News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by amasad on Monday May 01, 2017 @06:49PM (#14242462)
This is just bad epistemology.

>As a consequence, if you, with your puny human brain, want to understand why AlphaGo chose a particular move, the “explanation” may well consist of the networks of weighted connections that then pass their outcomes to the next layer of the neural network. Your brain can’t remember all those weights, and even if it could, it couldn’t then perform the calculation that resulted in the next state of the neural network.

Why did you reduce the neural network to the connections and layers but maintained the “brain” at the level of the whole? If you want to compare apples to apples you should also reduce the brain to neurons and connections. When a ball is about to hit your face your brain “can’t remember how to calculate the velocity and acceleration of the ball and predict that in 100ms it will impact your face and thus you need to send a signal for your hand to move to cover your face”. Yet we do it, how? Well, it’s encoded in the complex system of nerves and networks just like the the information about the various potential Go boards and moves is encoded in the neural network.

>And even if it could, you would have learned nothing about how to play Go, or, in truth, how AlphaGo plays Go — just as internalizing a schematic of the neural states of a human player would not constitute understanding how she came to make any particular move.

Similarly if you were to study the neurons, nerves, and networks and their firing patterns that are involved in protecting your face from the ball you wouldn’t learn anything about balls, acceleration or even pain.

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by throwaway87423 on Monday May 01, 2017 @10:20PM (#14243502)
> When a ball is about to hit your face your brain “can’t remember how to calculate the velocity and acceleration of the ball and predict that in 100ms it will impact your face and thus you need to send a signal for your hand to move to cover your face”.

It's likely doing optical flow calculations (much simpler), rather than integrating an ODE. Richard Dawkins apparently makes the same mistake about "catching a ball" in his book.

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by mockery on Monday May 01, 2017 @11:35PM (#14243774)
By 'optical flow calculations' do you mean a linear extrapolation of the projected 'image-space' position of the ball?

If so, that seems like it would be insufficient since a thrown object doesn't move linearly, let alone its projection.

If not, then I'm curious what you're describing, and how it's much simpler than integrating an ODE?

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by throwaway87423 on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @01:44AM (#14244195)
Not quite. If you're interested take a look at,

https://youtu.be/eKaYnXQUb2g?t=6m10s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iz9UVIo_ZUo&list=PL0AknDL1Vt...

Camera homography preserves straight-lines, but it also gives a heuristic to avoid obstacles. Apparently this is also how bees and birds navigate.

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by laretluval on Monday May 01, 2017 @07:08PM (#14242591)
Are you arguing that we "understand" the opaque computations in our brain because they happen in our brain?

That is pretty clearly not a useful definition of understanding.

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by amasad on Monday May 01, 2017 @07:48PM (#14242824)
No, I didn't say that. I only brought up the brain and involuntary computation to point out the false equivalency.
Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by goatlover on Monday May 01, 2017 @08:40PM (#14243092)
So we understand what AlphaGo or our brains do at an abstract level, but not how they accomplish what they do.
Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by randyrand on Monday May 01, 2017 @07:21PM (#14242668)
Not only that, but they're forgetting time.

A brain 2x the size does not mean it must learn twice as much, or can understand 2x more complicated things. But may just mean it can learn twice as fast.

Re:Our Machines Now Have Knowledge We’ll Never Understand by deepsun on Monday May 01, 2017 @09:01PM (#14243195)
I often hear "brain size" argument, and can't help but remind that crow birds (brain mass: 13g) are smarter than sperm whales (8,000g). By "smarter" here I mean performing human (1,300g) IQ tests better.