News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by willvarfar on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:15AM (#14192158)
Was Feynman sexist? A quick googling finds nothing.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:20AM (#14192185)
>Was Feynman sexist?

In the same way, and probably much less, that any male was in a totally different era of the 60s and 70s...

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by tps5 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:08PM (#14195700)
I know plenty of men who lived through that era (and one man who was born 4 years after Feynman) who are not in the slightest bit sexist. Or are at least far too polite to show it.

Feynman was clearly a bit of a prick. It also appears that he behaved rudely toward women [0]. In my opinion, the fact that there were some (significant) negative aspects of his personality doesn't take anything away from what he accomplished, or from the (significant) positive aspects of his personality.

[0] http://longnow.org/essays/richard-feynman-connection-machine...

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by xorcist on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:40AM (#14192283)
The above described behaviour was at the very least extremely bad manners .. even in the 60s/70s.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by eeeficus on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:50AM (#14192324)
Why is asking people for something is bad manners? Especially as you put it "extremely bad manners"?
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by foldr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:56AM (#14192355)
I suggest that you try asking random women in the office to bring you soup and see how that goes.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by oblio on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:09AM (#14192410)
Heh, for an even better reaction he should try asking random men in the office to bring him soup.

Depending on his workplace, things could become physical :D

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by foldr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:57AM (#14192365)
It actually turns up a lot of article about Feynman and sexism. E.g. this one:

http://mathematigal.com/home/2014/7/14/feynman-is-not-my-her...

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by leereeves on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:02AM (#14193557)
Is there anything in that article about Feynman except an unsubstantiated claim made during divorce proceedings?
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by teddyh on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:52AM (#14194642)
Apparently not.

Also, I seem to remember reading that similar claims were routinely made at the time in order for the divorce to be approved by the court. I.e. nobody was trying to make claims of abuse, they were simply trying to ensure the divorce was approved, and both parties agreed to make whatever exaggerated or false claims that could be seen as reasonable grounds for divorce.

Anyway, that’s what I remember. I could of course be wrong about this particular case.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by foldr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:28PM (#14195946)
What's your standard for "substantiated"? We're only going to have reports of what people said about him.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by Asooka on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:45AM (#14192569)
That's rather unfortunate. If I may propose an alternative treatment of Feynman though: simply forget that he was sexist and instead claim he was very progressive and helped female colleaguea all the time. People already want to be like Feynman, so if we simply turn Feynman's historical image into what we want people to be like we would accomplish more than by telling people that their heroes are evil.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:33AM (#14192815)
>we would accomplish more than by telling people that their heroes are evil.

Not to mention that being sexist is not evil, just bad manners (or that there's no such thing as "evil", it's a theological concept).

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by foldr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:48AM (#14193453)
Discriminating against someone because of their gender is wrong, not just bad manners. "It's not wrong because nothing is truly wrong" is surely an excuse of last resort. I don't see anyone on here bringing that point up when people are complaining about NSA surveillance or some other hacker cause célèbre.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:25PM (#14195064)
>Discriminating against someone because of their gender is wrong, not just bad manners.

Depends on the discrimination. Costing them a job opportunity is wrong. Telling them "hey, make me some tea" is bad manners -- same as if you asked a lower ranking male employee whose job is not it, that.

>"It's not wrong because nothing is truly wrong" is surely an excuse of last resort.

It's also an excuse nobody made. Wrong != evil. People are not cartoonish figures who are either holy or evil.

>I don't see anyone on here bringing that point up when people are complaining about NSA surveillance or some other hacker cause célèbre.

I'm not sure of the relevance. NSA surveillance is totalitarian. Asking female colleagues to "make you coffee" is impolite.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by foldr on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:30PM (#14195966)
>Telling them "hey, make me some tea" is bad manners -- same as if you asked a lower ranking male employee whose job is not it, that.

No, treating your women colleagues as if they are inferior merely because they are women is wrong. It is not merely bad manners, any more than racism or xenophobia are merely bad manners.

>It's also an excuse nobody made.

Are you just referring to the fact that I used the word 'wrong' instead of the word 'evil'? If so, just substitute 'evil' for 'wrong' in my previous comment.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by coldtea on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:58PM (#14196274)
>No, treating your women colleagues as if they are inferior merely because they are women is wrong.

Here's the thing: asking them to make him a coffee doesn't mean he thinks they are inferior. At worst, it assumes that this is something that they'll gladly do -- which is more about the era, than about himself. Many others would do the same without anybody thinking twice about it, we just magnify this anecdote from the 50s and 60s because he's famous. Heck, in the same time they had different seats and toilets for blacks and whites and people were OK with that, it was the law even...

>It is not merely bad manners, any more than racism or xenophobia are merely bad manners

Racism alone is not even bad manners -- it's just BS thinking (finding differences in races). Lots of old white elders for example can be racist but otherwise good people (and kind even to people with different skins they're thinking in racist ways about). It will have to translate in some actual harm to become actually (instead of merely potentially) bad.

In other words: people can think whatever they like, as long as they are not putting it in action that hurts others. The same thing, that is, that one might grant to artists with violent tendencies and visions that put that in their art. Some prudes might complaint, but as long as they don't actively hurt real people, what's the problem?

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by kazinator on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:02PM (#14196305)
Yes, asking someone to make you coffee is in fact treating them as "inferior". Firstly, in the sense of superior versus inferior: master versus servant. Secondly in the sense that your own work is too important to be interrupted with the preparation of coffee, whereas theirs isn't, or not to the extent that yours is.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by thomasahle on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:44AM (#14193958)
Evil is also a well studied concept in philosophy, e.g. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/concept-evil/ (Without claiming any relation to the discussion)
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by Chinjut on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:24AM (#14192769)
Haha, uh, that would be… one bizarre way to go about things.

Nah, I'd rather have the truth, yet work to nonetheless have people be good. Many heroes are flawed; let's emulate their positive qualities, and avoid their negative ones, without failing to acknowledge them or outright covering them up.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by cwilkes on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:17AM (#14193713)
> he was very progressive and helped female colleaguea all the time.

If there were only some sort of diagram to describe this many worlds idea

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by Maken on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:03AM (#14194133)
Wouldn't it be better to explain them nobody is perfect?
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by TeMPOraL on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:59AM (#14192645)
That's a pretty evil suggestion, but it may just work.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by Asooka on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:45AM (#14192912)
Of course it would. Think of say Abraham "I would never tell a lie" Lincoln. Who chased after a woman in the freezing snow to give her back her 20p. Our heroes always been moulded into idealised versions of themselves, a sort of mythological figures. You probably think it's evil because it seems like historic revisionism, i.e. what Stalin, Kim, etc. have done. I think it's justified to tell small white lies like this, like "Feynman respected women", if it helps people be better towards each other.
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by logfromblammo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:38AM (#14193372)
Did you ever read that chapter of Surely You're Joking where Feynman hanged himself from a tree for seven days to learn the secrets of subatomic physics? That's where Feynman diagrams came from.~
Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by jandrese on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:37AM (#14193884)
Having read his book the answer is yes, but not exceedingly so for a man of his time. His chapters on wooing dancing girls is not for someone with especially delicate sensibilities. But remember this is during the 40s, 50s, and 60s. Sexism was the norm, in fact it was considered good for society in upper class circles.

It's unfair to be hard on a man for simply living in a different age.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by kamaal on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:00AM (#14194115)
>>It's unfair to be hard on a man for simply living in a different age.

Unfortunately this how most current day news, trends and discussions are shaping out to be. Pretty much a lot of things considered bad now, were once perfectly acceptable.

Another annoying things these days are people who pick up some kind of negative thing about a famous personality and use that to discredit their whole life's work. Like talking something negative about Gandhi, and then use that ruse to make it look like his whole life was a waste.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by hwillis on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @04:43PM (#14197798)
I think that in cases like that you are the one being reductionist, not the other way around. Bringing up the flaws of people like Ghandi, MLK, Feynman, Hawking etc is a perfectly reasonable thing to do, even a responsible thing to do. Great men are still imperfect and their problems do not discredit them.

In a way its dangerous to not bring up their flaws; say MLK jr. defended the rights of people of color but was against gay rights. It is wrong to idolize him utterly, because then his views can legitimize views we think are wrong now.

I don't think any reasonable person tries to tear down great men and women by bringing up their flaws. I think they are just trying to recognize the real person, rather than the ideal. Their life does not reduce to one mistake just because we talk about it happening.

Re:Feynman Algorithm (2014) by leephillips on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:20AM (#14194279)
All you say is true in general. But Gandhi, while apotheosized in the West, is not so universally admired in India. Many people celebrated his assassination. A great many Indians, at the time and now, think that he set back Indian independence significantly, and that, to the extent that his economic ideas were adopted, they retarded the development of the nation.