A better case is: you are a healthcare worker. A federal agent asks you about your ex-employer. You always had a bad feeling about that company but you put in your 40 hours for your paycheck and kids' health insurance. Perfectly willing to help the investigation, you answer truthfully. You are asked about a co-worker you slept with after you had met your girlfriend, but before you started dating. Your girlfriend is in the room. Thinking it doesn't matter and not wanting to discuss it with a stranger in front of your girlfriend, you lie. Turns out the co-worker was involved. If the prosecutor decides he doesn't like you, congratulations you are now a federal felon. You don't even need a fun story about a personal relationship: say you misremember something. Or someone else does, and contradicts your truthful story but the feds think you're the one who's lying.
Also I'm not sure the label "criminal" is a useful one. It's almost certainly the case that every adult US citizen is a criminal. They simply haven't been caught yet. Every modern US president has admitted in public to being a criminal (drugs). The expanse of laws is so vast, vague, complex, interpretable and arbitrary it's impossible to not break one. If there were consequences for every lawbreaking act, everyone would be in jail and there would be no-one left to prosecute or to do the prosecuting.
I agree that the labels aren't helpful, but it's vitally important to society that employees don't kid themselves about their responsibility (and culpability). Many employees are paid and treated abusively by their employers. Nonetheless, they cannot allow themselves to become instruments of crimes.
To be fair, the statute does say you must knowingly and willingly be lying. Theoretically, that would be on the feds to prove. Of course, I don't think it's possible to prove whether someone knows something. But if they can prove that you at one time did know, or with a perfect memory should have known... I don't know how that works. Would it be a coin flip at that point whether the jury would believe that you simply "misremembered"?
1. Worked with you.
2. Is neck-deep in the criminal enterprise.
3. Is testifying for the promise of leniency of immunity.
4. And is quite happy to throw the CEO, the CFO, and, since the FBI asked him about your name, you under the bus.
Regardless of whether or not his claims are true, he will be happy to testify that yes, you absolutely knew about the criminality, because you discussed it with him at lunch, and did nothing about it.
This may, or may not be true. He may or may not have misremembered this conversation. He may be trying to save his ass. Either way, it's your word against his, and the prosecutor, who pleads to the jury that there is no possible way you didn't know about your involvement.
You may well be found innocent, but you never want to put yourself in this position. Talking to the police is just giving them more rope to try to hang you with.
Harvey Silverglate, a Harvard law grad who works as an attorney, estimates the average American commits three felonies per day. He published an entire book on the topic[1]. The number is probably a lot higher for people who have built or served as directors of a company.
1) http://thinkaboutnow.com/2016/07/average-americans-commit-3-...
The most commonly commotted one is lying to an employer to claim a paid sick today... And frankly it's unclear to me why people thing that's acceptable, but taking $100 from a convenient store cash register is not.
Another common one is people borrowing parents from their parents to make a down payment on a house. Lots of people do it, but the sentence for using such a loan and not disclosing it is 30 years.
This particular violation is referred to as a "head shot" by investigators looking for something with which to nail a suspect.
http://davidsimon.com/kwame-brown-another-federal-case-anoth...
This doesn't detract from your point! Any felony conviction is a nightmare for someone just trying to build up a down payment for a house! But the way we talk about sentencing needs to be more sophisticated.
Uber was literally hiring contractors for the purpose of breaking the law, in one case actively recruited a driver from a county where it was was legal to a county where it was illegal (driver was arrested), provided drivers training on how to avoid police detection, and even provided at least Miami drivers a lawyer when charged (lawyer was an Uber lobbiest not a traffic lawyer).
Net impact on society: a bunch of rides subsidized by VC money and a lot of unemployed/underemployed workers left with marks on their driving record or criminal records which likely caused them to lose their Uber job and further hurting their chances of future employment.
Very few people care about the direct negative externalities you mentioned, including here in HN.
Nobody should have criminal liability for actions they took on the direction of their employer, while the employer gets away without consequence. Otherwise we should all get law degrees for free.
If you don't want to come out and point blank refuse you can always say that you can't do it because you're not that good. That's a perfectly valid excuse and one that I've used on occasion. (Long story, maybe one day.)
Most people don't have that flexibility.
> chose I think a really terrible example, one that creates a false sense of what it means for someone to be incidentally and unjustly swept up in a crime
I think the author chose an example from their own experience. Just because it seems ridiculous, doesn't change its accuracy.
I think it is quite relevant because it gets past the people who "can't believe that such a thing would happen to them".
actively committing a crime ("stealing cars") v. passively committing a crime (failing to do something or looking the other way)
Also ignoring intent, People don't unintentionally steal a car. People can unintentionally fill out a form or misunderstand or be unaware of the requirements of the law.
Additionally, theft is ingrained into the fabric of society and religion. Following some sort of government reporting requirement is not included in any religious teaching that I am aware of.
I am talking instead about a situation where an employee knows the organization is corrupt, and then knowingly and actively participates in some of those criminal actions. You can't deliver vouchers you know to be fraudulent. If you do, you are and should be criminally liable. Large-scale organized fraud depends in part on the willingness of every cog in the organization to perpetuate the criminal enterprise.
At least as reported, petty theft seems quite rare; poor people qualify for food stamps, food banks, etc., or just beg/panhandle for money, so there aren't many cases. This profile of them suggests most shoplifters do it more for the thrill than any kind of necessity: http://www.shopliftingprevention.org/what-we-do/learning-res...
Most people really don't have the flexibility to not quit. See, if you don't then you could easily end up in the kind of trouble that will cause your life to go right off the good path and onto a terrible one. Keep in mind that simply committing one crime makes you more likely to commit others just because you are now vulnerable. That tactic has caused many smart and otherwise good people to lose their bearings.
Because at the end of the day, you know you can probably get away with institutional crime quite easily, but not with petty theft. And most people know what the consequences of the latter are, but not so for the former.
I'm not suggesting it, I'm saying it.
I am NOT saying "feels" - I am saying "they do NOT have the flexibility to quit".
For example, my sister and her husband do not have that flexibility. They are at the limit of what their "barely above minimum wage" jobs support. They have some savings and they are very good about managing their resources; however they are a job loss or injury away from going negative and both work in jobs that are physically demanding.
https://www.popehat.com/2015/05/29/dennis-hastert-and-federa...
If you take a job at a health provider that you later learn is corrupt, and later knowingly transport false vouchers as part of your job while otherwise avoiding direct participation with the more overtly criminal parts of the enterprise, you are a criminal. What you're doing is wrong. Put into that situation unexpectedly, you must either quit, or immediately report your employer (and, presumably, then quit). You can't knowingly accept a paycheck from a criminal enterprise if doing so requires you to help carry out criminal actions. The law says that's criminal, but even if you don't care about that, so does the social contract.
Are you less culpable than the owners? Sure, of course you are. But this article chose I think a really terrible example, one that creates a false sense of what it means for someone to be incidentally and unjustly swept up in a crime they themselves tried to avoid.
We in this industry all need to be taking more responsibility for our individual actions and the net impact they have on society.