News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by TeMPOraL on Monday May 15, 2017 @06:02AM (#14340380)
We need to be careful with the scope here, I think. "War on general-purpose computing" is already abstract enough most people just roll their eyes and move on; expanding that to "war on freedom" guarantees that almost nobody will care.

I have mixed feelings about what to do. On the one hand, there would be merit in requiring a professional license for programmers like in other engineering fields - a lot of the mess in our industry could be removed if at least some jobs would require a license, which would give both a recognized right to refuse work based on ethical issues (backed by professional association) and the liability in case you fucked up badly and people died.

On the other hand, I fear the day when Turing-complete systems will get regulated and require a (probably expensive) license to use. Like many others here, I benefited a lot from being able to tinker with computers and programming languages in my teenage years, before I had access to formal education on the topic. I would like my children to have the same chance.

In a way, my feelings are reflected on a smaller scale in the way I feel about sandboxing. On the one hand, I appreciate the idea of isolation and don't like user-hostile software to be able to do whatever it wants on my system. On the other hand, I'd love to have the right to breach the sandbox myself and mess with software running on it. On Windows I still can alter GUI elements of running applications; try that on unrooted Android.

If it was just about security vs. freedom, then the problem would be relatively easy; some compromise could be reached (e.g. expanded definition of "life-critical" systems which would require licenses, and also hopefully licenses for jobs requiring use of personally identifiable information). As it is, there are other selfish/malicious actors in play - like music/movie industry pushing for DRM, corporations fighting for their walled gardens, etc. It'll be hard to navigate this problem space.

Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by braveo on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:53PM (#14343080)
> On the one hand, there would be merit in requiring a professional license for programmers like in other engineering fields - a lot of the mess in our industry could be removed if at least some jobs would require a license

Right, and we all believe that the Volkswagon debacle really was some nefarious programmer doing it without any knowledge of management.

I'm tired of developers getting blamed for this shit, put the blame squarely where it belongs, on the people with the money who are making such decisions.

Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by watwut on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:43PM (#14344009)
Through, to be fair, plenty of developers are cool with such management decisions as long as the company is cool or the decision helps their career too. They may even proactive come with proposing ideas to management.

Management is ultimately responsible for the overall culture. However, bad cultures find plenty of eager employees. We are talking about skilled people able to find job elsewhere if the ethics was consideration - we are not talking about uneducated dudes having no choice.

Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by braveo on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:57PM (#14345048)
oh right, it's not the managements fault because the developers are the ones coming up with the nefarious ideas.
Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by ForHackernews on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:42PM (#14344930)
If developers were licensed professionals, they would have added backup to say "no" to managers making shady demands.

"I'm sorry, I can't do that, it's against my professional oath"

"That violates the software guild bylaws."

"I can't do that, I'd lose my license!"

Lawyers, accountants and other real professionals answer to higher principles than their boss.

Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by braveo on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:56PM (#14345046)
no it wouldn't, they would just hire someone who was willing to do it.
Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:54AM (#14348267)
They'd probably find someone willing to risk their license for extra money, but it still makes hiring such people more expensive, and could make the management rethink the whole idea.
Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by watwut on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:04PM (#14342635)
Good process - meaning testing by people motivated to find bugs would do hundred times more for security and quality then certification of individuals. Houses are not safe because of schools, they are safe because of building codes and fines of you break the code.
Re:Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2... by userbinator on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:05PM (#14346852)
a recognized right to refuse work based on ethical issues (backed by professional association)

One relevant "professional association" which comes to mind is the IEEE, which is actually pro-copyright/IP/DRM. Make of that what you will.