News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Weight Loss Trap by gragas on Sunday May 28, 2017 @10:17PM (#14437029)
I like to stick with the first law of thermodynamics. It's worked very well my entire life.
Re:The Weight Loss Trap by grzm on Sunday May 28, 2017 @10:28PM (#14437062)
Do you have something specific to the article to contribute? While as far as we know the laws of physics apply to human respiration, a general statement like this ignores at least endocrinology and amounts to trolling.
Re:The Weight Loss Trap by starchild3001 on Sunday May 28, 2017 @10:59PM (#14437146)
Human biology is complex. Reducing it to simple thermodynamics completely ignores factors like metabolism, psychology and microbiome.

Eating nutrient deficient/extremely tasty sweets (or junk food) has very different effects than eating nutrient dense/bland red meat or vegetables with the same calories.

Reductionism is counterproductive in this case. You should re-read the article. It describes a number of ways where human metabolism responds to calories and/or body weight in unexpected ways (hence the biology is 'complex').

Re:The Weight Loss Trap by Double_a_92 on Monday May 29, 2017 @02:15AM (#14437667)
The difference between junkfood and healthy food is the "calorie density". A big mac is 500kcal, but you are still hungry after eating one.
Re:The Weight Loss Trap by beagle3 on Monday May 29, 2017 @07:05AM (#14438511)
That's not the whole story.

Do this experiment: drink/eat fat, 38% sweet cream is probably the friendliest to the uninitiated, but butter, olive oil, coconut oil would also work.

It doesn't get more dense than pure fat (and only about 2.5 as much as 38%fat sweet cream), and you will NOT be hungry afterwards.

Re:The Weight Loss Trap by jjeaff on Monday May 29, 2017 @02:53AM (#14437795)
Again, an oversimplification. Different flavors, salt intake, even psychology can come into play in how your appetite is affected and how your body may react to what you just ate.
Re:The Weight Loss Trap by jjeaff on Monday May 29, 2017 @02:52AM (#14437790)
Dunnings Krueger much?

We have calories in down to a pretty good science (although more and more studies are finding very incorrect measuring going on). Good luck counting calories out. That's a rabbit hole of extreme complexity.

Re:The Weight Loss Trap by beagle3 on Monday May 29, 2017 @07:03AM (#14438508)
I agree with the DK reference, but I disagree that we have the "calories in" nailed down (and of course, calories out is completely out of the question).

For example, food temperature must (calorically) make some difference - e.g., if I drink a liter of 3 deg(celsius) water every day, and remain at 36 dec(celsius) myself, vs. if I drink a 43 deg(celsius) tea (and remain at same temp), the "in" is significantly difference (to the tune of 40kcal/liter between the extremes), whether you count it on in or out.

Furthermore, we don't even have carbs properly - depending on microbiome, undigestable fiber to you might be digestable to me, e.g. [0], and whether you eat digest papaya or carbon at the same time as other things can significantly change how much "calories in" the represent.

[0] http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2010/04/japanese-guts-are-mad...

Re:The Weight Loss Trap by jjeaff on Saturday June 10, 2017 @05:28PM (#14529285)
Yes, I left that part out of my answer just to keep from muddying the water even further.