News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by kcorbitt on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:15PM (#14199082)
I understand how hedonism could seem appealing. But when I consider my own life experiences, I find that the happiest people I know are all motivated by some "higher calling," although the callings in question vary widely, and may seem distasteful or simply trivial to a third party. By contrast, I don't know that I've ever met someone who pursued pleasure for pleasure's sake and felt truly satisfied with their life. Others may have different experiences, so take from that what you will.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by freeflight on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:05AM (#14201292)
While I agree that growth can happen trough struggle (which does not equate suffering!), I have a very hard time believing that most living things are actively looking for suffering or pain.

What living things do you know that go actively out of their way to experience pain and suffering? Such a behavior would be highly disadvantageous to any species and would run counter to the most basic instincts of all things living. We have pain receptors for a reason, that reason ain't that we just gotta learn to "enjoy the pain". As such I would argue that all living things live their lives on a rather hedonistic basis.

Equally, it could be argued that if "having a calling" makes you "suffer less", because you've found a purpose for your life while a lack of purpose can lead to suffering, then having a calling might just as well be considered a hedonistic lifestyle choice.

The notion that pain and suffering are something that needs to happen to "pull trough" is trough and trough a human invention among the same lines as proper "working virtues".

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by literallycancer on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:32AM (#14202395)
>What living things do you know that go actively out of their way to experience pain and suffering? Such a behavior would be highly disadvantageous to any species and would run counter to the most basic instincts of all things living. We have pain receptors for a reason, that reason ain't that we just gotta learn to "enjoy the pain". As such I would argue that all living things live their lives on a rather hedonistic basis.

What about extreme sports? Extreme meaning ultra-marathons here, not jumping off buildings and rocks.

I'd say if you live a too sheltered existence where you avoid all negative feelings, you will have a very bad time in a crisis. So choosing to experience suffering is an insurance of sorts, learning to manage it so that you can function when it's really needed.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by jbrown on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:27AM (#14202730)
> What living things do you know that go actively out of their way to experience pain and suffering?

There are plenty of masochists out there in the world. Recently there was a pretty clear example of this described in the popular podcast S-Town.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by freeflight on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:56PM (#14208610)
Masochists are the outlier that pretty much always exists and are a rather bad example because humans are the only species with the luxury of possibly having such a, rather destructive, trait among their population.

Afaik there are no wild animals exhibiting behavior that's comparable to human masochism if animals with comparable traits existed they most likely went extinct because going out of your way to actively look for "pain and suffering" is a rather big disadvantage in the grand game of survival.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by jbrown on Thursday April 27, 2017 @12:35AM (#14209194)
> Afaik there are no wild animals exhibiting behavior that's comparable to human masochism

The context of this whole discussion is hedonism, utilitarianism, ethical theory, and philosophy in general. These ideas don't exist (to our knowledge) amongst animals, so I don't find it convincing to use animals to support your argument.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by freeflight on Friday April 28, 2017 @09:01PM (#14224372)
>These ideas don't exist (to our knowledge) amongst animals, so I don't find it convincing to use animals to support your argument.

But aren't we humans just that, animals? While the concept of ethical hedonism is of a rather philosophical nature, I still think the basic definition of hedonism translates very well into actual nature.

At least when hedonism is defined as "strive for pleasure and happiness" while evading "pain and suffering" there should be no issue applying this to other animals because we know for a fact that animals, besides humans, are able of these emotions and feelings.

What we don't know is if other animals actively reflect about these things. But that's a matter of motivation and not actual observed behavior, if we go by observed behavior than pretty much all living things are living a "hedonistic lifestyle".

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by pjc50 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @06:56AM (#14202023)
"Through" and "trough" are different words.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by jbrown on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:34AM (#14202776)
I've heard an accent that has trouble pronouncing the English "th" sound, instead approximating it with more of a "t" sound that misses the tongue thrust. Maybe that is what's happening here?
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by sjcsjc on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:50AM (#14202505)
Since the misspelling was repeated, this could actually be a helpful comment.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by freeflight on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @10:02PM (#14208646)
Sorry about that, I'm not a native speaker so I sometimes confuse words that sound similar. Grammarly is usually pretty good about pointing stuff like that out, sadly it failed me this time.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by peterwwillis on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:34AM (#14200656)
Most of us probably relate to the experiences of the people we are around the most. I've never met anyone who has told me they felt truly satisfied with their life, and I know I will never be. I thought that was one of life's virtues... What good is a cup running over if you never drink from it? And if you drink, is it still full? My point is, I need a glass of wine...
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by Retric on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:11AM (#14202622)
Hedonism like anything else can be done poorly. The first and most important step is to optimize for what you actually enjoy and not just use the greedy algorithm of what feels good this second. The goal is to align effort with actual reward and not maximize meaningless numbers like total income.

Do you enjoy taking a lazy morning with 30 minutes of quiet reflection each day? Great, but don't assume that means you would be happy maximizing that and living in a monistic life.

The cost benefit on drugs is really complex for example, but so is having a committed relationship, or any other major life choice. That does not mean you should ignore the actual complexity of life, rather you should actually consider the cost benefits of where you live, what you do etc etc.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by true_religion on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:28PM (#14199513)
Would you characterize people with a higher calling as content or actually visibly happy each and every day?
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by jasikpark on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:33PM (#14200027)
I would call them alive. They might not be happy everyday. There is always time to be sad, and to be angry, and to just stare into the void and realize how screwed up life is sometimes, but I would say that if you have a higher calling, it's much easier to be happy in a less hedonistic way.

Actually: yeah, I just basically described contentedness. Though there is definitely a difference between contentedness and complacency.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by raducu on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:03AM (#14202566)
Nobody is happy each and every day, that's impossible given human nature.

There are however people who are satisfied and content with their life almost every day.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by ziikutv on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:15PM (#14199966)
Agreed. For me, I noticed that I am always seeking for an answer. A magical key that will unlock everything lol. I do not mean from a religious POV. I just mean things like..if I do X, Y will happen which will lead to Z, so on and so forth.

Related to this: Instead of Hendonism, I am getting into Stoicism; of course adapting it to 'modern day'.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by mcguire on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:13AM (#14200379)
Epicureanism and Stoicism start from very different principles, but they kind of get to the same place. As for me, apathy isn't all that appealing, and a philosophy based on seeking something seems better than one based on avoiding something.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by ci5er on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:17PM (#14200178)
Either I have mis-read stoicism, or you have, or I misunderstand you, or a combination of the above.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by ziikutv on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:47PM (#14200291)
Edited paragraph. Those were two separate topics.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by ci5er on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:53PM (#14200312)
Well, then, post-edit, good on you, mate.

Still sounds like you might be getting a bit mystical with both the old and the new. You might want to play around with extreme spiritual skepticism to get your grounding before launching off with any sort of practice with any expectations. But, you know, hey! YMMV.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by che_shirecat on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:23PM (#14200199)
there's no seeking for an answer in stoicism. the answer is already there, both within and in nature, revealed day by day through living a virtuous life. unrelated - you're using semicolons incorrectly.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by ziikutv on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:46PM (#14200287)
Two unrelated paragraphs :).
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by coldtea on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:41AM (#14200707)
>But when I consider my own life experiences, I find that the happiest people I know are all motivated by some "higher calling," although the callings in question vary widely,

That's true. Hedonism is a treadmill (no pun intended) like most other traps. Heroin users are also hedonists...

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by Neliquat on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:46AM (#14201486)
Maybe the 1st few times... after that you are avoiding pain, rather than chasing pleasure. It is a small, but important distinction.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by coldtea on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @07:34AM (#14202148)
When you're chasing pleasure the first times, you're avoiding pain too. Not many totally happy with their lives people get into heroin...
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by zer0tonin on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @05:47AM (#14201742)
That's the whole treadmill concept.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by voidz on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:55AM (#14201247)
Until they run out of heroin..
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by empath75 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:49PM (#14199618)
If people are following the 'higher calling' because that makes them happy, then that is hedonism.
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by coldtea on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:45AM (#14200721)
Not really. The same circular reasoning can be used to make altruism selfish, etc.

It makes far more sense to define those things by their external manifestations rather than by some final (and worse, sometimes even subconscious) motive.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by RodericDay on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:12PM (#14199956)
No, not really.

Hedonism refers to pursuing pleasures such as money, sex, food, luxury. Unless you want to play fast and loose with terms, an achievement such as becoming a veterinarian or winning a tennis championship or breaking a videogame speedrun record doesn't qualify.

Some words are tricky to fully define outside any ambiguity. Love and Game are good examples.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by badosu on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:05PM (#14199691)
Well, that makes almost everything humans do hedonic, doesn't it.

Happiness in this case probably comprises of a state of mind different of perceptual pleasure.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by pasquinelli on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:28PM (#14199784)
Epicurus advocated learning as the best form of pleasure because you can't do it to excess very easily like you can with things like eating, drinking, etc.

The various helenistic schools of philosophy were all searching for what constituted virtue. They were quite explicitly after what was good about life and how to organize life around that. The fact you can understand every every human motivation in hedonistic terms is no coincidence; it's the justification for the philosophy, the reason there was a school of hedonism.

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by chibolo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:22PM (#14200196)
"Hedonic" and Hedonism should be defined differently. The semi-last paragraph gives a good point to what Hedonism is.

"That is why the real Epicurus – in contrast to the crude sybarite invented by his detractors – denounced the rapidly rotting fruits of dissipation and excess. The constant pursuit of intense pleasures will in fact backfire, according to Epicurus, because it leads to the psychological hell of enslavement to unsatisfiable appetites. The would-be hedonist must take care to ensure that the pain of overreaching desire does not ruin his peace of mind and thereby defeat his original aim of securing a balance of pleasure over pain."

Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by lmm on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:34AM (#14201424)
I think it's possible to make mistakes in both directions. Certainly in my own life I used to be far too concerned about trying to do something for the ages; adopting the Epicurian attitude has made me a lot happier. (I still spend time helping others, because that's a satisfying thing to do in itself, but I've stopped trying to change the world).
Re:A practitioner’s guide to hedonism (2007) by jbrown on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:19AM (#14202685)
You make a very good point. I think my observations are pretty similar to yours. My solution is to expand from the hedonistic goal of maximizing one's own pleasure, to the larger goal of maximizing the total amount of happiness in the world.