News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Sunday May 21, 2017 @09:13PM (#14390263)
I'm going to sound like a broken record here but there are policy and other decisions being made in the Bay Area that are restricting the housing supply and driving up the price of existing housing. You don't have to be a bystander in this process, you can help lobby for more supply.

A list of propositions and legislation to support (SF, Brisbane, Mountain View, the CA state legislature) can be found here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14195301

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jrapdx3 on Sunday May 21, 2017 @10:35PM (#14390593)
The question I have has several parts, but fundamentally I wonder if the housing supply could even be increased enough to materially affect housing prices.

Not saying that the housing supply isn't excessively restricted, but how much can restrictions be decreased and how much difference would it make?

An analogy is building freeways to relieve traffic congestion. What regularly happens is that additional roads or adding lanes to existing roads provides temporary respite from traffic jams. But before too long the roads are jam-packed again, the problem isn't solved, just have more cars clogging traffic.

I suspect adding more housing won't lower housing prices, just bring some more people into the area. BTW this is what's happening here in Portland OR, where a building boom has been going on for years. The area population has increased, housing prices are still out of range for many people.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:00PM (#14390696)
> fundamentally I wonder if the housing supply could even be increased enough to materially affect housing prices.

Yes, it can; SF built 5,000 units last year, a record, and rents and owner move-in evictions finally declined. At the very least, building more housing can prevent further large price rises.

> BTW this is what's happening here in Portland OR, where a building boom has been going on for years. The area population has increased, housing prices are still out of range for many people.

The question is what would happen if you didn't build the housing. I contend that the people moving in would outbid everyone for the existing housing stock, which would drive rent increases even more than rents are currently going up. It may be that the new housing is just keeping things at a base level.

Flipped on its head the logic here doesn't really make sense; destroying existing housing stock would be disastrous for rents and prices, it makes sense that building more would help prevent increases.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by timthelion on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:14AM (#14391844)
In eastern europe, we have Paneláky <https://www.google.cz/search?q=sidli%C5%A1t%C4%9B&source=lnm... and the housing prices are low in the panel houses and much higher everywhere else (though no-where nere US levels). You can even buy an apartment in a panel house an hour and a halfs drive outside of prague for $5000USD https://www.sreality.cz/hledani/prodej/byty/ustecky-kraj,lib...
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by mattmanser on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:21AM (#14392115)
In Europe and the US a lot of these were built too.

A lot of them are now being torn down.

I'm not an authority on why, but I believe they tended to be crime and drug hot spots. I have also read of various health problems being associated with them (both physical + mental).

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by zaccus on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @02:37PM (#14403917)
Buildings like that in the US tend to be housing projects, where people are less likely to have a sense of ownership. Not exactly apples to apples.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by timthelion on Thursday May 25, 2017 @07:18AM (#14416596)
There was also a technical issue, caused by the fact that in the US, many of the buildings had windows which could not be opened. People didn't like that.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by literallycancer on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:19AM (#14392106)
I suspect that people aren't talking about 1.5 hour one way commute when they say that rents are too high.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by expertentipp on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:50AM (#14392232)
> panel house an hour and a halfs drive outside of prague for $5000USD https://www.sreality.cz/hledani/prodej/byty/ustecky-kraj,lib....

From the photos alone I can smell the odor of alcohol and feel the depression and suicide looming in the air.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by timthelion on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:54PM (#14397238)
Oh don't be silly. US is 48th on list of countries by suicide rate. Czech Republic is 83rd.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_r...

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by expertentipp on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:11AM (#14398943)
Czechia is an exception in this part of Europe, Poles/Lithuanians are more likely to have this "problem".
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jrapdx3 on Monday May 22, 2017 @02:49AM (#14391489)
You might be right, possibly housing prices could be higher. If in fact prices have stabilized or leveled out (it's sure hard to get up to date info of that kind), it suggests there's an equilibrium between increasing population and housing availability. The more housing the higher the population will go for any particular average housing price point. Simplistically, price = population/amount of housing.

I think an issue is building new housing attracts an influx of population up to the point that housing is not too expensive, keeping the average price point about the same. Conversely, outflux of population would cause prices to plummet, which has happened in the past during recessions and high unemployment. In effect, housing stocks then are reduced by being removed from the market, but that's not exactly healthy for the community either.

> I contend that the people moving in would outbid everyone for the existing housing stock, which would drive rent increases even more than rents are currently going up.

That's possible, but unless people moving in are much wealthier than the people already there, the price could only rise a certain amount before no one could afford it and sales would fall off. That's similar to certain (expensive) condo prices around here, but still seems there's a ceiling effect.

Your comment inspires me to talk with some real estate folks I know, it's been a while since getting their perspective on the market.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:27AM (#14392134)
> building new housing attracts an influx of population

You got this backwards: we build housing for the influx of population. People don't move to new places just to get a new house. They move for economic reasons, like they got a $150k software dev job in SF & don't want to commute 90 minutes each way, or they got evicted so the landlord could double/triple the rent.

Regardless of whether SF builds now housing stock or not, the population influx is already happening and has been happening for the last 10 years. The issue is, new, wealthier residents are pulling the market up and forcing existing, lower-income residents out to the periphery of the Bay Area.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by chii on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:38AM (#14392179)
> forcing existing, lower-income residents out to the periphery of the Bay Area.

but this should drive those who receive low income out of state, and thus lower the amount of worker available for low-income jobs, which in turn should drive up the wage?

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by tbihl on Monday May 22, 2017 @06:53AM (#14392445)
That assumes an underdamped system (and I'd be really interested to know if that feedback is generally considered underdamped). In the end, can't we agree that things would stabilize or nearly stabilize in the appropriate equilibrium?

On another note, I (as a visitor) always figured the most visible effect of the dearth of affordable housing was the ridiculously early time the city shuts down. Madrid is the city I've spent the most time in, and there SF shutdown time would be right in the middle of, or before, dinner! I just figured that the early closing time facilitates closing up, cleaning, and getting home before the transit shuts down since no one working in restaurants or nightlife could afford to live in the city. I'm sure I'm not the first one to suggest that: is that theory generally discounted/disproven?

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by ghaff on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:14AM (#14392904)
I'm not sure I see the correlation. US cities in general start rolling up the sidewalks earlier than is often the case in Europe. Dinner times in particular tend to be earlier. 7pm is a fairly typical peak sitting time.

As a counter-example, Manhattan is an atypically late night city for the US [that also has very high housing prices]. You could argue that it also has 24 hour mass transit to cheaper areas. But, in general, tons of US cities that shutdown fairly early have low housing prices.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:46AM (#14393484)
If you work in the Financial District and live in Pittsburgh, then you have to be on BART no later than 10:30pm to get home. Assuming a 45min clean-up and some slow diners keeping the floor occupied until 9:30, I would arrange for a 9pm closing time.

With the same situation, but a 30 minute commute and a 24h transport system and staff happy to get home around the same time, you could set the closing time at 10:30-11pm.

> tons of US cities that shutdown fairly early have low housing prices

Ah, are they low-density? I have lived places with very fast commutes and low property prices that would shut down by 7pm, since it was deep in the country and thus there was stuff-all foot traffic once people stopped working.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by tbihl on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:29AM (#14401455)
Agreed that Europe is a bad basis for comparison; it's only what I had, not what I would prefer to use.

I can't substantiate this, but it seems that there is a small number of US cities where it is difficult to have cars, and easy enough to use transit, that driving is prohibitive for people in these low-paying jobs. I say this having grown up in a rural area where having many cars around a home was a reliable sign of poverty, not wealth. In most US cities the amount of cheap or free parking is staggering.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:48AM (#14392223)
California is big, and moving costs can trap people in places they can barely afford. Fronting up the $600 to rent a U-Haul & take it to Nebraska can be a mammoth challenge. Plus, they need a job at the other end.

It's more likely that they would move to unregulated housing or live on the streets.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by corvallis on Monday May 22, 2017 @10:03AM (#14393613)
Please check your comment about BART schedules. BART guarantees a ride to your destination from any point in the system if you get into a station by midnight. The last train from Embarcadero station to Pittsburg leaves Embarcadero at 12:26 AM.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @11:25AM (#14394328)
I don't fancy getting home at 2am.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by corvallis on Monday May 22, 2017 @12:36PM (#14394961)
That's nice, but you were commenting on workers who would potentially need BART to get home after being released from work at a late hour. We are able to do so.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:10PM (#14396116)
Oh, I based my times assuming that people didn't live at the BART & needed to catch a bus connection… but I guess driving is relatively pleasant once you get away from the city & thus you can use a car instead.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by saosebastiao on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:17PM (#14390772)
If you consider the fact that developers have been building at near peak-Dubai paces in Seattle for salable prices that are much lower than the bay area, I'd say you're worried about nothing of consequence. If you merely let them, they'll build until they can't cover their costs.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jrapdx3 on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:01AM (#14391538)
I don't have the data at my fingertips, but IIRC Seattle housing prices were historically lower than SF, but higher than Portland OR. I think that could make it hard to assess the effects of bringing more housing on line in Seattle, at least comparing to SF would be misleading. However the history of housing costs in Seattle might be informative.

> If you merely let them, they'll build until they can't cover their costs.

The problem in the building industry is that financial commitments are made years in advance, meaning even if things are in a slump, units may be built anyway because the project was on track to happen well before the slump came about. It's also occurred that units are constructed just before a slump hits and as a result the completed units sit empty, the developer goes bankrupt, etc. Overbuilding can and does happen and it can take many years, even decades for a property to finally break even.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by quanticle on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:25AM (#14392127)
>The problem in the building industry is that financial commitments are made years in advance

>Overbuilding can and does happen and it can take many years, even decades for a property to finally break even.

And in that, the building industry is no different from airlines, oil refineries, auto makers, chip fabs or any other capital intensive industry. Why should we privilege the building industry over the others?

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by saosebastiao on Monday May 22, 2017 @10:01AM (#14393601)
> I don't have the data at my fingertips, but IIRC Seattle housing prices were historically lower than SF, but higher than Portland OR. I think that could make it hard to assess the effects of bringing more housing on line in Seattle, at least comparing to SF would be misleading. However the history of housing costs in Seattle might be informative.

Not sure why you think historical prices matter one bit. Seattle is proof that you don't need San Francisco prices to continue building. Developers from LA and SF can and regularly do build in Seattle where prices are lower but regulation is less obtuse, and many times they end up using Californian general contractors who prefer higher utilization over higher rates with more downtime.

> The problem in the building industry is that financial commitments are made years in advance, meaning even if things are in a slump, units may be built anyway because the project was on track to happen well before the slump came about. It's also occurred that units are constructed just before a slump hits and as a result the completed units sit empty, the developer goes bankrupt, etc. Overbuilding can and does happen and it can take many years, even decades for a property to finally break even.

Overbuilding may occur, but units don't sit empty. They always end up renting out, until the rent is so low that they can't cover variable costs like maintenance. If the rents aren't high enough to cover debt servicing, they'll still rent out...the owner will go bankrupt, they'll lose the property and the lender will take a loss, but the property will be sold by the courts at a price where someone can make money off the current rents.

Despite what you may think, developers will continue developing if prices move downward. Downward price movements primarily impact landowners and lenders, not developers. If developers see downward price movements, they start bidding less on land.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by rcpt on Monday May 22, 2017 @12:18AM (#14390961)
> building at near peak-Dubai paces in Seattle

I'm curious about this - do you have some data? Not that I doubt it's true, I'm simply interested in how one would quantify this kinda thing.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jld on Monday May 22, 2017 @02:01AM (#14391316)
I can't speak to the Dubai comparison, but Seattle is bringing 10,000 apartments online this year.

http://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattles-re...

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by mcv on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:20AM (#14392111)
Does that count as near-Dubai speed? Amsterdam is building 50,000 appartments over the next 10 years, and that's considered not enough. But there's simply no space to grow here. These are the last few empty corners of the city being filled in.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by mattmanser on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:29AM (#14392146)
But 50,000 / 10 = 5,000 per year, half the rate?
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by mcv on Monday May 22, 2017 @10:27AM (#14393805)
Yeah, but still same order of magnitude. I would have expected near-Dubai speed to be more than that.

Though admittedly Seattle is smaller than Amsterdam. I expected it to be bigger (because Amsterdam isn't all that big).

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by chronic940 on Monday May 22, 2017 @06:42AM (#14392407)
Lol
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by scythe on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:43PM (#14390865)
In order to increase the housing supply "significantly", you need to increase zoning limits in >10% of the relevant population-weighted land area. However balkanization makes it impossible to do this through a single political entity.

The solution IMO is a "trigger" law that will increase zoning heights in a suburb when the nearby suburbs pass similar laws. This prevents any one town from becoming gentrified if they raise their growth rate above the regional norm.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Monday May 22, 2017 @12:08AM (#14390929)
The biggest impediment to building in CA isn't zoning laws; most areas are zoned for way more density than they are built to.

As an example, Habitat for Humanity wants to build 6 stories of below-market-rate condos in Redwood City, which complies with zoning codes, but are being opposed by a lawyer who lives on the block, because it's "out of character" with the other buildings in the neighborhood.

It's a byzantine approval process that includes City Councils who are 100% responsible for local housing decisions, and are elected and responsible only to current city residents. Zealous Planning Commission boards who consider things like shadows and wind when making decisions, EIR (environmental impact report) appeals, CEQA lawsuits, a constitutional housing amendment (Prop 13) that incentivizes existing homeowners to oppose new development, and more...

(It help if more areas were upzoned, but it's not the reason by any stretch)

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by literallycancer on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:28AM (#14392138)
>Zealous Planning Commission boards who consider things like shadows and wind when making decisions, EIR (environmental impact report) appeals, CEQA lawsuits, a constitutional housing amendment (Prop 13) that incentivizes existing homeowners to oppose new development, and more...

On the other hand, you don't want to end up with this[1], so considering things like shadows and/or view obstruction has some merits.

1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vera_Coking#/media/File:View_o...

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jrapdx3 on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:15AM (#14391606)
Portland is unique among similar cities in that large tracts of undeveloped land became available for housing construction in the last several years. That means thousands of units will be available in the near future, in addition to the large number recently added to the inventory in the metro area. I'm guessing that would well exceed the 10% zoning limit increase you mention.

I haven't checked housing costs recently, but anecdotal data (from people looking for apartments, etc.) is that prices are still through the roof (so to speak). It could be prices will decline later this year or into next year, but pretty soon the supply of new housing will cease to increase so rapidly.

It remains to be seen what happens to housing costs. I could be all wrong, but I'll predict there won't be a significant decrease despite the rapid pace of development.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by scythe on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:34PM (#14396300)
Portland is the cheapest city of its size on the West Coast excepting possibly Sacramento (which exports its richest people to Tahoe/Napa/SF). If you ask me the reason people there complain about costs is that the wages aren't high and it used to be even cheaper.

I had a friend a few years ago who -- unemployed -- drove across the country to Portland, took a job fixing inventory at a music store, and got a room within walking distance of the train. Try pulling that off in the Bay Area!

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by nitrogen on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:00PM (#14390694)
But before too long the roads are jam-packed again, the problem isn't solved, just have more cars clogging traffic.

Isn't that a good thing, indicating greater economic activity?

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:06PM (#14390725)
It's a well known feature of transportation planning that traffic expands to fill available road space: http://www.culturechange.org/issue8/traffic%20expands.htm

The argument is, if the traffic is just going to expand to fill the new roads we build, then why not build more densely instead and help people have shorter commutes. Also some arguments around vicious cycles of building more roads, leading to more traffic, leading to demand for more, bigger roads, etc, vs. supporting biking/walking/public transit

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by CuriouslyC on Monday May 22, 2017 @07:55AM (#14392796)
The problem with density is that it assumes that housing will be efficiently allocated so it reduces people's need to commute. Unfortunately there are a lot of other factors involved and density in some cases ends up making traffic worse.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jeffbax on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @09:29PM (#14414718)
Supply is the only way to get out of the problem facing US cities today, and it's entirely a regulatory problem:

http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2016/08/lai...

http://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2017/05/the-nimby-challen...

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by aaron695 on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:48AM (#14393100)
> What regularly happens is that additional roads or adding lanes to existing roads provides temporary respite from traffic jams. But before too long the roads are jam-packed again, the problem isn't solved, just have more cars clogging traffic.

I've never seen proof of this, do you have any studies?

I know it's blah blahs law which I can't remember but outside of academia I never see a real world case.

If you just mean they fill again from growth well that makes sense. Without building them they would be even worse.

I've never see a cited case where improving infrastructure makes everyone worse off.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by ghaff on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:53AM (#14393125)
There are some references in the Wikipedia article on Induced Demand. Most of the cited cases deal with heavily trafficked roads being removed and demand decreasing as a result.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by aaron695 on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:32AM (#14393394)
That's it.

I find the examples on wiki a little sketchy and some are flat out anecdotal.

I do agree it will increase the total traffic as you improve the system but the concept it can ever make it worse or the same in the entire system doesn't make sense.

Peoples need to travel by car is not totally fluid. Jobs stay the same and many people catch public transport for reasons other than convenience.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by ghaff on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:55AM (#14393552)
I'm not sure I've heard the claim that adding capacity actually makes traffic worse other things being equal. It's more that, as you say, people will time-shift, take alternate transportation, take a different route, move, change jobs, etc. to keep a commute under a particular time.

It's sort of another version of the "work expands to fill the time allotted to it" maxim.

And if it's not commuting we're talking about, some people will just choose not to drive into a city for dinner, etc. because it's too much of a hassle.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by pascalxus on Monday May 22, 2017 @12:36PM (#14394956)
CA has been constricting the supply for the last 30 years, so it's not going to be fixed overnight! I guess it would take 10+ years of non-stop building to get housing anywhere close to the nationwide level, just a wild guess.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by Retric on Monday May 22, 2017 @06:44AM (#14392414)
US population has continued to grow so individual new roads or housing will never be enough on their own. It's the rate of new roads and housing that's important. Consider the Big dig was extremely expensive and made significant long term impact, but another one would still help.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by Camillo on Sunday May 21, 2017 @10:11PM (#14390498)
There should be a site where these actionable things are concisely listed. Not a HN comment, a real website. Maybe people could even sign up for emails whenever a new action item pops up.

OTOH, many people here are not US citizens, so they cannot really do much about any of this.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Sunday May 21, 2017 @10:24PM (#14390545)
There is! yimbyaction.org. They have a mailing list where they send out calls to action on upcoming legislation.

https://yimbyaction.org/mailinglist/

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by Kluny on Monday May 22, 2017 @02:31AM (#14391405)
strongtowns.org can keep you posted as well.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by coolspot on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:44AM (#14391729)
Not all cities must be made into overpopulated ant colonies. People love SF as it is, and if you increase density it would be not SF, it would be something else. If you like dense cities - there are plenty of them - LA, SD, NY...
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by alpha_squared on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:31AM (#14391927)
> People love SF as it is

I'm sure people loved SF in the '70s, too. I'm sure people loved SF in the '80s, too. I'm sure people loved SF in the '90s, too.

SF has been changing for a while, most American metropolitan cities have. I always find the argument, "I love ____ as it is now" a little amusing, implying that it was either always that way or that it's finally a way that the person wants it to be.

Honestly, I miss the SF of the '90s and early 2000s, which is probably not the same SF that "people [of today who] love SF as it is."

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by timthelion on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:05AM (#14391805)
Exactly my thought. If you like sky scrapers, WHY NOT move the startup capital to LA? Is there any real reason it has to be SF?
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:49AM (#14393507)
I don't think it's that people love sky scrapers so much as they are willing to tolerate them in order to avoid paying half their salary in rent every month. In any event, we don't need skyscrapers to solve the housing problem, we need more 5-story buildings, which are currently a pain to push through the Planning Commission and BoS in SF, even along transit corridors.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by falsedan on Monday May 22, 2017 @05:34AM (#14392164)
> like dense cities - there are plenty of them

> LA

what

> SD

wut

Until jobs start spreading out & not get concentrated in small geographic areas, we are doomed to support the high-density metropolis or urban-sprawl-commute-hell.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by xxSparkleSxx on Monday May 22, 2017 @03:55AM (#14391769)
It's funny, I live in SD and many say the same thing. "We don't want to increase density, we like that it feels like a small city. It's a privilege to live here, if you can't afford it too bad."

Something's got to give somewhere.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by alpha_squared on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:43AM (#14391977)
> It's a privilege to live here, if you can't afford it too bad.

From my brief stint in SD, I thought that sentiment was interesting. Especially considering that the housing market is very heavily tied into the military stipend provided for active members. There is a noticeable shift on a nearly annual basis where rental prices shift across the board all together and it doesn't have much to do with influx of residents/demand, but with the stipend increasing for active members. I don't know if this stretches to home-buying as well, but it's almost as if there's this strange symbiotic relationship between the city and military (government) and everyone else is just expected to keep up.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by sintaxi on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:12AM (#14391835)
A city is not obligated to densify. The give is that people start to move to places they can afford to live instead of complaining about what hasn't been handed to them.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by alpha_squared on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:33AM (#14391933)
> instead of complaining about what hasn't been handed to them

While I understand this sentiment, it's certainly glossing over the opposing view of people being kicked out of the homes/neighborhoods they grew up in.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by CuriouslyC on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:03AM (#14392846)
I don't think people being forced out of the neighborhood they live in is necessarily a bad thing, if it means that the new residents are paying more to society for the privilege of living there, and thus lowering the tax burden on everyone else.

The problem from my perspective is that land taxes aren't sufficiently high. Land should not be an easy, safe long term investment. Land should be something you gain title to in order to put to a highly productive use, i.e. live in. A lot of property in growing cities is owned by foreign investors who rarely (if ever) occupy it. If land was no longer a good investment, this would instantly liberate a lot of housing to be used by people who need it.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by jefurii on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:43AM (#14393072)
> I don't think people being forced out of the neighborhood they live in is necessarily a bad thing

I wish my account would let me downvote this

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by ghaff on Monday May 22, 2017 @08:58AM (#14393159)
Gentrification has plusses and minuses. It is one of the processes by which a city improves in various respects. However, in spite of (very imperfect) mechanisms like rent control and caps of property value assessments, an inevitable result of a neighborhood becoming more upscale is that prior residents and business owners find it increasingly hard to remain there.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by sintaxi on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:42AM (#14391971)
Except they are not. Anyone is free to purchase any property that someone else is willing to sell. If you don't own the property you live in then you may not always be able to live there. Its pretty simple. If you want guarantees own the things you use.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by alpha_squared on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:48AM (#14391988)
I don't know if you're aware of this, but your statements are coming off awfully privileged. From the idea that people need to "earn" things, a strangely unique American perspective that you "earn" anything at all (completely pretending that you didn't start off ahead in a lot of ways anyway). To the idea that "its pretty simple" [sic] and that the blindingly obvious solution is to just "own the things you use" - a luxury that not many people can do.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by chii on Monday May 22, 2017 @09:13PM (#14398098)
but the point is that it cant be any other way. property owners aren't going to do sell or rent below market price. if you're poor, you get shoved around, which has been more or less the same since the dawn of humanity.

the modern day of today doesn't mean that changes. not until there's unlimited frer resources.

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by eecc on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:57AM (#14392031)
Ah the same old: "it's your fault if you're poor" argument. What's the next one, "poor life choices"?
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by pascalxus on Monday May 22, 2017 @12:32PM (#14394925)
Thank you for bringing this up. Don't be afraid to sound like a broken record, there are so many uninformed voters out there. We need the repetition.

But, one thing we have to be careful of: If you place constraints on builders: such as requiring affordable housing, it reduces the amount of supply thus making the problem worse for everyone.

What we really need, is more supply. Lots of deregulation to encourage as much building as we can possibly get

Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by smrtinsert on Sunday May 21, 2017 @10:57PM (#14390688)
the headline is still very applicable to other metro areas.
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by kevinburke on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:02PM (#14390709)
True, though the Bay Area is unique in the amount of leverage NIMBY's have in the process, through "discretionary review", CEQA lawsuits, EIR appeals, and other tactics...
Re:Baby boomers are making it harder for millennials to buy ... by sintaxi on Monday May 22, 2017 @04:07AM (#14391818)
Perhaps you can't afford to live in the Bay Area. Live elsewhere.