News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by pgodzin on Sunday May 07, 2017 @06:55PM (#14288172)
Seems like demining is done manually - slow and dangerous. I'm surprised we can't build the tech to identify mines and extract them safely.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by jdietrich on Monday May 08, 2017 @12:28AM (#14289253)
Large areas of reasonably flat land can be demined very quickly using a demining machine. It's a large armored vehicle with a set of rotating flails on the front, similar in appearance to a combine harvester. The flails detonate the mines, while a thick steel scoop deflects the blast away from the vehicle. It's a low-tech but very effective approach.

The problem in the Falklands is that demining machines are very destructive of habitat. A demining machine effectively ploughs the land - a useful side-effect if you're clearing agricultural land, but a serious problem if you're clearing a nature reserve.

http://www.gichd.org/resources/publications/detail/publicati...

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mschuster91 on Sunday May 07, 2017 @07:35PM (#14288295)
Any robot capable of doing the neccessary manual digging would be so heavy it 'd certainly trigger the mines; also as you can see in the photos the land is not flat but highly varied, so a robot cannot drive there.

Another thing that makes demining really tedious is the amount of scrap metal in the earth - and if it's former farm land that's been mined it's bound to have loads of metal in it, mostly remains of agricultural equipment, and on the minestrips of former Yugoslavia you often enough hit archeological artifacts during mine-clearing.

If you wanted to do automated demining, you'd need:

1) scanner technology that can differentiate between scrap metal and mines, as well as penetrate at least 1-2m into the ground

2) robots on 2 legs and with 2 arms - basically, humanoid robots. Anything other is only usable on flat fields.

3) robots must be able to conquer vast amounts of vegetation. For example, the Yugoslavian wars were 2 decades ago - many of the minestrips that are still not cleared up are in the backside of the country and heavily overgrown by everything from grass to massive trees now. (Source: am half Croatian, seen some minefields)

4) robots with high-quality visual processing. The most devious mines are those that have been hidden in / masqueraded as stuff like old cans, soccer balls or other stuff that children pick up, play with it and boooom. Any robot which has to do demining in such areas must be able to detect and avoid these.

5) cheap robots. A single robot with above capabilities will run well into the 8-figures at the moment (esp. due to #2), a human is cheaper (especially as there's protective armor available that helps to prevent or soften severe injuries).

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by SomeStupidPoint on Sunday May 07, 2017 @10:39PM (#14288887)
I don't see why 4 legs wouldn't work.

We see 4 legged animals in forests and on mountains, seeming to donjust fine navigating the terrain (and often doing better than humans).

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by thaumasiotes on Sunday May 07, 2017 @11:04PM (#14288960)
Nah, it just can't be done unless you have two legs and two arms.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by PhasmaFelis on Monday May 08, 2017 @12:56AM (#14289352)
> Any robot capable of doing the neccessary manual digging would be so heavy it 'd certainly trigger the mines

Hm. Could you use light bots to search out and mark the mines, and send in diggers only once the area has been thoroughly inspected? Of course that just makes everything even more complicated...

How much of normal mine clearance is searching vs. removing? Is there any advantage to robots that mark mines for manual removal, or is that already the "easy" part?

> 1) scanner technology that can differentiate between scrap metal and mines, as well as penetrate at least 1-2m into the ground

Forgive me if this is naive, but do mines actually get buried 2m deep? I would think that would be unfeasibly difficult. Or are we thinking of shallower mines that were buried by natural soil movement?

> 2) robots on 2 legs and with 2 arms - basically, humanoid robots. Anything other is only usable on flat fields.

It could conceivably be helpful to use a robot that can cover moderately rugged terrain. You'd still need to use manual methods on the rougher patches, but it might at least reduce the size of the problem.

I realize it's probably unfeasibly expensive no matter what, but it's interesting to think about the problem.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by salgernon on Sunday May 07, 2017 @08:44PM (#14288533)
I was going to cite stories about random walk simple robotics being used to clear mines in Afghanistan- think lawnmower powered beach balls. But apparently this isn't as effective as I'd thought:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4808061

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by pgodzin on Sunday May 07, 2017 @08:52PM (#14288563)
Well those actually explode them right? Don't want to do that here to avoid disrupting the ecosystem
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by pgodzin on Sunday May 07, 2017 @07:54PM (#14288358)
Thanks for breaking that down. Didn't think about the need to differentiate between scrap and mine. And yes I was thinking specifically about this instance on the beach which faces much fewer issues than areas covered with vegetation.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mschuster91 on Sunday May 07, 2017 @07:59PM (#14288380)
The problem on the beach is not vegetation, yes, but uneven land and especially sand and salt water.

While a tank or an AK47 might work in this environment as intended, a robot with fine gears and other relatively delicate moving parts will have trouble with the sand... and the corrosive sea water environment. It will require an extensive amount of maintenance.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by kobeya on Monday May 08, 2017 @06:12AM (#14290432)
That's kinda the design requirement though, isn't it? If it were easy to detect and remove, they wouldn't have served their jobs.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by abrowne on Sunday May 07, 2017 @09:54PM (#14288759)
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by partiallypro on Sunday May 07, 2017 @11:09PM (#14288980)
Or we could genetically modify the penguins to be heavy enough to set off the mines
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by robotresearcher on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:44AM (#14289497)
Add front legs and wool and you have a sheep. Which they have on the Falklands already.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by partiallypro on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @09:49PM (#14313348)
GMO Penguins sound way cooler
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by CPLX on Monday May 08, 2017 @02:06AM (#14289575)
Rodents of unusual size? I don't think they exist.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by cgio on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:04AM (#14290184)
You have not been to Australia obviously. Tell that to the possum gracefully munching flowers outside my window.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mason240 on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:13AM (#14291160)
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by throwanem on Monday May 08, 2017 @05:55AM (#14290361)
Eh. On the one hand, that's a marsupial; on the other, possum-sized rats aren't at all unusual in Baltimore, and I gather in other cities as well.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by Lio on Monday May 08, 2017 @08:37AM (#14290988)
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by yuubi on Monday May 08, 2017 @08:57AM (#14291075)
I think a capybara's size is unusual for a rodent, but YMMV.