I think this strongly conflates many issues. First of all, WannaCry spreads through a weakness in Microsoft's SMB implementation. Such a weakness can occur in both walled-garden and open systems.
Secondly, sandboxing, besides improving security, can increase our freedom: we get to decide which application can access what data. In the current model used on many computers, an application can access all user files and exfiltrate usage patterns, address books, etc. WannaCry would be pretty ineffective if it was sandboxed and could not encrypt user's files. Now such malware (as we've seen with the Handbrake malware) can upload all your passwords, browser history, etc.
Sandboxing is fine. It should be up to the user what we decide to sandbox and what not.
(I do agree that society is moving towards being totalitarian. Or at least, making itself extremely vulnerable to totalitarianism.)
True - but isn't the latter exactly the problem we're facing? That we increasingly don't get to decide whether we want that sandbox or not?
Unfortunately, the nature of the world is such that if you allow users to control sandboxing, the next wave of attacks will come from applications that kindly ask users to disable the sandbox because of $reasons.
You can make the best locks in the world and it's all for nothing if every time an attacker knocks on the door the user opens it up and lets them in, but the solution can't be to weld shut every door.
Security commonly fails at UX. We could do better.
But at some point, if you ask the user "should this app access your private information" and the user says yes, that's what needs to happen, and the user needs to learn when to say no.
Linux evades a huge amount of virus and phishing just because you have to `chmod +x` stuff before running, for example. A "Software wants to do nasty stuff. Allow | Disallow" prompt just does not make it.
Also, users will want to piece the sandbox some times, do not make it an all or nothing situation. Make giving common permissions easy, rare permission hard, and give fine grained control over them.
We are not there yet, but I personally fear, that all it would take is the political realization, that the ability to predict behavior leads to more efficient governance.
Technology has the ability to "set us free" or "enslave us", but it's up to the people to decide which they want in a democracy. In the current conservative climate, we're certainly heading more toward dystopia, racing rapidly to make some of the darker cyberpunk come true.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/may/07/the-great...
In short, they identified easily manipulated people by analyzing Facebook profiles, and manipulated them through Facebook ads. For me this is like a real-life botnet. The laws say 1 person, 1 vote, so why not manipulate the person to vote the way "we" want them. In a big-data way, targeting swing states...
And turning the world into farms.
What do you see as pros and cons?
on the downside, look at how they live.
I'm afraid this comment isn't up to HN standards, but i've always thought the teleological end of humanity was something that resembles an ant colony more than pack wolves, i'm not sure there's anything to be done to avoid it.
It's also funny how "ant colony" seems to be the direction of both the now deceased USSR-style socialism and modern capitalism -- with elites on top, total surveillance, and everything, just with different names.
> Feudalism is one of the oldest. It may appear to be rare nowadays, but some philosophers and historians have called it the “most natural” of human societies, simply because it cropped up in so many places throughout the millennia -- everywhere, in fact, that metallurgy and agriculture combined to let close-knit groups establish and enforce inherited aristocracies.
the rainforest itself is incredibly productive, although not in a monocultural way.
I have mixed feelings about what to do. On the one hand, there would be merit in requiring a professional license for programmers like in other engineering fields - a lot of the mess in our industry could be removed if at least some jobs would require a license, which would give both a recognized right to refuse work based on ethical issues (backed by professional association) and the liability in case you fucked up badly and people died.
On the other hand, I fear the day when Turing-complete systems will get regulated and require a (probably expensive) license to use. Like many others here, I benefited a lot from being able to tinker with computers and programming languages in my teenage years, before I had access to formal education on the topic. I would like my children to have the same chance.
In a way, my feelings are reflected on a smaller scale in the way I feel about sandboxing. On the one hand, I appreciate the idea of isolation and don't like user-hostile software to be able to do whatever it wants on my system. On the other hand, I'd love to have the right to breach the sandbox myself and mess with software running on it. On Windows I still can alter GUI elements of running applications; try that on unrooted Android.
If it was just about security vs. freedom, then the problem would be relatively easy; some compromise could be reached (e.g. expanded definition of "life-critical" systems which would require licenses, and also hopefully licenses for jobs requiring use of personally identifiable information). As it is, there are other selfish/malicious actors in play - like music/movie industry pushing for DRM, corporations fighting for their walled gardens, etc. It'll be hard to navigate this problem space.
Right, and we all believe that the Volkswagon debacle really was some nefarious programmer doing it without any knowledge of management.
I'm tired of developers getting blamed for this shit, put the blame squarely where it belongs, on the people with the money who are making such decisions.
Management is ultimately responsible for the overall culture. However, bad cultures find plenty of eager employees. We are talking about skilled people able to find job elsewhere if the ethics was consideration - we are not talking about uneducated dudes having no choice.
"I'm sorry, I can't do that, it's against my professional oath"
"That violates the software guild bylaws."
"I can't do that, I'd lose my license!"
Lawyers, accountants and other real professionals answer to higher principles than their boss.
One relevant "professional association" which comes to mind is the IEEE, which is actually pro-copyright/IP/DRM. Make of that what you will.
Knowing history that's usually what they get. WannaCry used an OS vulnerability that would have existed regardless of how locked down user space is.
Obviously really different issues, but the resolution was that the phishing scam was shut down in short order because it relied on Google for OAuth and they turned the app off and revoked the credentials.
1 - http://gizmodo.com/a-huge-and-dangerously-convincing-google-...
In some sense, I rather take solace in the fact that hacks, attacks, cracks, leaks, etc. are continuing to happen regularly --- they are a sign that there is still some freedom left in society. "Imagine a world without crime" is a somewhat common phrase used by some, and if you actually do, you will realise that it would pretty much be the world of Orwell's 1984: there is no crime because there is no more freedom of thought nor action; everything has become under the control of some central authority.
This goes beyond computers, although they will be a large part of it; it's really a general war on freedom.