News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by panabee on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:00PM (#14309232)
It would be great to see more balanced discourse on monopolies, especially in a software-dominated world. Most analyses and articles fixate on the costs of monopolies.

Let's assume the worst of Google and conclude they abused their search monopoly. Innovation in search was stifled. Competitors were damaged and achieved only a fraction of their potential. For instance, Yelp might be worth $15B instead of $3B in a world without "evil" Google.

But Google's search monopoly and concomitant cash flows also gave society free worldwide communication, self-driving cars, cheaper smartphones, free digital maps, and countless other benefits.

All policies hurt some and help others.

Before supporting or rejecting a policy, it's wise to consider the overall benefits to society instead of focusing only on the injured parties. Why should thinking about monopolies differ?

To reiterate, this is neither endorsing nor disparaging monopolies. It's a request for objective analysis and updated thinking to reflect the potential new realities of monopolies like Google that give products away for free.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:26PM (#14309469)
>But Google's search monopoly and concomitant cash flows also gave society free worldwide communication, self-driving cars, cheaper smartphones, free digital maps, and countless other benefits.

To be clear you can't be sure those things wouldn't be around if google hadn't had a search monopoly. Maybe we would have even better digital maps for example had there been way more firms competing. Monopolies can't just be measured by the businesses that they outcompete but also in all the never-realized businesses who their market domination discouraged.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by rhino369 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:01PM (#14310691)
Plus, a lot of those products already existed. Mapquest was free digital maps. Everyone and their mother had free webmail and web chat.

Android didn't make smart phones cheap, maybe slightly cheaper, but not cheap.

Still waiting on self driving cars.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by panabee on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:41PM (#14309574)
Agreed that measuring a hypothetical world is impossible, but what do you suggest as a more fair and balanced analysis of monopolies?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:13PM (#14309816)
Oh boy, antitrust is my pet political issue so I apologize for my inability to maintain impartiality (and wall of text) in advance. I would say that America has gone through this debate already and perhaps we should look to our history. Take this:

The tremendous and highly complex industrial development which went on with ever accelerated rapidity during the latter half of the nineteenth century brings us face to face, at the beginning of the twentieth, with very serious social problems. The old laws, and the old customs which had almost the binding force of law, were once quite sufficient to regulate the accumulation and distribution of wealth. Since the industrial changes which have so enormously increased the productive power of mankind, they are no longer sufficient.

The growth of cities has gone on beyond comparison faster than the growth of the country, and the upbuilding of the great industrial centers has meant a startling increase, not merely in the aggregate of wealth, but in the number of very large individual, and especially of very large corporate, fortunes. The creation of these great corporate fortunes has not been due to the tariff nor to any other governmental action, but to natural causes in the business world, operating in other countries as they operate in our own.

The process has aroused much antagonism, a great part of which is wholly without warrant. It is not true that as the rich have grown richer the poor have grown poorer. On the contrary, never before has the average man, the wage-worker, the farmer, the small trader, been so well off as in this country and at the present time. There have been abuses connected with the accumulation of wealth; yet it remains true that a fortune accumulated in legitimate business can be accumulated by the person specially benefited only on condition of conferring immense incidental benefits upon others. Successful enterprise, of the type which benefits all mankind, can only exist if the conditions are such as to offer great prizes as the rewards of success.

The captains of industry who have driven the railway systems across this continent, who have built up our commerce, who have developed our manufactures, have on the whole done great good to our people. Without them the material development of which we are so justly proud could never have taken place. Moreover, we should recognize the immense importance of this material development of leaving as unhampered as is compatible with the public good the strong and forceful men upon whom the success of business operations inevitably rests. The slightest study of business conditions will satisfy anyone capable of forming a judgment that the personal equation is the most important factor in a business operation; that the business ability of the man at the head of any business concern, big or little, is usually the factor which fixes the gulf between striking success and hopeless failure.

Now this is Teddy Roosevelt in 1901 but tell me that doesn't sound an awful lot like today! And this is the president known as the trustbuster, speaking in general favor of business. I won't spell out how he reconciles this with his general opinion in favor of antitrust regulation because hopefully that hook can get you to read the rest of that speech here.[0] And here[1] is a speech by John Sherman. These are the men who convinced our country of the importance of antitrust over 100 years ago and much rings true today. Perhaps we should consider these arguments first so we can at least avoid retreading old ground.

And to plug one article I love, check out Bloom and Bust by Philip Longman[2]. He uses this quote from Woodrow Wilson in 1912:

Which do you want? Do you want to live in a town patronized by some great combination of capitalists who pick it out as a suitable place to plant their industry and draw you into their employment? Or do you want to see your sons and your brothers and your husbands build up business for themselves under the protection of laws which make it impossible for any giant, however big, to crush them and put them out of business, so that they can match their wits here, in the midst of a free country with any captain of industry or merchant of finance … anywhere in the world?

[0] http://www.emersonkent.com/speeches/controlling_the_trusts.h...

[1] https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=wu.89098552482;view=1...

[2] http://washingtonmonthly.com/magazine/novdec-2015/bloom-and-...

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ng12 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:40PM (#14309565)
How does Google's search monopoly lead them to self-driving cars? This is why I question the Google vs Bell comparison. It seems to me Google wins because they are really, really good at producing technology, not because they have a systematic first-comer advantage.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by Retric on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:58PM (#14309707)
Monopolies tend to be lest cost conscious. So, Google may be over investing in their self driving team which could cause a less efficient solution to win.

Picture the MBA where one team Q spends 100m/year per player to get the best players and more importantly keep them from other teams, but Q has a poor coaching staff. The fact Q keeps wining reduces the drive to replace that poor coaching staff, and other teams may fail to compete so they may give up on the playoffs instead focusing on cheaper players.

Not fast forward 20 years and the sport is overall in a worse position with Q lowering standards because nobody else is really competing. For a more relevant example consider the IE 6 stagnation before Firefox.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ng12 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:04PM (#14309752)
That's just economics at work though. The guy with more money to blow will always have an advantage.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by Retric on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:26PM (#14310894)
Not so much. The invisible hand of economics just means the less efficient or less desired producers are pushed out of the market. It's just that the guy with more money can often invest it to become more efficient.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ng12 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:51PM (#14311056)
Right, money is an advantage and big companies generally have lots of money. The point is Google is not unique in that regard.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by Retric on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:05PM (#14311157)
They are actually a massive outlier.

http://www.siliconbeat.com/2016/05/20/apple-microsoft-google...

While Apple has a larger total cash horde ~(216 billion) only 7% of that is in the US or 15B, Google has a larger US cash horde @$73B * 31% = 22.6B making it the largest accessible cash horde in the US.

PS: The ~$1.68 trillion in cash held by U.S. companies at the end of 2015 is kind of misleading as financial companies are required to hold cash on hand and thus can't use it for R&D or they are keeping money out of the US while waiting for a Tax holiday under Trump or possibly some other administration.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ng12 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:15PM (#14311242)
I'm not saying that Google doesn't compete on their cash reserves, I'm saying "so what"? Does having a lot of capital make you a monopoly? Should we penalize business for having cash to spend?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by Retric on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:28PM (#14311359)
Look at it from the other direction. I am saying one of the downsides of monopolies is they end up with a lot of capital, but they don't use it efficiently. At the core investing capital efficiently is a different skill.

Another way to look at it is after breaking up AT&T it created a lot of horribly dysfunctional companies. Verizon is a long way from greatness, but many of these guys where far worse and then went out of business because they where inefficient. Remember, it was the same people, tech, and business models before and after the breakup, but busting up AT&T exposed problems to market forces which then went away.

I am fine saying the rot has yet to set in at Google. But, give it 20 years and expect the same kind of problems because of human nature.

PS: Granted, this does not really answer your so what, but efficiency in the long term really is a boon to society.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by wildmusings on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:05PM (#14309758)
>How does Google's search monopoly lead them to self-driving cars? This is why I question the Google vs Bell comparison. It seems to me Google wins because they are really, really good at producing technology, not because they have a systematic first-comer advantage.

I don't think you can really call self-driving cars a win for Google at this point. It looks like they might be beat to market by actual car companies, which would be a really devastating outcome for Google.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by iandanforth on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:04PM (#14309750)
Rockefeller was an ardent proponent of Monopoly because to him it was obviously the most efficient system. He controlled the price paid for crude, the manufacture of oil, and the prices paid for transportation. Under this control he substantially lowered prices for the consumer. Of course this also meant that all profits went directly to him making him one of the richest people to have ever lived. Interestingly he also railed against using monopoly to price gouge. He could enforce minimum prices to preserve market stability but rarely charged exorbitant rates. That restraint however is not intrinsic to monopolies and, in fact, the contemporary populace had a hard time believing his motives weren't purely short-term and profit seeking.

Today Google might be in a similar situation where the thing that will take down their huge position of control is not bad behavior toward their end users but a well justified fear that that power can be abused (and would be abused by most people)

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by Unkechaug on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:50PM (#14310101)
So are you saying that this kind of situation is considered OK by most people's standards, so long as the party in control acts as a "benevolent dictator"?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by jlamberts on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:14PM (#14310306)
I think in theory most people would agree that a benevolent dictator is a good thing both economically (monopolies) and politically (actual dictators). The problem is that human nature gets in the way in both cases, so you can't really trust a company or a leader to stay benevolent (or that their successor will be even if they are).
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by rpiguy on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:19PM (#14310342)
Replace the words "benevolent dictator" with "winner." People go to Google by choice, they win based on consumer preference. Unlike say, Windows, there is nothing locking you into Google you don't have to use Chrome or GMAIl, or their search.

Yes a lot of people are okay with one company controlling 80% percent of a market if - they get there by relatively fair practices, there are clear and viable alternatives, and the consumer isn't forced to use them.

Now if the behavior of the "winner" starts to have clear, negative effects on consumers and consumers are no longer happy, the story changes considerably.

Maybe I could see an argument against the greater Google ecosystem (Android, Google Play, which does lock you into Google), or the distributor of content also being a content creator, etc.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by SXX on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:12PM (#14310789)
> Unlike say, Windows, there is nothing locking you into Google you don't have to use Chrome or GMAIl, or their search.

I agree about their search, but problem with Chrome isn't just lack of alternatives. Problem is that Google have too much power over web standards and all of competitors have to follow. Even Mozilla had to implement DRM.

Gmail is similar: Google never directly used their power against competitors, but they make email a lot more centralized. Their intransparent anti-spam make it much harder to run own mail servers or send notifications / newsletters, etc.

Of course almost any company with 60-80% of market share would likely do the same and this is why it's bad.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by lallysingh on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:36PM (#14310955)
Are the relevant standards bodies just puppets?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by SXX on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:41PM (#14311491)
None of them are independent. Members of W3C / WHATWG / etc work for Google or competitors. They all have to agree on something because with Chrome market share anything can be enforced anyway.

If there feature video on YouTube / Netflix won't play without everyone going to implement it anyway.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by maverick_iceman on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @06:09PM (#14312182)
Making their anti-spam operations transparent may be self-defeating, spammers may then be able to game the system.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by SXX on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @09:17PM (#14313237)
There are more ways to make it transparent than exposing anti-spam secrets and here is few random ideas. First of all there is already CA system and there no reason why there couldn't be system where you pay for signing certificate to make sure your mail is always delivered as long as certificate reputation remain high. Imperfect, yet that would be much more reliable than current lottery system.

Another way to improve situation is to get rid of shady black lists BS like Spamhaus and replace them with proper organizations. Google could also create some consortium to improve protocols, implement easy to use mail servers that send everything properly out-of-box, then enforce DKIM usage, etc.

But no, Google need nothing of it because they have huge market share and directly benefit when non-Gmail services become unreliable.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by yazan94 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @03:14PM (#14310804)
Well nothing locks you into Windows, you can always use a Linux distro.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by iandanforth on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:46PM (#14310580)
Quite the opposite. Even when there is a benevolent dictator its likely that most people will resent and fear concentration of wealth and power because the situation is so rare as to be unbelievable. Many of Rockefeller's contemporaries were also aspiring monopolists but didn't care too much about screwing the little guy so they could luxuriate in opulence.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by nabla9 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:20PM (#14310354)
Balanced discourse should start with everybody explaining what they mean with "monopoly" and not assuming that they know or others know how the term is used.

Monopoly power. It's clear that Google does not have pure monopoly. Google has so called monopoly power.

Monopoly power can create barriers to entry with different mechanisms. Some examples

* reduced number of competitors

* limit pricing

* set-up costs

* loyalty schemes

* vertical integration

* horizontal integration

* economies of scale

* network externality

Company or companies having monopoly power does not automatically mean that they have to be divided or cut down. It means that they have to work under more restrictive rules that disable some advantages of having monopoly power.

---

Personal analysis:

I think Google, FB, MS, Apple, Amazon are doing their best using their monopoly powers get leverage and creating internet economy where distributive innovations sell to the big players and they are able to maintain the monopoly.

How to deal with that is complex issue. Limiting monopoly powers should be done intelligently.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by stingrae on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:59PM (#14309713)
Pre-breakup, Bell Labs produced a very large percentage of the scientific/engineering breakthroughs that power our modern world.

The breakup arguably changed Bell Labs, hurting its ability to hire talent as well as its access to resources.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ticviking on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:11PM (#14309798)
It also freed their patent library and talent to develop a whole host of new products and technologies which lead pretty directly to Google and the WWW as we have it today.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by rayiner on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @01:42PM (#14310030)
The Xerox monopoly also produced a large percentage of the breakthroughs that power modern computer technology. It went into rapid decline after an antitrust settlement forced it to hand its patents over to Japanese competitors.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by rgbrenner on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:17PM (#14309382)
so if you do something good, you should be permitted some amount of illegal behavior? If you're a priest, perhaps you would be permitted 1 murder, in exchange for your good behavior over the years?

Is that what you're saying?

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by panabee on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:56PM (#14309687)
excellent straw man. :)

killing a person and killing a competitor are very different. if they were identical, jeff bezos would be serving 1000 life terms. :)

the desire to dissolve monopolies is based on frameworks defined decades ago. the question is whether these frameworks are as applicable today -- and in particular to software companies like google that do not charge consumers (with money).

perhaps these old frameworks remain applicable, but it's difficult to consider their conclusions valid if they are biased to only see harm. that would be like saying cars and airplanes are terrible because they ruined the railroad industry.

to reiterate, maybe society is worse off with monopolies. but one cannot credibly make this assertion without considering both the costs and benefits.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by nickik on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:47PM (#14309614)
Being a monopolist is not illigal. Also in the US Anti-Trust cases need to probe harm to consumer. This is not the progressive area where you can just use Anti-Trust law against any company you don't like.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by rgbrenner on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:52PM (#14309655)
3rd sentence from the parent I was replying to: "Let's assume the worst of Google and conclude they abused their search monopoly."
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by karajima on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:27PM (#14309479)
Well, if that 'murder' was an execution of a convicted criminal. Why not?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by kingbirdy on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:34PM (#14309521)
I know MapQuest is pretty bad but I don't think Google Maps out competing it is equivalent to executing a convict.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ionised on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:01AM (#14323998)
Because the death penalty is dumb?
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by dkarapetyan on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:49PM (#14309625)
You should use quotes around free.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by JustSomeNobody on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:57PM (#14309692)
Exactly. My data is a currency and I have to spend some of it to get those services.
Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by thr0waway1239 on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @04:17PM (#14311269)
>> Let's assume the worst of Google and conclude they abused their search monopoly. Innovation in search was stifled. Competitors were damaged and achieved only a fraction of their potential. For instance, Yelp might be worth $15B instead of $3B in a world without "evil" Google.

Abuse manifests itself in many ways, only one of which is the stifling of innovation.

Let us consider the lookalike audience feature in Facebook and Google. You, the engineer, are tasked with improving the efficiency of the system. You are told that a 1% improvement in the effectiveness of this targeting produces like a gazillion dollars in the company's bank account.

You start by running some numbers to understand the effectiveness of the current system. You need some metrics to do this, obviously. One metric is the click through rate of an ad when it targets a certain lookalike segment, which is probably easy to measure. But then you see if it lead to a purchase - but how can you do this? In the world of ad-ROI measurement, this is like the last mile - the so called click attribution problem.

You come up with the following suggestions to your bosses:

1. Capture more of the data going through the inter-pipes. Create Google Analytics so you know who goes to which website. Have people logged in to Facebook permanently, often without their knowledge. Make apps which ask for all kinds of permissions which they don't need. Create devices which are capable of tracking anything you want, and you control the switch remotely.

2. Buy every company in sight which might have collected some reasonable amount of data

3. Start making data triangulations. Collect and purchase datasets which allow more of this.

4. To get people to spend more with you, expand the size of the smallest sized lookalike segments (larger surface area for ad targeting). This will at some point take you back to steps 1, 2 and 3.

Imagine all this going on at Google and Facebook scale.

But wouldn't this all happen even when there are no monopolies? Perhaps, but there would be a lot of potential for data brokerages. And those data brokerages, not unlike markets of goods and services, will start assigning accurate prices for personal information. The monopolies are preventing these data brokerages from being created. They are cutting out the middlemen, so to speak. And more often than not, they are doing it with the sort of impunity that was inconceivable even a few years ago. Right now, no one really knows if their personal information is worth anything. But if it wasn't worth anything, then Facebook to a larger extent and Google to a smaller extent, wouldn't be nearly as profitable. There are many startups being created today which don't want to call themselves that, but are glorified data brokerages with the explicit goal of being acquired by a tech giant to get a big payout in return for the consolidation of often private information.

For example, around 2012 I heard of the idea of 'privacy lockers' where people will put their personal information and all companies will have access to it, but for a price. Imagine that! If that had actually come into existence, Facebook would have been acquired by the privacy locker company of course. Which in some ways only leads us back to the original problem.

So the next question is whether this consolidation in and of itself is a bad thing? I don't know, is a nuclear weapon dangerous when it is controlled by a madman? It is worse in some ways. We can't be certain about either the potency of the weapon (private data) or the sanity of the people in charge (corporate motivations).

There will be a reset button at some point. Splitting up the companies into smaller entities seems like a hasty conclusion today. When (not if) these tech giants cross some unacceptable privacy boundaries, the resulting backlash is going to result in a lot of wistful "wish we could go back in time when splitting was still an option" thoughts.

Re:“Google Is as Close to a Natural Monopoly as the Bell Sys... by ionised on Friday May 12, 2017 @09:51AM (#14323927)
> also gave society free worldwide communication

How is that now?