News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by petertodd on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:38PM (#14431276)
Propaganda? Your 30 minute old account sounds like propaganda too.

We all know we could reduce crime by putting cameras in people's homes. But we don't do that, because there are risks to those kinds of invasive measures.

Aadhar is infrastructure that allows for centralized control of the population. Sometimes that control will be used for good things, like stamping out bribery. But that control can just as easily be used for evil too. And history has shown time and time again that's exactly what happens. I live in Canada, a country filled with refugees of authoritarian regimes. Among my friends I personally know lots of people who have fled those kinds of regimes; I know very few people who have fled countries because of bribery. The latter is annoying and unproductive, but the former is deadly.

That's why you're seeing so much opposition to Aadhar: because it's incredibly dangerous.

edit: better wording

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by derefr on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:13PM (#14431472)
Police forces can be deadly, too; and the alternative to them usually isn't (it's mostly "just" fraud, armed robbery, rape and slave trafficking.) But we prefer to risk authorizing some people to carry deadly weapons around—even knowing it can and does turn out badly sometimes—in order to reduce the prevalence of the things we get from lawlessness.

Aadhar isn't risk-free, but if the majority of the country want it (i.e. if, being informed of the possible consequences, they aren't rioting or impeaching the guy extending it), I feel like that's their choice to make, just like the choice of having police would be.

Also: One of the things about our modern, globalized world, is that any state that's not a military superpower in its own right can't really get away with bootstrapping toward totalitarian autocracy for very long before some concerned state that is a military superpower steps in with a foreign-aided coup. I'm not asserting that that is always a good thing for the world—but, sort of like the "re-insurance" companies backing financial institutions, this arrangement allows smaller states to do "risky" things like using a panopticon to destroy corruption, with a bit of a safety net.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by petertodd on Saturday May 27, 2017 @04:45PM (#14431882)
> But we prefer to risk authorizing some people to carry deadly weapons around—even knowing it can and does turn out badly sometimes—in order to reduce the prevalence of the things we get from lawlessness.

Yes, and we can get away with that because deadly weapons have an important safety feature: they're operated by individuals who can think for themselves, and themselves resist tyranny. Those weapons are also operated by individuals who are vulnerable to individuals who also have those weapons - notably an argument against drones is they make war too easy, without enough consequences against the agressor.

When those deadly weapons become more powerful - and more likely to be used against civilians rather than military - society is less and less accepting of their existance. That's why biological and chemical weapons are banned, and nuclear weapons are heavily discouraged.

Imagine if we had the ultimate deadly weapon - the ability to kill any individual with a push of the button with 100% success rates, with the owner of that weapon not being vulnerable to it. We'd be terrified of that weapon, because for all the good it might be able to do, in the wrong hands it'd be game over for freedom.

The opposition to Aadhaar simply recognizes that for whatever good it can do, it is a dangerous weapon, one with surprising power. Part of its surprising power is that it gets used to argue for implementation in other states - fighting that weapon needs to start not by arguing against it in your own country, but by arguing against its deployment anywhere.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:34PM (#14431585)
> Aadhar isn't risk-free, but if the majority of the country want it

Thank you for soberly defending the program. I disagree with one of your precedents (specifically, that Indians are informed about the risks they're taking) but agree with your logic.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by petertodd on Saturday May 27, 2017 @05:08PM (#14431991)
FWIW I mostly agree with the logic itself too, and I think it's a much better and more honest argument than failing to treat such surveillance systems as dangerous. My disagreement is on the tradeoffs.
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by splintercell on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:59PM (#14431393)
> We all know we could reduce crime by putting cameras in people's homes. But we don't do that, because there are risks to those kinds of invasive measures.

Surprisingly, in India if people would be against such a measure then only because it would violate the modesty of women, and not because it invades the privacy.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by realonedev on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:02PM (#14431406)
Refer,

https://thewire.in/24713/aadhaar-identification-simplified-m...

The UIDAI has emphasised several times that information related to religion or caste is neither collected nor stored in the Aadhaar database. Applicants and holders are encouraged to look at their Aadhaar to confirm this

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by splintercell on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:09PM (#14431448)
Give me a list of 1000 Indian names and I can guess their religion with nearly 95% accuracy.

All the points you say sound like you're 'prepared' or 'rehearsed' to say things like this.

When the next Gujarat riots happen, trust me just a list of people and their addresses would be sufficient enough to figure out where all the Muslims live.

[dead]
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by splintercell on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:53PM (#14431675)
> And, Godhra Train was burned by 2000 Muslims surrounding a train and burning people with nothing to escape.

> Next time before mentioning Godhra and Muslims in same sentence don't forget to mention what 2000 Muslims did to unarmed people in train by locking the train compartment.

None of these things matter. Lets say that 10 people committed a crime in broad daylight in front of hundreds of people, then they hid in some houses, and goons who have the backing of the govt then used the Adhaar database to single out all the community members of the same community as the culprits, found them and lynched them.

Even then, nothing changes the fact that dilution of civil liberties happened by the Adhaar card, as article linked claims.

> 95% of the stats are made on the spot, like you made above.

That's not a 'stat', it's my confidence level on my ability to judge these things.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by realonedev on Saturday May 27, 2017 @04:12PM (#14431754)
You are unable to back up your claims by verifiable data source and quantifiable data points.

Can you get the caste of a person by reading the Aadhar number ?

Answer is No.

If you or your relatives had not lost bribe money due to the Direct Benefit scheme, then I cannot understand the blatant hate of Aadhar.

Otherwise, I hope that neither you nor your immediate family members were accumulating wealth by being corrupt or being the actual middleman themselves.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by intended on Sunday May 28, 2017 @09:26AM (#14434302)
The answer is yes

After the change in 2016, aadhar no longer gives only a confirmation/negation, it also provides demographic information aka full name, and address + a few more features.

Surnames are highly distinctive especially when combined with address data, so yes Aadhar now will provide you with enough information to assess caste.

Furthermore - since when do mobs and angry people worry about 100% accuracy. In the throes of emotion, close enough is good enough.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by splintercell on Saturday May 27, 2017 @05:23PM (#14432035)
> Can you get the caste of a person by reading the Aadhar number ?

Are you saying that government does not have any information associated with the Aadhar number? You're straw manning really badly. The whole argument, nearly every single person in this thread, making against you is that Aadhar is dystopian. But your argument is "But you can't figure out a person's info by just reading the Aadhar number".

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by narrowrail on Saturday May 27, 2017 @07:10PM (#14432358)
As an American (born and raised), this whole discussion is fascinating and is similar to the 'Obamacare' debate here. All of the Indians I've known in the US corroborate your claim about knowing one's religion/ heritage by last name alone. I hope the discussion can remain civil, but there does seem to be an agenda among some participants.
[dead]
Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by dang on Saturday May 27, 2017 @09:15PM (#14432682)
We've banned this account for breaking the HN guidelines. Creating an account and immediately getting into a flamewar is not an acceptable way to use this site. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and promise to follow the rules when commenting here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by JumpCrisscross on Saturday May 27, 2017 @03:28PM (#14431562)
> Can you read at all?...It's not that hard.

Please refrain from personal insults. We're trying to understand something together. Name calling doesn't promote that goal.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by realonedev on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:48PM (#14431325)
Propaganda? Your 30 minute old account sounds

Do you know the difference between a reader and writer ?

Please Google the difference.

Not every reader on hn for over 5 years needs to have an account.

And, not every old account need not contribute anything useful to the discussion.

Good Day.

Re:Aadhaar isn’t progress – it’s dystopian and dangerous by it_learnses on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:53PM (#14431349)
you didn't address his main points though.