News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by squeaky-clean on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:48PM (#14396393)
There are no secrets in the bathroom analogy. We all know what you're doing in there (or have a 50% chance at guessing). But you still want privacy.
Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by hammock on Monday May 22, 2017 @06:25PM (#14397375)
Nobody gets it...

He said you can have privacy without secrets. But suppose there exists a room with a door where you don't know what someone is doing behind it. The activity behind the door is the secret. The door is still representing privacy (not secrecy). That was the point of the analogy.

Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by unabst on Monday May 22, 2017 @07:05PM (#14397570)
You're adding an element of your own subjective knowledge/awareness. You could not know a secret or something kept private. The only thing that is the same is your not knowing. What you don't know could still be a secret, something private, or even public knowledge for that matter. The point is, you not knowing doesn't make anything anything.

A secret is an attribution to the contents of a description which are withheld for security reasons. Or at least, that's what it should be. And that's what it appears to be with the military.

Privacy is a right to withhold information based on a fair desire to not have that information be known.

Invasion of privacy is someone pulling the curtains when you're showering or opening the door when you're in the bathroom.

That should not be confused with invasion of secrecy.

Either way, the main point is that these two terms are confusing, and even the law confuses them. And yes, people would consider something they don't know a secret also, and your use of the word is intuitively correct. But a clearer distinction could and should exist, and we should all work towards that clearer distinction. I believe the words are already more than adequate, since we already see the correct (most practical and fitting) distinctions used where they are most needed in practice (military).

Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by Chris2048 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @07:19AM (#14400321)
There are known-unknowns, and unknown-unknowns :-)
Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by baloneyman on Monday May 22, 2017 @06:25PM (#14397372)
The point they are trying to prove is that there is no way of knowing what happens in the bathroom. It is theoretically equivalent to secrecy
Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by coldtea on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:36AM (#14399022)
In the real world, though, 99% of the time, we DO know. And even if we don't know exactly, we can narrow it very closely. We either shit, take a bath, masturebate or whatever. We still want privacy of any of those things.
Re:Get your loved ones off Facebook by sankyo on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:59PM (#14398274)
We found scorched tinfoil in the wastebasket. Someone has secrets and is not covering up.