News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by theprop on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:05PM (#14380453)
It would be much better to send those defaulters to prison where the annual cost is typically more than the most expensive colleges in the country...oh wait, maybe we should just send them to college and pay for it, that might save even more money?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by trendia on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:14PM (#14380482)
Before we start paying for it, we should ask why the costs have increased so dramatically in the last 10 years, and why the benefits of a degree have gone down. Then, neither debt nor debt collection would be an issue.

After all, the reason people can't pay back their debts is 1) even state colleges are expensive, and 2) the job market doesn't reward degrees. It's not like changing the payer of tuition from the individual to the government is going to change either of those issues.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Spooky23 on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:53PM (#14380808)
It doesn't take a Kreskin.

1 - There are an amazingly large number of well compensated overhead positions and offices compared to the 90s.

My alma mater, a large state university literally had to buy a 9 story office building to house administration.

2 - They spend money like water.

Example: The student internet network was run when I was there in 1996 by three telecom/network guys and a little army of student helpers who did installs and support for $4.25/hr. Now the costs are 25x, and the contractor has also built a small office building next door to house their people.

Example: Capital costs run amok. My alma mater has built a Tier-4 data center that is 15% occupied, a football stadium, a monumental second library that doesn't contain many books but does contain a lot of marble, a business school building, an art building, a bunch of extra dorms, and a gas fired power plant.

Example: New dorms are hotel like, with multiple fitness centers, TVs approximately every 10 linear feet, and associated parking structures.

The school I'm thinking about is doing well, but they've probably bonded nearly a half billion worth of capital projects alone that are not research funded. If you had 0% 30 year bonds that's over $1500 a student alone for 30 years assuming 10,000 students.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by dancing_shark on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:54PM (#14380945)
No need to be coy -- what is the university you're talking about?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by mjevans on Saturday May 20, 2017 @02:21AM (#14381277)
What's happening in one place is probably happening in more than one place... so everywhere.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Spooky23 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @08:42AM (#14382120)
I didn't call them out because they aren't doing anything unusual.

Drive around any town. The colleges and hospitals are wrapping up an orgy of construction in most places. The root causes are very similar

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by cbanek on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:28PM (#14380542)
I agree that the system doesn't reward degrees. It merely requires them as a ticket to ride.

I'd say that we're getting less productivity gains out of degrees these days likely because a lot of people get a degree, then get a job that uses absolutely nothing they learned from that degree.

In that case, the degree is more or less worthless, and only proves to the employer that you can jump through the hoops. And between a known hoop-jumper and some random person, most companies would rather take the hoop-jumper.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by chii on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:26PM (#14380738)
> It merely requires them as a ticket to ride.

sounds suspiciously like the advertising landscape, where it's a zero sum game. You pay $X to advertise to obtain Y% marketshare gain, but if your competitor also spends $X, it nullifies your Y% marketshare gain.

Replace the above with a college degree and job, and it seems the same.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by laGrenouille on Saturday May 20, 2017 @05:07AM (#14381572)
Except that neither is actually a zero sum game. If Pepsi and Coca-Cola both spend $1B in advertising neither may gain any proportional market share but they would still expect to collectively benefit from converting some coffee/tea/juice drinkers to their product.

In the case of raising the bar for a basic education across the board, at least in theory, we would expect to increase national/global GDP.

I'm not saying the increase in either case warrants the respective cost, but dismissing improvements in education on the grounds that life is just one big zero sum rat race seems overly simplistic.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by nroets on Saturday May 20, 2017 @05:44AM (#14381629)
Without advertising spend, the best search engine in the world would have been a university research project (the original Google based on Page Rank.)

I would not see many of the quality TV productions, because I don't have pay TV and I don't pirate. (Survivor etc).

Advertising spend paid for instant search, voice search, knowledge graph, Chrome and even Android.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by BenjiWiebe on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:17AM (#14381011)
I've a friend who teaches electrical engineering at K-State University. He says that a pretty good number of his students are merely trying to get a degree, not actually learn/understand it. The minimum required to pass is all they would know at their peak.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by cbanek on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:45AM (#14381079)
I'm conflicted with engineering education.

On one hand, you really need to get a basic grasp of the fundamentals of a lot of areas. Even if you forget it, I like to think it's all in there somewhere, and would at least require less time to re-study it.

On the other hand, when you are actually working on a project, or at a job, typically you zoom in on one area of focus. For example, I have a Comp E degree from UIUC, and I had to take analog signal processing. Got a C, and never used it in my professional career.

But subjects that I have used, the course material was such a survey over the problems that it's only the very beginning of what you might need for the work. Therefore much study is required anyway on the job.

Then the practical experience, with test equipment, devices, best practices, isn't even usually taught in college.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by dikdik on Saturday May 20, 2017 @10:50AM (#14382617)
I mean, is this surprising? Despite the original purpose of college, today the majority of people only go to college because they want a decent job.

If your best shot of getting a decent job requires you to first get a 40k piece of paper, many people will do this and they will put in the minimum amount of work to get what they want. I mean, it's efficient after all isn't it? Why work more for the same result?

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by mrow84 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @04:10AM (#14381493)
This idea is formalised in the concept of "positional goods" [0]. Fred Hirsch coined the name in his book The Social Limits to Growth, which I definitely recommend - it contains a lot of interesting discussion about the place of positional goods in the economy, and how the rising share of consumption of positional goods affects welfare.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positional_good

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by peckrob on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:59PM (#14380648)
> Before we start paying for it, we should ask why the costs have increased so dramatically in the last 10 years

When I started college in 2000, in-state tuition at my alma mater (a major state university) was $3,021 for 2 semesters. I just looked and it's now $10,968 for the same 2 semesters. In 17 years, tuition went up 263%. From what I can tell, inflation over the same period was 42%.

At this rate, I'm scared that I will literally never be able to save enough to put my daughter through college without taking out loans, assuming tuition continues this trend. Something has got to give.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by kaybe on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:28PM (#14380746)
If she's young enough to learn another language well in time, you could consider sending her to Europe. All in all, it's still cheaper and possible to get by with summer jobs and some help from parents.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by madengr on Saturday May 20, 2017 @09:18AM (#14382228)
Yes, at KU in 1994 it was a little over $100/credit*Hr. Tutituon was free if you were a TA. I had an RA and TA, so I got paid to go to grad school.

Now I have two kids in elementary school, and I'm socking away $2k/month for college savings, wondering if that will be enough. I figure $80k/kid.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by eli on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:06PM (#14380670)
Yes, it is outpacing even healthcare and child care spending. Definitely beyond inflation.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Arizhel on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:25PM (#14380732)
It seems to me the answer isn't all that difficult: colleges in other countries are much cheaper, or even free. So just move to someplace like Germany.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by majormajor on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:24PM (#14380530)
> 2) the job market doesn't reward degrees

Oh, it does. The schools and banks have just positioned themselves to capture as much of the added value as they can - which might take away a lot of the financial upside, but the difference in unemployment rate is still quite significant.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by randomdata on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:41PM (#14380776)
> but the difference in unemployment rate is still quite significant.

I was expecting significant to mean more than 1.3 percentage points[1] over the entire population of the same age[2], especially given those who have certain difficulties will most likely never attend college, and will struggle in the workplace because of those difficulties (think mental disabilities as an example). Handing a degree on a silver platter to someone in that position isn't really going to help them.

Knowing that such people exist and need to be accounted for, while seeing how close the numbers really are, I'm even less convinced that the market rewards degrees than I was before I read these comments.

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU04027662 [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS14000048

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by majormajor on Saturday May 20, 2017 @01:07AM (#14381144)
Sorry for the lack of clarity, I was referring to the combination of unemployment rate and workforce participation rate (which is 74% with bachelor's degree or higher, 58% with high school only). There's doubtless some confounding factors there, but it shows where the jobs are going. I don't think those inherent difficulties for certain people you mention don't need to be considered separately because the market doesn't care why you didn't attend college - part of what the market is rewarding is, frankly, either not having or being able to overcome inherent difficulties.

( https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11327662 and https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNU01327660 ) -- edited to fix links

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by randomdata on Saturday May 20, 2017 @06:47AM (#14381788)
How are you establishing causation here? Of course, older generations are far more likely to have only high school, if that. It seems likely that older generations are less likely to be participating in the workforce. I'm not sure if this data includes beyond retirement age, but certainly early retirees would be included in the participation rate.

More interesting would be to narrow our criteria down to ages 25-34 to see how the rise in postsecondary schooling has changed the employment landscape over time. My opinion is that the unemployment rate is on trend[1], and while participation is unfortunately skewed from the 60s to the 90s due to rising of women coming into the workplace, since the 1990s there is little change in participation despite rising rates of postsecondary attainment[2]. If the workplace valued college, shouldn't we see a more obvious change over time corresponding with rising rates of postsecondary attainment?

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS14000089

[2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS12000089

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by robotjosh on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:35PM (#14380568)
Nobody has ever asked to see my degree or if I have one. They only care what I can do and how much it will cost. I looked into taking a few classes but saw that tuition has quadrupled making 2 classes cost more than an entire semester when I was in school only 10 years ago. Not only that, there are fewer professors and more non-professors teaching. Professors still do not make 100k even if they teach all day every semester so all this extra money isn't going to them.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by learc83 on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:52PM (#14380805)
>Professors still do not make 100k even if they teach all day every semester

That's not true at all. When I was in school, I used the state's public employee salary lookup to checkout how much my professors made. Almost all of professors (all of the professors and associate professors, and several of the assistant professors) in my department were making more than 100k. In addition, I was in a low cost of living area compared to most of the US.

I looked outside of CS as well. Humanities departments weren't paying that much, but most 100k pretty normal in most of the hard science departments, and the business school professors were making even more than the CS department.

Sure the adjuncts and grad students weren't making anything, and there are too many of them.

Also no one has ever asked if I had a degree either, but that's because it was on my resume. Without a degree you're going to get screened out before you even talk to someone a lot of the time.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Spooky23 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:03AM (#14380968)
When did you go to school?

There are different strata of academic. The adjuncts make peanuts and are either people who are stuck with a vision of being in academia or outside professionals earning a buck.

Tenure track professors end up making good money, which imo is well deserved.

Now you also have this middle tier of professors who are wandering nomads on 2-3 year contracts. They have a professor title, make better money than adjuncts, but tend to get dropped at the end of the contract. My neighbors boarder is one of these folks -- she commutes about 200 miles from her home and stays in my town for 2-3 days. This is her third contract like this.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by yequalsx on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:10AM (#14380989)
At large state universities pay is good. It goes down dramatically when looking st regional state universities and community colleges. Also over 50% of higher education is taught by non-tenured or tenure track faculty. Pay for such workers is low and frequently don't include benefits.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by trendia on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:26AM (#14381034)
At my university (large state research school), professor salary was dependent on grants.

Professors get big grants? They get nice salaries.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by derekp7 on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:58PM (#14380642)
I wonder if anyone has done an itemized breakdown of where each dollar of tuition goes to? How much to the teaching staff, how much to building maintenance, etc. Would be interesting.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by csa on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:25PM (#14380730)
I don't have the numbers with me right now (on phone), but the ratio of administrators to professors has gone through the roof over the past few decades. This is where a lot of the money is going.

Facilities have also improved quite a bit at many schools.

Over the same period, the ratio of adjunct faculty to permanent faculty has also increased. Meanwhile, the permanent faculty are burdened with even more administrative duties (e.g., committees).

The administrators learned that they could eat high on the hog on the government's dime, and they have done so with a frightening degree of efficiency.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by robotjosh on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:45PM (#14380789)
Someone should start a college with only a few administrators and simple buildings. It could cost at least 1/4th of what it costs now.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by derekp7 on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:44PM (#14380929)
Then that brings up the next issue -- would students choose the simple college over the more expensive one? After all, they can get a loan for both, and many 18-year-olds make different (less beneficial) choices then they would later in life.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by BenjiWiebe on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:20AM (#14381020)
"...frightening degree of efficiency." Sounds like they are good administrators at least.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by douche on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:17PM (#14380704)
It's all facilities and administrators.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by ProAm on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:00PM (#14380650)
> ask why the costs have increased so dramatically in the last 10 years

This is easy its because the government increased the amount students are allowed to borrow. It's a 1:1 ratio

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by criddell on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:34PM (#14380762)
Is that true though? I thought it was more because funding has been cut so the costs are shifted from taxpayers to the students.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by StudentStuff on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:52PM (#14380941)
That is part of the issue, but it is also an excuse so that universities can hire vast numbers of administrative staff that they have historically never hired. Why should a small satellite campus of a major university have 2 officers on duty 24/7, when they respond to anywhere from 5 to a dozen incidents a month?

That is 8 full time employees plus space & equipment doing a BS job that should be handled by local police (who also happen to be overstaffed). Should a university really be blowing that much cash needlessly?

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by criddell on Saturday May 20, 2017 @10:49AM (#14382611)
Security officers might not be the best example. A university needs insurance and chances are the cost of setting up and maintaining a security force is less expensive than paying a higher insurance premium.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by StudentStuff on Sunday May 21, 2017 @04:21PM (#14389056)
Most universities are self-insured from what I've seen, in the education industry most schools are self-insured too.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by learc83 on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:55PM (#14380813)
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by unclebucknasty on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:26PM (#14380535)
>we should ask why the costs have increased so dramatically

>It's not like changing the payer of tuition from the individual to the government is going to change either of those issues

Some believe the ready availability of government-backed loans is partly responsible for the dramatic tuition increases.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by tzs on Saturday May 20, 2017 @09:32AM (#14382281)
I've not had much luck finding historical tuition data, but was able to get some Stanford data going back to 1920. Here is a graph of Stanford tuition from 1920 through 2011: http://i.imgur.com/fXnjDNn.png

The data from 1920 through 1990 was only for every ten years, then it becomes yearly after, which is why the first part of the graph has more straight segments. Note the tuition axis is on a log scale.

Comparing Stanford tuition growth by decade to inflation, here is how much Stanford tuition every 10 years was above the inflation adjusted tuition from 10 years earlier:

  1930: 183% 
  1940:  41%
  1950:  13%
  1960:  22%
  1970:  85%
  1980:  27%
  1990:  39%
  2000:  29%
  2010:  23%
From this, it appears that if government loans affected Stanford tuition that did not manifest as a long term change in the growth rate. It looks like the long term growth is about 30ish% a decade in reasonably "normal" times. If the loans affected the growth rate it seems to have mostly been confined to around the time the loans first became widely available. In other words, if the loans had an effect, it seems to have been more of a level shift than a growth rate shift.

I'd like to see similar data for other schools.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by emodendroket on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:20PM (#14380504)
Well, it could, if paired with a bigger government role in public universities.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by trendia on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:24PM (#14380531)
Ah yes. Like setting a price ceiling? Adding more administrators, managers, and bureaucrats to "find where all that money is going"? By paying teachers less?

It's not an easy task to reduce the cost of something... this is even more so when the government is the one doing it.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by bobdole1234 on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:40PM (#14380585)
It's actually really easy to cut the costs on things, and all you need to do is cut all the levels of useless middlemen taking their cut.

Kind of like how Canada uses this one simple trick to cut their health care expenses.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by StudentStuff on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:03AM (#14380967)
When you pass laws to force government organizations to be wasteful, they will comply. Outside of that, not wasting taxpayer dollars is generally a high priority.

A great example of laws purposefully foot binding & hobbling organizations is USPS, who is not allowed to up the ante and offer any modern services, and has to severely overfund their pension obligations, to the point that they are funding pensions for people they haven't hired.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by emodendroket on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:53PM (#14380631)
Well, no, you probably need far fewer administrators, actually.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by eloisius on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:56PM (#14380818)
I think GP was making this suggestion in a sarcastic jab about what cost reduction efforts look like when done by government.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by emodendroket on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:06PM (#14380843)
OK, but I don't think it holds up. The US has one of the systems of education (and healthcare, too) with the least government interference and it's wildly expensive. As far as I am aware the biggest drivers for rising tuition costs are construction and increasingly large administrative departments.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by poikniok on Saturday May 20, 2017 @01:54AM (#14381230)
The US has tons of government interference in all of those areas though!
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by emodendroket on Saturday May 20, 2017 @07:34AM (#14381928)
Compared to other OECD countries not really.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by tenpies on Friday May 19, 2017 @09:21PM (#14380507)
Can you imagine trying to convince tax payers who don't even agree on universal healthcare that they should now pay NYU's tuition for someone studying Intersectional Feminist Literature?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by TillE on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:49PM (#14380796)
Yeah what a crazy hippie liberal idea...supported by, for example, the ruling center-right Christian party in Germany.

Americans really need to get over their dumb cultural hangups on a lot of issues. (Also, universal healthcare does enjoy very wide support already.)

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by ericd on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:58PM (#14380825)
What is that person going to do for work afterwards that it's worth it for society to do this with its limited resources, given that they're not independently wealthy, and they haven't been developing their skills for a career on the side? I don't mean to be snarky, I'm genuinely curious.

If I'm not mistaken, historically, only the rich have gotten these sorts of degrees.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Spooky23 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:16AM (#14381005)
They are going to have a well practiced ability to analyze text, data and other sources and understand, critique or respond to arguments presented.

Liberal arts teach you about thinking.

I dual majored in CS and History, concentrating on the path that Marco Polo supposedly took to China's the people and cultures there. The later has been far more helpful to me that the CS stuff, which was mostly theoretical bullshit.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by ericd on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:45AM (#14381078)
Good point, and I'd add that a circumspect citizenry with experience in many varied areas of thinking is necessary for democracy to function well. It's probably worth it to society to fund for that benefit alone. Thanks for the reminder.

You did get a fairly in-demand degree job-wise to go with it, though. Do you feel like the history degree by itself would have been good enough work-wise?

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by Spooky23 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @08:49AM (#14382141)
I've had this debate with colleagues and friends many times.

I struggled with choosing CS because everyone assumed I'd go to school for computer related stuff from age 8. I wanted to be sure I did what I wanted to do. But I also wanted good job prospects!

End of the day, CS opened doors to good jobs immediately after college. Without that, i problably would have gravitated towards teaching, sales, law or something similar.

Between luck, hustle, timing and what I know (not necessarily in that order), I'm pretty happy with how things have turned out. Had I taken another path, I tend to believe I would land in a similar place. But who knows!

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by therealdrag0 on Sunday May 21, 2017 @11:41PM (#14390856)
I similarly was a computer kid, but took a different path (English, Philosophy), and I did end up in the same place. After teaching English for a year in Korea, I spent a year pounding out the lightest CS degree I could. Now I have a healthy dev career, and I don't regret lib arts at all (except maybe wishing I did them at the same time, instead of serially).
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by ericd on Saturday May 20, 2017 @01:32PM (#14383416)
Makes sense. I think your approach is a good one - mix passion and practical.
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by dragonwriter on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:52PM (#14380942)
> If I'm not mistaken, historically, only the rich have gotten these sorts of degrees.

I'm fairly confident you're quite mistaken.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by ericd on Saturday May 20, 2017 @12:38AM (#14381063)
It's very possible. Do you know of any evidence of a large number of people in the lower classes getting college degrees that had very little direct career relevance outside of a few spots in academia?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by johng on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:17PM (#14380703)
So part of the reason we are in this situation and the costs have skyrocketed is because the government got involved in loaning money for school. We follow that up by getting the government involved in loan collections and obviously they've screwed that up entirely. So your suggestion is to now have the government get involved in paying for the college altogether, and then expect that NOT to go wrong in any way?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by tedmiston on Friday May 19, 2017 @11:18PM (#14380870)
Whatever happened to trade schools and apprenticeships anyway?
Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by SamUK96 on Saturday May 20, 2017 @03:26AM (#14381394)
The 60s-80s-born generation performed a real doozy and told their kids "you can be anything you wanted!", so of course we ended up with a culling in trades and "plebian" jobs, and an explosive influx into "soft skills" like history, literature, etc., since that's far better than milling drill-bits all day right?

The craziest thing is that this has been a totally first-world thing. Any english/american university student will tell you how engineering degree courses are made up predominately of foreign students, where-as the less employable and "trade"-producing courses are dominanted by the firsr-world population.

I did Physics. It was 130 students 120 white male, 9 white female, 1 black female. Zero international students

Same university, but mechanical engineering, 70%+ black, 70%+ international students (india/china essentially).

So, to answer your question to what happened to trade schools: they still exist, but the first world young white generation doesn't want to do it anymore, and foriegn/black students have filled in the gap, for whatever that may be.

Re:Americans Are Paying $38 to Collect $1 of Student Debt by zaroth on Friday May 19, 2017 @10:07PM (#14380672)
We did send them to college... and I can guarantee you that we are paying for it.

It doesn't seem to have helped much if all you need to not default is $5/mo and yet what's the default rate again?