Re:Get started making music
by komali2 on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:27PM
(#14302054)
Is Apple's Garageband free? I thought you need to own an OSX device to run it? (my understanding is OSX only runs on Apple hardware and also is not a free OS)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yes, it's "free" (not open source). It's included with the purchase of a Mac.
The point is, that kind of free is marketing speak. More accurately, you can purchase Garageband as part of a package including Apple hardware. Or you could say Apple hardware is free with the purchase of Garageband.
Not any more.
Re:Get started making music
by Nullabillity on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @05:46PM
(#14304067)
So no, it's not even gratis, it's $500+ depending on how crappy hardware you want it to be tethered to.
That's a slippery slope to saying that OpenOffice for Windows isn't free software either because you have to buy a Windows box. This is not a useful definition of free you're using. GarageBand is not Libre software.
I dunno if it's a slippery slope starting at Garageband. I say the slippery slope starts at OpenOffice or GoogleDocs or something along those lines, given that OpenOffice could probably be run on a potato if you can find a way to install ubuntu on it and stick some RAM into it.
Re:Get started making music
by thomastjeffery on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @06:43PM
(#14304470)
That's absurd, since OpenOffice runs in Linux, and is free, as in freedom.
when it comes to getting software, we've stopped including the price of the required computer since like… 1995?
Re:Get started making music
by quadrangle on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:43PM
(#14302231)
Garageband is completely non-free/libre/open which seems what you are saying