News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by ricw on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:45AM (#14341492)
Finally it looks like the desktop CPU market could become interesting and competitive again. Intel being pushed to release a new top of the line core i9 processor?! I cannot remember anything like this since the amd64 days more than 10 years ago.

Would love to play with one of these setups..

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by 013a on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:19AM (#14341747)
The i9 isn't new. Its a rebranded Skylake-X/KabyLake-X chip. This has been on their roadmap for over a year [1]; they just changed the name to trick consumers into thinking its something new.

The hype between here and reddit about i9 is astounding to me. You've been able to get an i7 in a 10 core variant for a year now [2]. Need 6 cores? Take a time machine back to Q3'11 and pick up an i7 3930k [3]. And if you needed twelve cores, you could buy Xeon [4]! Heck, go crazy, get 22 [5]!

The only difference is likely price; hopefully the i9 is cheaper.

Fundamentally, why you should not be excited about these things: They'll use the enthusiast motherboard socket/chipset, not the consumer socket. And they'll have a 140W TDP, whereas Ryzen has 95W max. These two things are what makes Ryzen so amazing. If you ignore these two things, then you might as well by Xeon; Intel has lead in that category for years and continues to.

[1] http://wccftech.com/intel-skylake-x-kaby-lake-x-q2-2017-road...

[2] http://ark.intel.com/products/94456/Intel-Core-i7-6950X-Proc...

[3] http://ark.intel.com/products/63697/Intel-Core-i7-3930K-Proc...

[4] http://ark.intel.com/products/91767/Intel-Xeon-Processor-E5-...

[5] http://ark.intel.com/products/93805/Intel-Xeon-Processor-E5-...

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by izacus on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:53AM (#14341998)
The problem is of course the fact that 6+ i7 chips don't actually fit the consumer motherboards, but you need to go to the server segment where MBs are significantly more expensive and lack a whole slew of additional features nice for desktop machines.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by Tsiklon on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:25PM (#14343348)
Intel have a high end desktop chipset related to the server boards which is used in such cases.

X79, X99, both are related to equivalent server chipsets in C602 and C612 respectively. Yes boards are more expensive but the HEDT platform has all the features you'd expect of a consumer/enthusiast board. also the high end i7s are all met with equivalent non overclockable Xeon E5-1* processors

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by valarauca1 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:34PM (#14342914)
>server segment where MBs are significantly more expensive

False-ish

Single socket server boards are on par with home motherboards. They only become expensive when you start wanting 2+ NIC's and A LOT of sockets. But then yes your feature thing is mostly true.

> and lack a whole slew of additional features nice for desktop machines.

False-ish

Intel's server socket (for non E7's) is 2011v3 which is also their enthusiast socket. I dropped a XEON E5v4 2030 into a 2011v3 ""ethusiast board"" and it worked without a problem.

Sure my enthusiast board doesn't support ECC RAM, and I can't over clock a XEON. But a 2011v3 board in and of itself is only ~50-60 more then an EXTREME low end <$100 stock standard home user motherboard.

You get what you pay for if you want a dirt cheap board to drop a server class CPU into you can find it.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:44PM (#14344018)
You don't need to go to a server board for ECC - a lot of the X99 boards actually do support it. Not all of them (EVGA doesn't, a lot of Gigabyte boards don't) but a lot do (Asrock usually does).

And you can find motherboards in pretty much any price range except the barest of dirt cheap. There are motherboards like the GA-X99-SLI that regularly hit $125 or lower. Cheapest thing on Newegg right now is a $150 Asrock board that supports ECC.

The only price range that you "can't get" for X99 is the under-$100 price range, i.e. the super-shitty low-end chipsets. And you actually can get it if you are willing to take an open-box item. I paid $60 after tax for my last X99 board.

Also realize that most of the people who are bitching up a storm about X99's $150 motherboards likely turned around and paid $250 for an X370 board when Ryzen launched. I mean, you gotta get one of the nice ones with the external clockgen so you can get your $300 Samsung B-die memory kit to run stable, right? (but that's totally different! /s)

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by sireat on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:11PM (#14344251)
Problem is that you cannot have both via current (from 2011+ on) Intel route: high clock speed on the CPU(achieved by OC) AND ECC.

You want ECC you have to get Xeons.

You want OC you have to get regular mainstream K chips or enthusiast -E chips without ECC support.

I think the last chipset which let you OC Xeons and still use ECC was X58 on 1366 socket.

Disclaimer: I am not counting tiny BCLK OC available on Xeons.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by valarauca1 on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:01PM (#14345084)
Because ECC and OC are targeted at different audiences. If you want both... you don't understand one or the other.

ECC is to guarantee system stability. Solving rare event that become regular once you have hundreds of boxes running.

OC INCREASES system instability. You put more power into a chip, increasing the probability of incorrect or malformed answers.

Now both these scenarios are rare, especially for single box home enthusiasts. Generally if you have a stable OC you won't hit garbled instruction results. Likewise you may almost never have an error that ECC would present.

---

Having OC and ECC basically says, "I want to solve one extremely rare error while opening myself up to another!" This is an idiotically unsound decision.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by Dylan16807 on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:26PM (#14345278)
ECC can help you ensure that your OC is still stable. And these chips are optimized for power use in servers. There is often a lot of room for stable overclocking.

You're also not guaranteed perfect operation inside the CPU without an overclock, so if it's idiotic to combine OC and ECC, it's idiotic to use ECC at all.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by mschuster91 on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:12PM (#14345171)
You can (and should!) decrease error ratios while OCing by providing proper cooling.

Having ECC memory in an OC setup will increase its stability further - and there are perfectly valid reasons for overclocking, for example if you want more computing power than even a 22-core Xeon does not provide.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:52PM (#14344578)
Definitely true.

Tangent: a lot of people wonder who would pay $1700 for a 6950X. The answer I always give is "people want to do intensive work and gaming on the same system". Otherwise the 4/6C chips are better choices for the money.

The great weakness of that system is - as you note - the lack of ECC.

I strongly, strongly recommend building two different systems for this situation. Depending on your needs it can almost be more economical to do it this way. i3s (and now Pentiums) support ECC and make good ZFS servers. The 4C Xeons aren't too bad either. You can also do some cheap E5 Xeon builds using engineering samples. Many-core Xeons are more than sufficient for the kind of stuff you need ECC for, even at relatively low clock rates. A 10C at 2.4 GHz is roughly comparable to 6C at 4.13 GHz (I use mine in Handbrake). And uses 2/3 of the power to boot.

And then you can focus on gaming performance in your gaming system. Like 3x as much for a given level of performance.

It's a lot like laptops. You're going to spend a lot more if you insist on only owning one system that can do everything.

The segmentation here does suck, I would rather see it supported even on consumer hardware, but practically speaking I don't think Intel is going to change this any time soon. Even if AMD does.

(and note: unless the manufacturer is willing to stand behind ECC, Ryzens's "unofficial" ECC support holds about as much weight as using Intel's engineering samples)

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by Aloha on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:43PM (#14344008)
I got to my inexpensive build by buying trailing edge hardware, still much faster than what I had, buy cheaper than current generation hardware.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by dom0 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:47PM (#14343033)
Motherboard price is square to the number of sockets. (This is actually accurate, look it up; and for somewhat good reason).
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by valarauca1 on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:53PM (#14344108)
Once you move into 2+ sockets you're already paying $5000+ for a CPU so what's an extra $4000 for a main board?
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by stolk on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:07AM (#14342129)
The i9 is most definitely something new.

It is the first desktop CPU to bring AVX512. If the code is designed for it, that by itself doubles the perf compared to AVX2 CPUs.

I look forward to porting my algorithms to 16 wide SIMD.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by 013a on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:06PM (#14343182)
Of course it is something new. The supposition is that Intel just rebranded something they already had in the pipeline; something which they release every 18 months or so.

AVX512 was already planned for Cannonlake.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by yohui on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:46AM (#14341948)
Mostly agree, but AMD's TDP estimates are slightly optimistic and in reality Ryzen's power usage is much closer to its Intel counterparts.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by leonlee on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:10PM (#14343215)
Unfortunately AMD and Intel don't use the same definition for TDP (look up AMD APC). AMD's values are more related to average power consumption during whatever they consider to be typical use. Intel's values on the other hand are more about the upper limit of power usage, "how high can it go" sort of thing. Both the average power and maximum power are useful bits of info, but it's obviously confusing and opaque for the end-user. The only reason that I can think of why AMD hasn't reverted back is because it would highlight how their processors are relatively power inefficient compared to their competitor's.

http://www.amd.com/Documents/43761A_ACP_WPv7.pdf

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by mtgx on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:41PM (#14343473)
Didn't Intel try to do the same thing with SDP?
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by loeg on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:16AM (#14342210)
Do you have a source for that?
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by yohui on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:39AM (#14342403)
paulmd already put up a list, so I won't repeat it. Ars Technica sums it up:

https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2017/03/amd-ryzen-review/

> Indeed, Ryzen's 95W TDP looks impressive compared to the 140W TDP of Intel's 6900K, a similar 8C/16T processor based on the Broadwell-E architecture. But in practice, Ryzen pulls just as much wattage from the wall as the 6900K, in some cases slightly more. Considering just how power-hungry Bulldozer was, that remains a significant achievement, even if it means that overclocking headroom isn't as high as some might have hoped.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:24AM (#14342272)
https://www.pcper.com/reviews/Processors/AMD-Ryzen-7-1800X-R...

https://www.bit-tech.net/hardware/2017/04/06/amd-ryzen-7-170...

http://www.tweaktown.com/reviews/8072/amd-ryzen-7-1800x-cpu-...

http://hothardware.com/reviews/amd-ryzen-7-1800x-1700x-1700-...

(bear in mind the 5820K/6800K/6850K are 6C, the 5960X/6900K are 8C, and the 6950X is 10C)

Essentially AMD is rating their TDP under a very light load - like a single thread at full boost clocks. Under an all-core load they are running roughly 30% over TDP. Intel's TDP rating is much more generous - they aren't quite rating at full, nonstop AVX load (eg Prime95) but typical full-load consumption is 15% under their TDPs which leaves some headroom for intermittent AVX usage.

Anecdotal evidence: my 10C20T Haswell-E Xeon pulls ~60% of its rated TDP during a Handbrake x264 encoding run. My 6C12T 5820K Haswell-E gaming chip (overclocked to 4.13 GHz all-core at stock voltages) pulls 75% of its rated TDP during a similar Handbrake x264 run. And supposedly x264 is smart enough to use AVX, so that should be a realistic-but-high figure. My OC'd 5820K pulls 90% of its rated TDP during a Prime95 SmallFFT run.

It's still a huge gain compared to Bulldozer - but not quite as rosy a picture as AMD is trying to paint. They are equal with Haswell-E/Broadwell-E in most respects, not 40% ahead like AMD is rating them.

AMD is playing the same game in the GPU market too. AMD's RX 480/580 are rated for "GPU only" TDP (which they define to exclude memory/etc) but NVIDIA rates the whole card. In practice, AMD is ~30% above their official TDPs while NVIDIA is pretty much spot on.

https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/Sapphire/RX_580_Nitro_Pl...

(RX 580 is rated at 185W TDP, GTX 1060 is rated at 120W TDP)

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by dom0 on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:49PM (#14343045)
TDP is and always was an expressly manufacturer- and product-specific number, though. It mainly exists for OEMs to match parts up with the correctly sized heatsink.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:03PM (#14344188)
That argument stops holding water when the manufacturer starts marketing around the superior power efficiency of their processors based on that same number.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by loeg on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:41AM (#14342417)
Thanks!
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by mtgx on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:57AM (#14342044)
Same with Atom-based Celerons/Pentiums, and Core M-based Core i3's and i5's, and more recently the Skylake "Gold" And "Platinum":

https://semiaccurate.com/2017/05/05/intels-new-scalable-xeon...

It's looking like with Moore's Law dying, Intel has just given up, and is instead trying to "innovate" with how to trick its customers to pay more for the same or weaker stuff.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by dogma1138 on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:50AM (#14341538)
No, Intel's i9 if it exists is a rename of the old HEDT platform.

This is also likely unrelated to AMD, with Coffee Lake coming which brings 6-core/6-thread and 6-core/12-thread CPUs to the mainstream (150-300$) Intel likely wants a new tier to relay performance segmentation when even a core i5 will come with 6 cores from Q3 2017 onwards.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by robhu on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:59AM (#14341600)
Nope. 6 core 12 thread CPUs came to the mainstream a while ago, AMD brought them. The Ryzen 5 1400 is $160.

Intel is playing catchup.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by 013a on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:25AM (#14341792)
Ever heard of the i7 5820k? It was released Q3'14. 6 cores. 12 threads. i7 name. Around $400. [1]

AMD's great revolution was getting the TDP on that core count below 100W, and getting them onto a consumer chipset/socket instead of the enthusiast/server platform. That's it.

We keep saying they forced some revolution in price/performance that Intel has had to respond to. Its 80% hype, 20% truth. Intel was complacent on the desktop, yes. But Ryzen's perf gains over Skylake aren't significantly more than Intel's tick/tock perf gains they push each year; the main difference is that Ryzen focused on the enthusiast, which is something Intel had de-prioritized.

[1] http://ark.intel.com/products/82932/Intel-Core-i7-5820K-Proc...

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by robhu on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:16PM (#14343277)
Of course there have been 6 core processors before the Ryzen chips, the difference is Ryzen brought them to the mainstream.

The Ryzen chip is a third of the cost of the Intel chip and doesn't require the expensive enthusiast X99 platform.

AMD's great achievement is bringing 6 and 8 core chips /to the mainstream/, affordable by pretty much everyone. Intel's X99 enthusiast platform has been around longer but is massively more expensive.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by BuckRogers on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:51AM (#14342508)
It's 100% true that they've forced a revolution in price/performance. You forgot the much cheaper motherboards and RAM on Ryzen. Intel HEDT has been out of what most people consider a reasonable reach. The more attractive of the HEDT chips started at $1050+ (6900K). Add in your quad channel RAM and LGA-2011-v3 motherboard and you have quite a bundle. Not part of pricing but the AM4 promise for socket longevity further seals the deal for enthusiasts.

Either way, I'm happily using a newly built R7-1700 in a Node 202 mini-ITX case with a Geforce 1060 Founders Edition. It's very quiet and having 8 cores and 16 threads is far more useful than I assumed it would be. It's one of those things that you didn't know you needed until you have it. I use it for so much stuff, and it handles it all with ease.

If nothing else, the 16 threads get a workout daily as my Steam Link is set to do CPU encoding and that uses 8 threads. Beautiful image quality on the TV as a result when the fam is doing some gaming. I'm in love with this system, very happy with Ryzen. Thanks to AMD! :)

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:12AM (#14342167)
Intel did a really shitty job marketing these (maybe the i9 name will help). They are hardly known even amount enthusiasts but they are really good processors for the exact same reasons that people like Ryzen. A moderate tradeoff in gaming for a big gain in productivity tasks.

They are even priced essentially the same as the 4C8T i7s.

I basically had Ryzen performance at Ryzen prices a year ago when I built my 5820K system. Motherboard, processor, and 32 GB of DDR4-3000 CAS15 cost me $600 all together. I hit 4.13 GHz all-core on stock voltage and still run well under the rated TDP.

Ryzen was an incremental improvement at best. 8 core Ryzen is slightly faster (being that it has 33% more cores) but I'm still winning vs the 6-cores.

The real change Intel needs to make is dropping the cost of the 8-core and higher chips, because they're just past any reasonable budget.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by 013a on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:26PM (#14342832)
The 5820K was an amazing processor. I have one as well. Its coming up on two years old, yet for $390 (at release) its only ~10-20% slower than a brand new $490 Ryzen 1800x, and much of that drop can be attributed to two fewer cores.

You're right on all counts. Ryzen was vastly overhyped. Its highly likely Cannonlake and KabyLake-X will destroy it when they are released in a couple months.

The world needed Ryzen to push Intel to lower prices on their high end chips. But, like most of the times when AMD "pushes ahead", Intel will beat them within a year, and hold that position for another 4 years. And then the cycle repeats.

I don't know how much longer AMD can keep this up. It seems like they're being propped up by their dominance in console tech.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by dis-sys on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:33PM (#14342899)
Without the so called incremental improvement offered by Ryzen 7, there is no motivation for Intel to drop its prices on 8 cores chips. Intel now has to answer the challenges both on the 8c16t category and 16c32t as well.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by paulmd on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:52PM (#14343074)
I suspect the answer to the 8C16T category is going to be "Skylake-X".

Intel is still sitting on a ~10% lead in per-core performance in real-world applications, and Broadwell-E is handicapped in a number of ways. Skylake-X is going to be a huge step forward. I think the 6C Skylake-X chips are going to come real close to the 8C Ryzen 7s (let's call it within 5-10%). And that leaves the 8C Intel chips with a pretty solid lead.

(Synthetics like Cinebench are definitely tilting AMD - but I don't see a corresponding lead in real-world applications, on a core-for-core basis)

If Intel can maintain premium performance, they can also maintain premium pricing.

No question the race is on, though. Next year is gonna be interesting, when both companies have sized up the other and fully prepared their responses. There's some obvious fixes for AMD (like the interconnect, or just getting memory stability fixed), and Intel could do something like put the L4 eDRAM back on their dies to get minimum framerates up[0].

[0] http://techreport.com/review/28751/intel-core-i7-6700k-skyla...

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by dogma1138 on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:02AM (#14341633)
The Ryzen CPUs just came out, no OEMs yet, and the sales are not a blimp or Intel's radar yet. Coffee Lake is honestly a more interesting part, it's a 6 core with an IGP, AMD's APU will be 4 core maximum atm.

I know it hurts but AMD needs to have ship an almost unreasonable number of units for several consecutive to be considered mainstream. If Ryzen will be anything like the Athlon 64, AMD would fail to capitalize on it and just be behind Intel when it comes to iterations.

Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by Keyframe on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:04AM (#14342106)
I bought 3930K 6C/12HT in 2012 and still rockin' it. AMD was not even on radar back then.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by trueSlav on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:10AM (#14342154)
My old 1090t from 2010 says hi.
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by Keyframe on Monday May 15, 2017 @07:48PM (#14346233)
I remember that one, the one that said hi to already-on-the-market i7 980x! :)
Re:AMD 16-Core ThreadRipper Enthusiast CPUs to Reportedly Ut... by FluffyTheWalrus on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:50AM (#14341529)
Don't lie you don't want to play with one of these setups you want to take it home own and make love to it. xD

16 cores is absolutely insane my first computer was a commodore 64 VIC-20 it was 1 MHz with 32kb of ram...

Hopefully this will bring some life back into AMD..