also, China emits twice as much greenhouse gas as the United States.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by neaden on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:37PM (#14464390)
It's almost like they have more people then the US does? Like about four times as many?
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by tzs on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:35PM (#14464366)
> Also, China emits twice as much greenhouse gas as the United States.

Not per capita, which is what is relevant when it comes to setting a country's policies.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:46PM (#14464516)
So as long as your country is overflowing with poverty-stricken people, you're a role model for solidly low carbon emissions per capita? Got it..
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by dguaraglia on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:56PM (#14465690)
Oh, moving the goalposts. The classical right-wing strategy.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Friday June 02, 2017 @03:30PM (#14472681)
How is that moving the goalposts? Any poor, overpopulated country is going to have low per-capita carbon emissions, true or false?

They also have a lower quality of life and poor GDP. Not exactly a positive goal to shoot for.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by dguaraglia on Friday June 02, 2017 @10:14PM (#14474613)
You started by saying China emits double the amount of greenhouse gasses the US does. Someone pointed out that it's still lower on a per-capita basis, so you switched tack to "oh, well, yeah, but... WHY DO POOR COUNTRIES GET A PASS!" That, my friend, is moving the goalposts.

So you want the US, richest nation in the world, to be held to the same standards as developing countries. Even though, in our economy, pushing for green energy actually generates more jobs than trying to bring back polluting industries. What, exactly, is there to gain from that?

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Monday June 05, 2017 @06:50PM (#14493010)
I'm not trying to set (or move) any goalposts, I'm just pointing out that per capita emissions is a fairly useless metric to judge anything by, for reasons we seem to agree on.

Ideally, I'd want the free market to manage the standards via private certification, rather than some monolithic, global, unenforceable treaty that is little more than virtue signaling via giving developing countries lots of free money for no (or negligible) return.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by pouetpouet on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:36PM (#14464369)
The US emit more than double per capita.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by fvdessen on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:44PM (#14465128)
USA's emissions/gdp are close to the world's average, and have been improving at the same rate as other nations. It is not doing a bad job at environment and there isn't a valid reason to single it out [1]

[1] http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/...

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:39PM (#14464425)
So you're saying you want to emulate countries that have much denser populations, countries who are so poor that they can't afford much carbon-producing industry, yet who continue to have unsustainable birthrates? I'm pretty sure the US sets a better example on that front.

Carbon per capita aside, do you realize how much pollution China and India produce? Do you realize what the rivers and lakes are like in those countries?

Yet you want to pay them Billions of dollars from US taxpayers to enable them to do even more of the same? How does that make sense?

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by kneth on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:37PM (#14464386)
Well, China has more than four times as many citizens.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:44PM (#14464484)
And therein lies the problem.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by oblio on Thursday June 01, 2017 @05:22PM (#14464901)
A fellow HackerNews reader had a great quote, I don't remember the source.

You're basically complaining that China has too many people and would presumably want that some of them wouldn't exist.

His quote was: "If you think a certain group of people shouldn't exist, how do you select that group of people? And how do you know that you, yourself, shouldn't he a part of that group?".

China's population is a fact. In the end, you can't argue against facts. And in their current circumstances, China, a much poorer per capita country than the US, is willing to sacrifice a bit of their profits for long term stability.

The US is basically eating its own seed corn.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:05PM (#14465320)
> would presumably want that some of them wouldn't exist.

I simply don't want to pay to enable them even more.

When the proper social constraints aren't in place, money = energy = more babies.

It's poor policy to continually reward countries that are chronically overcrowded and polluted, it just makes the issues worse long-term.

>The US is basically eating its own seed corn.

It's hilarious to me that you believe this when ~85% of the rivers in China are qualified as "very polluted" or "extremely polluted."

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by legolas2412 on Friday June 02, 2017 @01:15AM (#14467640)
> When the proper social constraints aren't in place, money = energy = more babies.

Funny, it is actually money = better healthcare = less infant mortality + higher cost of raising child = less fertility rate = less babies.

Rich countries don't have more babies than poor ones, its the opposite.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Friday June 02, 2017 @03:10PM (#14472565)
>Rich countries don't have more babies than poor ones, its the opposite.

Rich countries are market democracies. They have the proper social constraints.

In a market democracy it's more like you described, but not entirely, there are plenty of people who abuse the welfare systems to have as many children as possible for the tax credits and other benefits.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by legolas2412 on Sunday June 04, 2017 @05:46AM (#14480569)
Clearly you don't understand the mentality of developing countries. Do you think they are socialist utopia?

I am from India. And the main sentiments for people having more children were - high infant mortality (not knowing who will live to be old, which is still high for India but falling fast), more hands mean more money in home (less people to hire in the farm).

The "more hands mean more money" is exactly what market economy gets you, not a centrally planned communist economy. But with rising standard of living and cost of raising a child, people are moving away from the old mentality.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by kaybe on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:03PM (#14465739)
Just a point, air pollution has peaked about 2 years ago and is starting to go down. (Not sure if that data is published yet.) There is some progress.
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by oblio on Thursday June 01, 2017 @10:17PM (#14466939)
Go read about the "1 child policy" and get back to me when you have a clue what you're talking about. "Enabling", sheesh. You're enabling them through buying iPhones made in China, not through this agreement. You're so way off in this discussion that I don't think it's worth continuing it.

Have a nice day!

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by Danihan on Friday June 02, 2017 @03:13PM (#14472587)
The "1 child policy" is what you get when you have an authoritarian government instead of democracy.

China doesn't have a properly functioning government, therefore they have to resort to crazy policies like that.

And I don't think we should be enabling through trade either, ideally we would jack up tariffs massively on countries with poor human rights, excessive pollution, etc.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by microcolonel on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:01PM (#14466598)
Here's a video which contains an argument that the accord is largely pointless, because China isn't just going to stick its head in the sand and go back to a pre-industrial economy tomorrow: https://youtu.be/QOFhpoDY0As

James Hansen, a former NASA climate scientist, previously described the paris accord as "a fraud". He's describing this from the perspective of knowing it's not enough to do anything significant, and incredibly expensive. [0]

[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/dec/12/james-ha...

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by dguaraglia on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:55PM (#14465686)
Pros: "it's the opposite of what Obama and Libruls wanted!". That's good enough for some of the Republican base, but that's about it. Most of the economic growth in the US has come from the clean energy industry and from improving current industries to be less polluting. Being able to burn coal and fuel 24/7 just "because we can" isn't going to make the country more productive. It's just a canard.

Cons: - US losing leadership position on everything related to climate change - US opening itself to tariffs from other countries that are in the Paris agreement - US looking like a regressive regime that does stupid shit just to get headlines

My guess is the third one will have the biggest impact.

Re:US quits Paris climate pact by chestervonwinch on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:26PM (#14464243)
Re:US quits Paris climate pact by microcolonel on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:29PM (#14464278)
Pro: As sergiotapia mentioned, good for business because it is costly to comply. It may also not have ended up having much positive impact on the environment, there are people who can argue that for you.

Con: People who support the pact symbolically, not necessarily having any of the expertise or knowledge required to consider it, will go into a blind rage over it; actual climate scientists will be considerably more calm.