Industrial farming is about as humane as any other method for killing I've seen/practiced.
People argue that hunting keeps one more connected with the concept of meat as quarry, but the end result is the same. I shot a scimitar oryx through the heart a few years ago (before the ban) and it still ran 100 yards before it dropped. I'm pretty sure stun guns and captive bolt pistols remove the concept of pain faster.
Most of our metabolism is tailored towards fruit. That doesn't mean it has issues with meat: it'll deal quite well.
But anatomic capability and morality are totally unrelated. My body is well-designed to rape women, but I won't use that as an argument to do so either.
Your oryx was able to run.
These moral/ethical lines are completely arbitrary.
Just because it is difficult and subjective to know what suffers doesn't mean we shouldn't think about it.
Edit: downvote welcome. I have lots of fake internet points to spare. I'm not going to dignify a subjective, semantic argument with anything more. Fuck, "meh" is more than 99% of HN comments deserve.
Moar Edit: Heil Trump!
If we can get lab-grown meat below the cost and/or of improved taste to dead animal meat, it's likely to do very well and open people up more to the moral argument which will cement it. Right now it fails miserably on both fronts.
And I'm sure there will be pushback from the "organic"/"all natural" what-have-you crowd which exists now about how lab grown meat has evil chemicals or some equally silly thing.
Not trying to criticize, it's how humans have existed for thousands of years — I'm just genuinely curious what a realistic "oh wait, I'm going to not do this" point is for people who eat meat.
If you're not willing to look the animal in the eyes and kill it, you shouldn't be eating it. I'll go one further and say if you haven't actually butchered a cow or chicken, you shouldn't be eating that meat. (I'll say the same about pork, bison, ostrich, snake, rabbit, sheep, etc... too but those are less common)
I grew up on a farm/ranch, I've looked cows in the eyes that I fed daily to fatten them up just for this purpose. I genuinely don't care about it, its a part of life. So for myself that point probably doesn't exist.
You can look at it in two ways philosophically, one, which seems predominant on this forum is that any human inflicted "suffering" is wrong and should be avoided.
One other view, which I think most cattle producers would think philosophically, is that you brought into the world more animals than if you didn't exist. Note, I'm just ignoring feed lots here as that isn't what I grew up around, nor does anyone I know support them.
Presupposing however that only the former viewpoint regarding suffering is correct is a bit of criticism however. Additionally, if you've ever watched how most predators take down prey, humans are vastly more humane about it.
I'd rather we separate out the feedlot question from the actual killing question. The former is an economic issue, the latter I think of in many ways as the Lakota did.
Oh come on. Many jobs are miserable and dangerous. I've been 20 feet away from a pig as the guts were removed, and that was more than enough odor. (the pig was full of shit)
I don't have a problem with the "look the animal in the eyes" thing though. Animals are just food. I butchered a duck. That didn't smell much, but I was a bit worried about being bitten by external parasites. A cow though... if that thing falls off the crane/hoist/lift thing it'll squish you to death. This isn't some wimpy emotion thing. Squish! Oh, and probably lots of ticks, and prior to death it may kick you or gore you. Cattle are not to be messed with unless you have special training and equipment.
The reason for actually having done it is to understand the reality of where food comes from, not to try to instill a view that everyone must do everything themselves to be able to use anything in the world.
Just to be clear in my case as I originally responded: There is a distinction between killing animals to feed oneself and outsourcing the killing to a farm which causes those animals to spend their entire life suffering (e.g., chickens confined to a small cage). That is not how humans existed for thousands of years.
That works just as well for restaurants.
But I can imagine life in coastal areas where fish is the only option.
For those who kill the animals they eat, do you ever feel attached to it? I can't imagine killing my dog for food. It's like cannibalizing my child.
In the future what we will find horrifying is that we waited for this excuse, as if without a meat replacement the preceding abuse was justified.
Any time PC culture and white privilege and social justice warriors I can't help but feel sad that we almost seem to be moving backwards while many groups are still fighting for equality as if at some point (unbeknownst to any minority) we achieved total equality and now its the majority that is being discriminated against.
Right now our only tool is a hammer...
I have several direct and extended family members that still think Jane Fonda should be publicly executed for treason, think the civil rights act and equal rights amendments were communist plots, and that Richard Nixon was the victim of an impeccably well executed Democratic Party plot to frame him. Amazingly, despite not being alive for any of it and despite the absurdity of the claims, some of their children have the same views. It took several centuries for western nations to realize slavery was bad, but an additional century after that to realize that institutionalized racism was bad enough to publicly address with laws, and we still aren't out of doing it in more nefarious underhanded ways. Running in a marathon was low hanging fruit and got lucky with timing. The rest of your list is going to take a few hundred years before we really feel that way as a unified society.
This woman set out to prove she could run marathons. Her ability to finish was visceral proof that at least some women can run marathons. The guy that tried to push here provided additional fodder to make it look idiotic to refuse them to try to run.
In comparison, many of the others things are not something you can see is wrong with your own two eyes, and can see repeated anytime you care.
It's harder to see for yourself that one race isn't better than another, especially not when you're looking at things with a biased starting point. Even when you meet nice/smart/law-abiding people of another race, you can write it off as "but not you - you're different" and hold on to the stereotypes. It takes many more examples to overcome for someone who has first gotten convinced by the stereotypes.
A woman running a marathon on the other hand, is such a simple thing to show, and it takes very few repetitions, that can be delivered in a very short amount of time, to prove that it's not a fluke or a single abnormal person. You might write it off as fake if you read about it, but not if you see a marathon go by or hear about female friends running one. And once it's happened a few times it sounds remarkable unremarkable.
But unfortunately that means a whole lot of issues are likely going to take a very long time to resolve because they are not nearly as easy to demonstrate.
But what says they have to continue just because they've been going on for centuries? What if this is the peak?
* listening to animal rights advocates
* not incarcerating more
* not using the death penalty even for minor violations
* not forcing everybody to have a cam in their bedroom (of course, strictly for access by security forces)
etc...
The only thing standing between your and my vision of the future is how we act - not our wishful thinking how things should turn out.
I think that could swing two ways. I can envision (but don't look forward to) a world where people wonder how we ever allowed thiefs to have a long career or murderers to kill a second time. If you RFID tag every expensive object and every human at birth (multiple times, if needed), add plenty of cameras that use face recognition to verify that tags don't move around, and implant a couple of remotely read sensors for bodily functions, it would become a lot easier to solve crimes (yes, people still could game the system, for example by committing suicide while in the company of someone they hate, but that would be rare)
Of a few of those, I dare say the majority is embarrassed about. Especially from outside the US.
How often do you look back in shame at people who did not use a cell phone in the 1960s? The answer is you don't. You understand that cell phones didn't exist back then and are glad technology has improved.
(and I say this as someone who eats meat, and doesn't have any particular ethical problem with doing so.)
This is an extremely simplistic view that ignores millennia of men being injured or killed for the sake of women. How many lifeboats have been recovered packed with women and children and not a single grown man? Was all that done out of hatred? If we really want to be simplistic, let's look at history and sum it up that women are indifferent toward the safety of men. That's about equally accurate.
The world will be inherited by the people who show up - Amish, evangelicals, conservative Muslims, orthodox Jews, etc.
So you may be right about the 50 year time-span, but looking onto the 100+ year span, your list of issues should likely look more like:
-Public blasphemy
-Public acceptance of homosexuality
-Lack of God in government
-Allowance of abortion
etc.
Just because things have gone one way for a while doesn't mean they'll keep going that way. For better or for worse.
This isn't supported by basically any demographic trend.
If being overwhelmed by demographics with higher birth rates was something that could actually happen, it already would have happened, and low-birthrate populations never would have occurred in the first place.
- Meat eating
These two for sure.
I think, or at least hope, the usage of the death penalty will increase. Some people definitely can't be rehabilitated, and life imprisonment is an inhumane and cruel punishment.
What things today are we going to be deeply embarrassed about 50 years from now? I have a few guesses:
- Our abysmal stewardship of the environment
- Mass incarceration
- The death penalty
- Domestic surveillance
- Police militarization and lack of accountability
- The drug war
- Transgender oppression (e.g. NC bathroom bill)
- The travel ban
- That we elected a president who bragged about grabbing unknown women by their genitals