Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low?
by Nition on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @05:58PM
(#14198490)
Petrol consumption is often best in cars at around 45mph (70km/h), so one effect of increasing highway speed limits not mentioned would be worse fuel economy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
This was mentioned in the article as the main reason for the legacy 55mph limit imposed after the Saudi oil embargo.
Oops, I see that now. My fault for only reading the first section of the article.
That number comes from a time of 3-speed transmissions and non-aerodynamic bodies. I heard better numbers back when 5-speed was becoming common, but now we're seeing 8-speed and 9-speed and CVT. It's probably around 65mph now.
I've heard 70km/h elsewhere, but the only personal data I have is I used to drive a 2002 5-speed manual VW Golf Mk IV, the 2L petrol version, and that had a fuel economy display on it plus a nice chart of economy per gear in the owner's manual. The book similarly said best would be at around 70km/h (~45mph) in 5th gear, and I confirmed that was true in my own tests. The 6-speed GTI was charted in the owner's manual as well and its best economy was shown as a little faster, in its extra 6th gear.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low?
by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:09AM
(#14202290)
Aerodynamic resistance (“drag”) doesn't care about your transmission. The sweet spot is even lower with electric cars (especially with all the peripheral devices turned off).
However, a modern mid-sized car with an efficient engine gets 40 MPG or more at 75 MPH, while a gas guzzler won't get such mileage at any speed.
Own a 2014 6-speed petrol VW and according to the manual the optimal speed for max mileage is around 70-75 km/h
Spark ignition engines suffer from pumping losses when throttled. So it is a pretty broad generalization to throw that number out. Fuel economy will depend on rolling resistance, gearing, and aerodynamics.