News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @04:39AM (#14177182)
"Lesson two: don’t ask people to make decisions they are not qualified to make."

He's implying that certain questions (such as whether or not the UK should be a member of the EU) should be left to the political and economic experts.

What if the political and economic experts disagree with the majority, not just because of their political and economic knowledge, but because they are a very limited demographic and don't even consider many of the things that are important to the people who are not experts in those fields?

Considering what he wrote, I would say we need more referendums, not less. So that people can become familiar with their votes having an observable impact on their lives. At the moment, people feel powerless, so when they're given a vote, they're more likely to use it in anger. Give them more decision making power, not less.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by 2muchcoffeeman on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:43AM (#14177382)
> Give them more decision making power, not less.

I can't see this working out at all.

In the 2016 US election 43% of you failed to vote.

For Brexit 28% of people failed to vote. And the younger the demographic, the fewer people who voted.

In Australia where voting is compulsory, we have close to 6% informal votes. Donkey votes are believed to be close to 2%. I shudder to think of the people who vote for Labour or Libs because "their votes doesn't really count anyway".

And you don't have to vote that often! You had one job!

Re:The stupidity of crowds by Swenrekcah on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:59AM (#14177419)
The thing is, when all you can do is vote once every 4 years, you don't have a lot of influence. If I were tasked with steering a cruise ship but my only tool was to splash my arms in the sea to make waves, I would give up pretty quickly. So the point about having more referendums, not less, is I think completely spot on to try to fix this issue.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:24AM (#14177512)
My statement was that giving people more referendums would make them use them more wisely, and I gave some reasoning for that.

Your response was that, not many people vote. I'm not sure how that addresses what I wrote?

Re:The stupidity of crowds by bostik on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:20AM (#14177671)
> giving people more referendums would make them use them more wisely

Psychology and sociology disagree with you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_fatigue

The only solution I can think of is to enact a set of laws that require and enforce science and evidence based legislation. However, this is such an affront to all the lobbying groups that even the suggestion of such laws will be aggressively attacked from every direction possible.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:35AM (#14177723)
That link doesn't actually argue either way. It just presents some ideas with lots of "could be" and "under certain circumstances" and "proponents often counter" and so on. No sources.

It does provide one example. But the example has nothing to do with referendums, it's about people being asked to vote on the same sort of question repeatedly in a short period of time.

I would argue that the nature of a referendum is completely different to that of an election, so the behaviour may be completely different.

Do you have a better link?

Re:The stupidity of crowds by bostik on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:13AM (#14177850)
There is research into the phenomenon, but since I don't want to even try to link to [cough sb], I can provide a couple of pointers for further research.

- 10.2307/2108922

- (no idea why, but this has no DOI: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25791895)

- (no DOI either: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0261379401...)

> I would argue that the nature of a referendum is completely different to that of an election

I think you are being somewhat dishonest here, and I would suspect you actually know that. From an individual voter's point of view there is very little practical difference: you are supposed to set time aside to go to the polling station at a given date, and cast your vote on an issue where it is HIGHLY unlikely that you have enough data to make an educated decision.

Referendums attempt to distill a complex issue (or a set of issues) into a binary decision. (I find it relevant that binary option trading is a common source of scams: http://scambroker.com/binary-options-trading-scam/); elections attempt to distill a complex set of competing and mutually exclusive issues into a personality contest.

Either way the only repeatibly reliable result is that no matter whose side wins, all the voters will eventually feel they have been shafted.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:28AM (#14177896)
I don't know why you felt the need to call me dishonest.

An election is for choosing who you want to defer decision making power to. Often you only agree with some of the things that person intends to do. The headline actions. And even then, you realise that they may not do some of the things they said they would, and will probably do many other things you never even hear about.

A referendum is about answering a specific question. One you have probably never been asked in your life time. And hopefully one where the result will be an actual thing that takes place, e.g Brexit.

I find it hard to believe that concepts such as voter fatigue would apply equally to those two considerably different things.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by bostik on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:55AM (#14182212)
My apologies for that unclear statement. I meant that in this particular issue, I believe you are not being honest with yourself.

There are several problems with voting fatigue, but chief among them is that the actual effects of the result are divorced from the outcome. It usually takes months, if not years, for a practical change to propagate from election campaigns to reality. (In the off-chance that an election campaign promise is actually adhered to.)

So for most practical purposes a vote taking place has little resemblance to its practical results. We take the expectation of tight feedback loops as a given in UI design. If usability and results from user actions are not coupled, the user will get confused, irritated and eventually will just give up. Why would we expect voting to be any different?

It's not just the vote itself that is causing fatigue, it's also the insane mental overload of having to deal with and the need to make sense of the constant (mis)information deluge. For months on end, as a voter you are supposed to digest a barrage of incoming information. It is tiring.

And all this still boils down to the need to eventually set time aside go to a polling station to drop a piece of paper into a box, only to see that nothing really changes. Do this often enough and only the activists will be left. The silent majority can not be bothered to care enough.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by 2muchcoffeeman on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:11AM (#14177846)
Right, you said:

> What if the political and economic experts disagree with the majority, not just because of their political and economic knowledge, but because they are a very limited demographic and don't even consider many of the things that are important to the people who are not experts in those fields?

So my understanding of your idea is, the perspective of experts and general populous is different. If we give people more chances to vote, they will have more opportunity to vote in a way that will address issues important to them.

But we already have the opportunity to vote "from our perspective". But a lot of people don't care to. So why would having more opportunities to vote improve the this?

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:33AM (#14177920)
Because voting in a general election is different to voting in a referendum.

A lot of people see voting in general elections as futile, because as far as they can see, all they get from any party is more of the same.

Regardless of whether or not that viewpoint is correct, it doesn't apply to referendums. A referendum is about voting for a specific thing and getting it, or not.

I think that if we have more referendums, people will start to realise the difference, and take part more.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by tigershark on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:28AM (#14177696)
Yes, we all know that democracy cannot possibly be wrong. Give people more power. It will be impossible for example to elect Adolf Hitler when the people have the ultimate power... or maybe he was legitimately elected by the majority of German people at the time? It's kind of scary that people keep repeating their errors and have a blind faith in democracy or whatever form of government is popular.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:19AM (#14177871)
As I said in another comment: "Democracy doesn't mean always making the right decision. But it does mean we take collective responsibility when we make the wrong one."

I never stated that the majority would always make the right decision as you're implying that I did. Nor will the correct decisions always be made by ignoring the majority.

I would argue that the people who voted to remain in the EU have more blind faith in government. Willy nilly disregarding concepts such as sovereignty, and representation, and democracy as concepts from the past that don't need to be considered any more, because we've not had a war to fight to keep them for a generation or two.

I don't want to tell my grand children that we allowed democracy to be eroded because some people were afraid how the value of the pound would be affected.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by velik_m on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:57PM (#14178972)
Re:The stupidity of crowds by Safety1stClyde on Sunday April 23, 2017 @04:48AM (#14177205)
We probably don't need more referendums, but a constitutional change like Scottish independence or leaving the European Union does warrant a referendum.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by barking on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:40AM (#14177371)
Paraphrasing some French commentator, the problem with referendums is that the electorate don't necessarily answer the question asked.

Voters often like to give a government a kicking mid-term.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by _pythonlover_ on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:45AM (#14177571)
What if 99% of the people has no idea about the implications of their vote? I'm genuinely curious here. What if the experts are right and the majority of people are against them?
Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:15AM (#14177657)
Then we make the inferior decision. Equally the experts can be wrong. Or they can be right about the particular things they are experts in, but wrong about everything else.

Democracy doesn't mean always making the right decision. But it does mean we take collective responsibility when we make the wrong one.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mrcarrot on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:48AM (#14177400)
I'd rather the UK did something about the effective disenfranchisement caused by FPTP parliamentary elections first.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:56AM (#14177412)
The UK did. It had a referendum about it 6 years ago. Two thirds of the voters chose FPTP.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by SilkRoadie on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:14AM (#14177854)
The scary thing is how easily people are swayed by blatant lies. Britain has been let down twice recently. Both times it was the quality of the debate around the referendums.

For the voting system a lie was spread about how it isn't fair one person gets to vote once while another can vote 6 or 7 times.. this was the description of the AV system.

You then have Brexit which was a shit show. It worries me how few people ask to see evidence. This is why I do not feel people should have a say in complex decisions via referendum. If the should then Britain has demonstrated how not to do it.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:37AM (#14177932)
You could equally say that stupid people shouldn't be allowed to vote because they make bad decisions.

Democracy isn't always about getting the right answer. It's about distributing decision making power and making sure everyone gets an input. Even when they're wrong.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mrcarrot on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:07AM (#14178002)
And it seems like a good example of why more referendums wouldn't do much good in the current UK political system.

Who's going to be setting the questions? Presumably the government? Which means realistically the Conservative party or Labour (generously assuming they can recover to a position of electability at some point). Why would they then ever pose referendum questions where they wouldn't like one of the answers (especially in light of the last referendum)? How does anyone really get more of a democratic voice when you'd just be choosing from options selected by the 2 big parties so that their preferred option is all but guaranteed to win?

"Should we: A) waste £90 million on a complicated new voting system, or B) keep our traditional voting system and spend the money on the NHS?"

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @11:03AM (#14178423)
The majority of the Tories wanted to stay in the EU. They didn't want the referendum. They provided the referendum because the public demanded one by giving a single issue party (UKIP) 12% of the vote at the previous general election.

The Tories wanted to remain in the EU, yet when the electoral commission recommended they change the wording of the question because it favoured staying in the EU, they obliged.

Personally, I still think the question was biased towards the status quo and should have been:

"Should the UK be a member of the European Union"

Rather than what it actually was:

"Should the United Kingdom remain a member of the European Union or leave the European Union?"

I wonder if the remain vote would have been even lower with a less bias question?

Referendum wording is generally heavily scrutinised. I'm sure if we had more regular referendums a process would be created to make sure it remained that way.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by dragonwriter on Sunday April 23, 2017 @11:19AM (#14178488)
> The majority of the Tories wanted to stay in the EU. They didn't want the referendum. They provided the referendum because the public demanded one by giving a single issue party (UKIP) 12% of the vote at the previous general election.

No, they provided the referendum because their leadership thought that the split within the party on the issue (while the majority was against leaving, there was a substantial minority for it) would result in loss of vote share if the party was unambiguously for staying, so they promised a referendum to keep their internal coalition intact.

Re:The stupidity of crowds by mike-cardwell on Sunday April 23, 2017 @11:32AM (#14178539)
About 20% of the Tory MPs wanted to leave the EU. So yes, that did play a part in the decision I'm sure. But I doubt that we would have been given a referendum without the increase in public support for UKIP. The Tory party was under threat because of the gains UKIP was making.
Re:The stupidity of crowds by dragonwriter on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:48PM (#14179293)
> About 20% of the Tory MPs wanted to leave the EU

Sure, but the split I was talking about is in the party-in-the-electorate, not the party-in-government. It wasn't a technique to maintain party unity in the Parliament, but to avoid losing party of the electoral base for the 2015 general election.

> But I doubt that we would have been given a referendum without the increase in public support for UKIP.

Sure, but that wasn't​ the public demanding an isolated referendum on the issue; the referendum was just a Tory tactic for minimizing the controversy over EU policy as a general election issue for the set of voters that, their view on that issue aside, were generally aligned with the Tories.