News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by cryodesign on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @03:47AM (#14399589)
Some good tips and a good reminder not to overload the user with information, especially on mobile.

However, trying to give this pattern a new name feels a bit disingenuous - it comes across as self promotional (even if unintended).

This is a well established pattern already and it's known as a Wizard - guiding users, chunking information, etc -- IBM talked about this back in 2001 [0]

And they wrote a 400 page book about this called Designing Effective Wizards [1]

I see this quite often in our industry, people trying to coin a new name for something when one already exists.

Please don't.

Give credit where credit is due or at least acknowledge people who researched it before.

/rant over

[0] https://www.ibm.com/developerworks/library/us-wizard/

[1] https://www.amazon.com/Designing-Effective-Wizards-IBM-books...

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by untilHellbanned on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @04:24AM (#14399743)
They likely don't know of the prior art. In fairness "one thing per page" isn't a very literature searchable topic and many people have trouble finding good search terms to uncover all the relevant prior art. "Wizard" doesn't intuitively scream out "one thing per page".

I have no idea how prominent IBM wizards are in the design literature, but I'm a scientist and I can speak to the challenges of finding relevant literature when all you have is what search terms makes sense to you.

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by cryodesign on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @04:39AM (#14399794)
Wizards are quite well known if you're working in software and design.

Here is another book that mentions it (2011) http://designinginterfaces.com/patterns/wizard/

And some other examples of the term being used:

http://patternry.com/p=multiple-page-wizard/

http://ui-patterns.com/patterns/Wizard

https://storify.com/kaniasty/how-to-design-a-wizard

The author worked in the industry for at least 10 years and not coming across this well established pattern seems unlikely, hence why it felt a bit self-promotional.

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by Nition on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:32AM (#14399972)
The "Wizard" idea is pretty old too. Microsoft Works had document "wizards" (complete with little picture of a wizard) in the 90s. "Install Wizards" were also common already then.
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by matt4077 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @06:13AM (#14400098)
Funny to see Jennifer Tidwell's Designing Interfaces mentioned here. It's an excellent resource–not just for its specific content, but also in the problem/pattern system is uses. (and it's an excellent antidote against the common believe that designers just care about making things 'pretty' and have no understanding of data or technology)
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by naasking on Thursday May 25, 2017 @04:08PM (#14419772)
> They likely don't know of the prior art.

Anyone who's ever installed software on Windows has seen a wizard in action. I think "wizard" is actually in the titlebar in many of them, since these are often autogenerated.

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by throwanem on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @06:13AM (#14400099)
"Wizard" sounds very Windows 95. It wouldn't surprise me to see someone who knows the history very well still trying to rebrand it - I wouldn't want to try to sell it under that name, either, not least because "wizards" in most consumer OSes have a longstanding reputation of not working all that well. And everything old is new again, etc.

(Actually, I have sold it not under that name! Back in 2011, breaking up a gigantic and incomprehensible triathlon registration form into topic-specific sections, presented one at a time with a next/previous flow and a review at the end before submitting. I didn't call it anything much, since it was a one-off and something of a desperation play, but it went over very well indeed, so that was nice. I sure as hell didn't call it a wizard!)

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by alkonaut on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:57AM (#14401191)
Because everyone loved to hate on the wizards in the 00's, people reinvented them and just gave them different names. It's still a wizard.
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by albedoa on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:21AM (#14401383)
To be fair, they were hated because a bad experience became expected. Many wizards were painful, were unclear about what was happening or about which options could be changed later, either didn't provide a method of moving non-linearly or erased your progress if you did, etc. Not to mention the dark patterns sneakily installing toolbars and whatnot.

I agree both with the parent comment as well as the sibling comment that absolves anyone from wanting to stay unassociated with that word.

Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by raarts on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @03:13PM (#14404268)
Most wizards were just annoying pop-ups which made you click on Next for a few times to get you where you wanted to be.
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by adambsilver on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @07:28AM (#14400343)
Thanks for sharing those resources. Will have a read.
Re:Better Form Design: One Thing per Page by jasonkostempski on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @08:34AM (#14400643)
ODK Collect has had it for a long time too.