News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by metalliqaz on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:13PM (#14419016)
I'd be more eager to cast scorn if I could find a company that hasn't skirted the law.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by cptskippy on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:25PM (#14419088)
So now we can't castigate lawbreakers until we can prove someone actually adheres to the law?
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by stupidhn on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:37PM (#14419565)
>So now we can't castigate lawbreakers until we can prove someone actually adheres to the law?

No, but we could at least hold out on castigation until it's proven they've broken the law. A class action lawsuit isn't proof of anything.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by chc on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:19PM (#14419052)
AFAIK none of the Japanese companies have messed around with emissions laws, and obviously Tesla wouldn't even need to.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by Chaebixi on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:24PM (#14419085)
Mitsubishi cheated on fuel efficiency tests.

http://money.cnn.com/2016/04/26/news/companies/mitsubishi-ch...:

> The automaker said last week that it had used improper fuel economy tests on hundreds of thousands of vehicles, including some sold to Nissan

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:21PM (#14419065)
That means that GM is no better than Volkswagen. It doesn't mean that they're good, though. What they did is still just as wrong, no matter how many other companies did it too.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by jerf on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:12PM (#14419381)
For a while now, I've been beating the drum on HN that if you keep raising regulations on the car companies faster than they can develop technology for, we will eventually reach the point where it will be economically impossible to build a car.

This story suggests a possibility I hadn't considered yet, which is that it may already be economically impossible to build a car that complies with the law.

At this point, while you are welcome to castigate the automakers for cheating, one must also consider that the authors of the regulation may bear some responsibility here too.

And I do mean both bear some responsibility; the cheating of the car companies has prevented the feedback from getting to the regulators that they've created an impossible situation. But they may still have created an impossible solution, and it may mean that people just going "Well just comply with the regulations then!" are proposing a non-solution to the problem without realizing it.

It is also worth pointing out that three years ago the idea that regulations were already impossible to comply with would have been met with hoots of derision, and probably someone is going to reply to me to dismiss it even now. We're asking auto companies here to forfeit billions of dollars, but the regulators themselves have no risk if they are creating an impossible situation.

Just because someone wrote a regulation somewhere doesn't mean it's good, or possible, or economical.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:33PM (#14419529)
> ... it may already be economically impossible to build a car that complies with the law.

I have no hard data, but my suspicion is that it is not economically impossible in any absolute sense. That is, it is possible to create cars that meet the standard, that can be sold to consumers at a price that allows them to be built. They may have lower power than customers desire, but what else are they going to do? Walk?

What is probably not possible is to do that when they have to compete against cars that only pretend to meet the standard. The cars that only pretend will cost less, or have more performance. If the buyer compares a car that meets the regulation and one that only pretends to, the one that only pretends to is a more desirable car, and will get the sale.

> Just because someone wrote a regulation somewhere doesn't mean it's good, or possible, or economical.

Yup. That's true of regulations on more than just cars, too.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by sqeaky on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:59PM (#14419723)
What if the goal is to regulate diesel out of existence unless it can be much better pollution-wise?

What if the car companies could make a much cleaner diesel engine, but it just wasn't cost efficient?

What if this kind of regulation is the stick to go with the various green regulation carrots (tax credits on fuel efficient vehicles, subsidies for renewables, etc...)?

What if making lawmakers responsible for legislating something out of business has unintended effects? Consider that in some places tobacco companies are suing governments over labeling, imagine the lawsuits if a car company could sue when they didn't like emission laws.

I agree it is easy to look at this with a sympathetic eye to automakers, but I think we cannot condone cheating when other alternatives exists. It may well be impossible to build a clean enough diesel engine. If so we should drop diesel and figure out something with another energy store

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by linkregister on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:33PM (#14419527)
Theoretically, your position could be true.

Empirically, VW released patches for their cars to bring the non-test characteristics in line with their test-mode characteristics.

The outcome was that the diesel-engine vehicles had reduced fuel economy and acceleration. [1]

Most customers still enjoyed their cars after the patch was applied.

1. http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/cars/guide-to-the-volkswa...

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:36PM (#14419552)
In a parallel post, I just agreed with you. But jerf's position may be closer to correct than you suspect, because fuel economy is also part of the regulations. Well, you can meet both if you make the car lighter. But collision resistance is also part of the regulations. And so on...

Did the patched cars also meet mileage standards? How close to the limit were they? (Or are there no mileage standards for diesels?)

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by linkregister on Thursday May 25, 2017 @04:17PM (#14419819)
1. Again, theoretically there will be a limit where these will converge for diesel and petrol vehicles. At that point, I predict that EVs, hybrids, and fuel cell vehicles will offset the overall requirements.

2. Collision resistance has improved as weight has decreased.

3. Did they meet mileage standards? Maybe. Probably. 46mpg (the resultant fuel economy after the patch) appears to be outstanding even for diesel vehicles. Mileage is imposed on individual models by year targets and also manufacturer-wide. That is why cars in general are sold with much lower margins: to help manufacturers offset the poor fuel economy and emissions of larger vehicles.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by InitialLastName on Thursday May 25, 2017 @05:50PM (#14420411)
> For a while now, I've been beating the drum on HN that if you keep raising regulations on the car companies faster than they can develop technology for, we will eventually reach the point where it will be economically impossible to build a car.

We can only dream that we will eventually reach the point where cars cost enough to offset their cost to society.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by zaroth on Thursday May 25, 2017 @08:58PM (#14421357)
I'm pretty sure US GDP wouldn't look so great the day after you take all the cars and trucks off the roads.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by InitialLastName on Friday May 26, 2017 @08:17AM (#14423511)
It would be better if it happened over more than one day and incompletely. Sometimes, though, facing reality hurts a little.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by widowlark on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:18PM (#14419043)
It's not that I'm surprised, I just wish it was better
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by simonsarris on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:18PM (#14419048)
Well, there's always Tesla.

All the more reason to consider EVs a moral good.

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by CalRobert on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:41PM (#14419192)
Reducing the marginal cost of driving in terms of cash (fuel) and time (self-driving) may have second and third order effects which are deeply problematic. I like EV's, but we're foolish to think that making driving effectively free won't have downsides.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by ghaff on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:31PM (#14419517)
EVs also don't make driving "effectively free." We don't really have a good handle on the long-term maintenance costs associated with EVs but even the electricity itself (at residential power rates) is about 1/3 to 1/2 of gasoline costs in the US. A substantial savings but not free.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by ATsch on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:21PM (#14419063)
Well, last I remember Telsa violates the GPL
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by mohaine on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:13PM (#14419382)
Source?
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by ATsch on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:39PM (#14419570)
Well, we don't have it sadly.

Jokes aside, there is no "offical" source for my claim. But the fact that they use a linux based system yet have no place to download it is all the evidence you need really. You can find a number of people detailing their (unsucessful) GPL requests in forum posts etc. by searching for "tesla gpl" or "tesla gpl violation"

Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by foldor on Thursday May 25, 2017 @03:36PM (#14419547)
I would assume since they're violating the GPL that there is no source, and that's the issue.
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by awqrre on Thursday May 25, 2017 @04:28PM (#14419914)
Do you include manufacturing environmental costs of their batteries and the environmental costs of the energy they consume that is produced by someone else?
Re:GM accused of installing devices in diesel trucks to beat... by PhasmaFelis on Thursday May 25, 2017 @02:43PM (#14419209)
I'm okay with scorning every one of them, actually.