A lot of successful Google products were acquired (Android, YouTube) and others were able to leverage their dominance in search. But we also saw that approach fail when the entire company was directed at trying to beat Facebook. It infiltrated all their existing properties and employees were directly incentivized with compensation linked to the success of Google+. And yet all of that wasn't able to overcome Facebook's network effect. The go-to Google strategy for creating a hit product failed (and it also explains why they seem to fail at anything that has network effects or requires consumer affinity and brand: 8 messengers and countless failed hardware products).
Google stands a good chance of being the next Xerox PARC: good at science projects and technology, but destined to see others capitalize on it.
And it makes sense if you think about it. Google's origin story was 2 PhDs coming up with better technology in a market that was already defined and a business model that was already understood. They applied that technology well, but it was only possible because of the openness of the web. It feels very much right place, right time.
Sure it could be the next Xerox PARC, but the next Apple (following the bad metaphor) will very likely be a division of Google itself.
And finally, if anything, Google's ability to kill products that it does not think valuable, is what keeps it innovating, exploring and yet not be a dinosaur search company. (I do miss Google Reader though. Did they really have to kill it so bad ? )
> Android, YouTube
First off, Android didn't even exist as a product yet when Google acquired it, and YouTube was popular but nowhere near the behemoth it is now. Taking those things and turning them into world beating juggernauts is a very non-trivial task; as you've probably noticed, most corporate acquisitions of startups have a very different outcome.
And Google is making money by removing more and more "free" listings and replacing them ads and their content. Morality aside, eventually they'll lose their effectiveness.
If it's so simple why aren't there other companies doing the same?
> Morality aside, eventually they'll lose their effectiveness.
People have said this for the last ten years. Sure, if you cry wolf long enough you will probably be correct at some point, but does this offer any insight?
Google is absolutely horrible at UI and application design, I can't think of any product that doesn't mostly suck from a UI perspective. Scale & speed is obviously a different story.
When I load Google.com, I should see the Google logo and at the bottom of a page a "click to continue reading" button that I should, well, click. Then as I continue to scroll down the search entry field should scroll up the page as the Google logo slowly fades out behind it. Searching should feel like an event.
But seriously, I love that Google keeps their search website so minimal. I think that takes courage.
The line should never be level. This is the worst position to be in. It means you're not doing anything at all.
Because the "simple" strategy is predicated on a market-dominant search product. It was simple for them, but extremely hard for anyone else—because Step 1 is "supplant Google with 75% market share".
Using your established brand to propel a new product is business 101 and building a whole web of closely related products is business 302.
The synergy between their many major products is quite astonishing (though it is not public knowledge).
Simple? Tell that to anyone else doing search.
You're missing the point. I think this is part of what defines their existence and probably their success; experiment with many different products/services (and do it quickly too), doesn't matter if you have 1 killer product for every 10,000 experiments.
For me, Google is a failure under the very same rule that makes MBA-driven businesses a failure for society. I.e. I'd actually prefer more business to be Google-like "failures".
For example, talk what you like about how Android is crap, but who'd you trust more with mobile OS - Google, or Samsung? Siemens? Oracle?
I will agree that Google seems lackluster at network effect related things and I find that they are generally very poor at marketing.
Building things that you consider failed is going to be a natural consequence of finding things that work because you gotta try things to know. As for Google finance if it isn't broke why change it? Don't confuse change with improvement.
MBA's are ANTITHETICAL to entrepreneurship. That doesn't mean an MBA doesn't have value towards starting a company, just like a degree in economics or history aren't irrelevant to starting a company. But it's not what it's for, in fact, it's for the opposite thing.
This is the average over all schools in their global ranking, and the US has most positions in the top 25 [1].
Meanwhile, only ~300 persons for every 100k start companies per month in the US [2]. Even assuming none start more than one per four years (which is doubtful), that's only 14.4% of the overall population over four years.
[1] https://www.ft.com/content/cbd9b418-314c-11e6-bda0-04585c31b...
[2] http://www.kauffman.org/~/media/kauffman_org/research%20repo...
In reality, business schools around the world turn out people who are qualified to start and run a company, and this includes R&D processes. Some people may choose electives that lead to middle-management, but others can and do choose electives in starting up, product development, service process design, negotiations etc etc.
This is garbage. Unmitigated, sweeping, unknowing drivel. I understand your claim perfectly well, and you are flat wrong, and apparently from a position of zero awareness. I can correct you authoritatively because a) I have actually completed an MBA, and b) it was one that included comparative studies of R&D processes in the case work and a team-based competitive simulation of managing R&D processes. Along with a toolkit of knowledge that made company formation and launch much easier. This has, as I say, all been super useful in actually building my business.
Moving the goalposts to some nineteenth-century context and claiming it's the same thing is, as I said, simply doubling down on the wrong. Also irrelevant.
The only exception to this I know is Babson, but I'm not certain whether they qualify their entrepreneurship degree as an MBA or not. I think they don't, but if they do I may have missed the mark by 1. Otherwise what I said is correct.
I think I'm done here; having presented real-world counterexamples, your claim, which was a gross and simplistic misrepresentation, is dead.
You think I'm moving the ball to something meaningless because you want to debate the value of an MBA and I don't.
The electives that have been most useful to this startup: "Entrepreneurship & New Value Creation", "Managing Service Businesses", "Negotiations", "Mergers & Acquisitions", "Business Law".
Amongst other outcomes, these units a) quite radically changed my perspective on matters pertaining to value creation & capture - which was especially surprising for someone with two decades meandering experience across many different product & service development gigs - and b) gave me the analytical tools & confidence I needed to put my ideas into practice.
The robots are great at doing one thing well by hook or crook. Problem is with scale and speed that come with large orgs, the good little robots follow their programming and over optimize the heck out of one little variable. The environment has no time to adapt. Massive unrecoverable collateral damage happens. But the robots are all very pleased with themselves cause their one little self worth defining metric has been met. But as nature already demonstrates highly virulent viruses like these cannot sustain themselves long term. This robot class will die out sooner or later cause the cost for destabilizing the ecosystem every couple days is just too high.
Startups usually do most of the r&d now, and once it gets to small/mid level and "the process" comes in, the bizdevs take over after it is usually already an established product and r&d mostly completed. Depending on the balance of that takeover it either kills the product, slowly bleeds it, or if the focus is still on product then sometimes a super growth engine.
Companies that can keep a focus on r&d, building and changing markets while being very efficient are key. Usually these are engineer led (Amazon, Tesla, Google etc)