Re:The Weight Loss Trap
by beagle3 on Monday May 29, 2017 @07:03AM
(#14438508)
I agree with the DK reference, but I disagree that we have the "calories in" nailed down (and of course, calories out is completely out of the question).
For example, food temperature must (calorically) make some difference - e.g., if I drink a liter of 3 deg(celsius) water every day, and remain at 36 dec(celsius) myself, vs. if I drink a 43 deg(celsius) tea (and remain at same temp), the "in" is significantly difference (to the tune of 40kcal/liter between the extremes), whether you count it on in or out.
Furthermore, we don't even have carbs properly - depending on microbiome, undigestable fiber to you might be digestable to me, e.g. [0], and whether you eat digest papaya or carbon at the same time as other things can significantly change how much "calories in" the represent.
For example, food temperature must (calorically) make some difference - e.g., if I drink a liter of 3 deg(celsius) water every day, and remain at 36 dec(celsius) myself, vs. if I drink a 43 deg(celsius) tea (and remain at same temp), the "in" is significantly difference (to the tune of 40kcal/liter between the extremes), whether you count it on in or out.
Furthermore, we don't even have carbs properly - depending on microbiome, undigestable fiber to you might be digestable to me, e.g. [0], and whether you eat digest papaya or carbon at the same time as other things can significantly change how much "calories in" the represent.
[0] http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2010/04/japanese-guts-are-mad...