News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mindcrime on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:44PM (#14134269)
More straw-man crap trying to pitch the ridiculous idea that hard work doesn't matter at all. OK, sure, you can argue that you're more likely to reach the very highest echelons of society if you are lucky enough to be born rich, etc. But:

a. "more likely" doesn't mean it isn't possible to achieve if you aren't "born right"

and perhaps more to the point:

b. "success" is measured on a continuum; it's not a binary proposition. And there's a lot of room between "Becoming a Supreme Court justice" (just to pick an example) and winding up as a barista at Starbucks. Like, plenty of lawyers who make a nice living for their families, or all the thousands of local district and superior court judges out there, or the hundreds of federal circuit judges who don't quite make it to the very top.

This kind of article is boring and pointless because it's selling a dangerous idea: that nothing you do matters at all, and, ergo, you might as well do nothing. I mean, if hard work doesn't matter, why bother working hard to begin with, right?

As the old saying goes: "It is better to shoot for the stars and miss than aim at the gutter and hit it". Or another take on it: "Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars."

So yeah, tell your kids to dream big and work hard. They'll probably go further than if you tell them "life sucks, you have no chance, so just go ahead and do nothing but play video games and smoke weed all day".

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by frooxie on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:42PM (#14134664)
If we tell people the dangerous false idea that hard work is the main factor that makes someone rich or successful, we could end up with a terrible society where the rich feel they have no responsibility to help the less fortunate (by e.g. providing universal healthcare), because they must simply have been lazy – even though most rich people started out rich, and even the rich people who started out poor and worked hard still owe their success partially to being lucky enough not to have been randomly afflicted by some disease, by growing up in a society that provided them opportunities for education and business, etc.

So if your kids turned out more successful than others, don't tell them it was just because they dreamt big and worked hard. While hard work is important, their success was also partially due to luck and the work of others, and they should never forget that.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mindcrime on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:42PM (#14135054)
While hard work is important, their success was also partially due to luck and the work of others, and they should never forget that.

Agreed. My problem is with this meme that seems to have become pervasive over the last year or two, which seems to posit that, effectively, everything comes down to luck. Clearly the actual truth is somewhere between the extremes of "it's all luck" and "it's all hard work". My response here is a reaction to what I perceive as a swinging of the pendulum towards the "it's all luck" mindset, to a degree that I think is damaging.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by chc on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:54PM (#14135125)
I think the thing is that the luck is much more make-or-break than the work. Luck can make how much work you've done irrelevant, but no amount of work can make luck irrelevant. For example, the "cash me ousside" girl didn't do any work, but now is more successful than I am by sheer weird luck. Meanwhile, lots of people have put in stupendous amounts of work and still ended up with bad results just because they were unlucky (remember, despite being beloved of the Internet nowadays, Nikola Tesla died penniless and alone).
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by true_religion on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:30AM (#14136901)
You have to both be prepared to take advantage of a lucky opportunity and be ready to work hard to maximize it. Doing neither means failure.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by graedus on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:58PM (#14134792)
> we could end up with a terrible society where the rich feel they have no responsibility to help the less fortunate (by e.g. providing universal healthcare), because they must simply have been lazy

I completely agree with you, but it's curious that you frame this as a hypothetical outcome. At least in the US, this idea has been deeply ingrained in broad swaths of the population for decades - and not just among the rich.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by maxxxxx on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:20PM (#14134505)
"As the old saying goes: "It is better to shoot for the stars and miss than aim at the gutter and hit it". Or another take on it: "Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars." "

These are fine. However, there is also the belief that all people who have reached the stars have worked hard or that people who haven't reached stars just haven't worked enough. These are wrong. Success is a combination of hard work and a good portion of luck. You most likely won't be successful if you don't work hard but if you don't succeed it's not necessarily because you haven't worked hard.

To me it's a call for successful people to be more compassionate with people who aren't successful.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by chronic940 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:23PM (#14134537)
So do you propose we give free scholarships, jobs, and tax breaks to those who end up unlucky?

I was unlucky and had medical problems in college. I deserve some relief. But I'm also a co-founder of a decent startup. Am I lucky or unlucky?

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by maxxxxx on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:30PM (#14134582)
You were lucky and unlucky. You have probably worked hard but you may also have been co-founder of a bad startup and lost everything. Or you could have gone bankrupt because of medical bills.

You definitely should work hard but by no means there is a guarantee you will succeed. You also need some luck.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by user5994461 on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:50PM (#14135102)
co-founder of a startup, I'd interpret that as he has nothing and he lives in the most expensive area in the world.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by majewsky on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:51AM (#14137312)
What makes you think that a startup can only be founded in SV?
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mcbruiser3 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:45PM (#14134693)
my god, you can't live life and expect nothing bad to ever happen to you. stuff happens, and if you want to be successful you'll deal with it.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by wavefunction on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:29PM (#14134573)
"Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars."

Funnily enough the moon is much closer than the stars. ;)

I think success is a matter of preparation, opportunity/luck and 'hard work' in the form of dedication when the opportunity presents itself.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by alasdair_ on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:46PM (#14134700)
>>"Shoot for the moon. Even if you miss, you'll land among the stars." >Funnily enough the moon is much closer than the stars. ;)

Sure but if you MISS the moon, you'll be stuck heading towards the stars until you run of of oxygen and die.

That's the point of this saying, right? ...

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by tracker1 on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:30PM (#14135346)
This totally reminds me of the scene in "The Expanse" series that showed the test run of an engine that allowed broader exploration of the solar system...
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by tracker1 on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:29PM (#14135337)
Almost every successful person I'm aware of is very driven... now, there's luck involved as well.. but it's a combination.

As the song goes[0]:

    This is ten percent luck, twenty percent skill
    Fifteen percent concentrated power of will
    Five percent pleasure, fifty percent pain
    And a hundred percent reason to remember the name!
    
[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6hpVHx6QCw
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by majewsky on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:43AM (#14137286)
That is certainly true, but survivorship bias still is a thing: Just because every successful person is hard-working, doesn't mean by any stretch that every hard-working person is successful.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by candiodari on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:09AM (#14138914)
Kind of the same thing everyone's saying here isn't it ? Not being driven guarantees failure, but there's just no way to guarantee success - although to a certain extent being driven does guarantee success. It just won't necessarily make you CEO or president or some such.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by cashmonkey85 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:25AM (#14136477)
That's why when hiring I always say hire the lucky person not the hard worker. You're an idiot if you think it's hard work that explains success of a company. I get applications to role a set of dices and the one that roles the hirest number is hired.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by 011235813213455 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:36PM (#14134622)
Nowhere in that article does he say that hard work doesn't matter at all.

>What I have learned in this short period of time is that the pervasive narrative of “if you work hard you will get on” is a complete myth. It’s not true and we need stop saying it. This is because “working hard, and doing the right thing” barely gets you to the starting line. Furthermore, it means something completely different depending on to which context you’re applying this particular notion. So much more is required.

If you note what he says at the end of that paragraph, it becomes obvious that what he's trying to get across is that you absolutely need hard work, but that will give you only the bare minimum to have a chance and it's definitely not a guarantee that you will do well.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mcbruiser3 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:43PM (#14134678)
he's a terrible writer then.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by 011235813213455 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:48PM (#14134723)
How does that make him a terrible writer?
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mcbruiser3 on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:17PM (#14134908)
because his message is unclear, clearly. even smart people on HN seems to be confused about his message. a good writer is not confusing.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by bherms on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:23PM (#14134949)
Seems more likely that the original commenter probably didn't actually read the article and just had a reaction to the title.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mindcrime on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:44PM (#14135074)
No, I read and understood the article. If I'm guilty of anything, it's reacting to more than just what this article is saying. But it strikes me as just one more in a long series of articles / essays / comments that have emerged over the past few years which, collectively, are promoting a message that denigrates the value of hard work and suggest that pretty much everything comes down to luck.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by bherms on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:24PM (#14135312)
Yeah I agree that there have been a lot of articles that basically approach the topic (which I thoroughly believe in, that it's not just hard work that gets you to the top) with the tone of "hard work doesn't matter". I thought this one was good though.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by notacoward on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:31AM (#14139092)
Interesting. The parent was directed to mcbruiser3, and you responded as though it was directed to you. Having trouble getting your message out with only one account?
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by grotsnot on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14140633)
mindcrime is the "original commenter" that bherms is referring to...
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by notacoward on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:11PM (#14135224)
> even smart people on HN seems to be confused about his message

I see no evidence of that.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by sjg007 on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:07PM (#14134441)
Did you read the article? It's about his life where he worked hard and got lucky to escape poverty and attend Oxford. He criticizes the system because it is inherently biased to the privileged so he argues that we need to do better.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by tajen on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:26PM (#14134967)
That's my problem:

> My mother gave birth to 12 children

Having 12 children is completely out of responsibility. Yet we saved this guy from poverty. Now what, not only the guy is barely thankful, but he claims that people should be able to reproduce this error and get the same incredibly good outcome – and it's a right? What about no?

He shows no understanding of what is normal; Growing from 12th-child of farmer parents to barrister in less than one generation is already a privilege; I'd be happy if my grand son had the same social status as I have already. Be humble. There's a lot of things to learn to rise in society, from not having TV to various attitudes about trading in business, from attitude about alcohol to relaxation things (or religion if that's your thing); No, if you don't educate your child, or if teach him that being a barrista is good enough, then he won't be able to become barrister despite his parents. But he's free to edicate his children better, that's how it works.

The XXI century is stuck in a wrong expectation that governments are supposed to compensate for your parents' life choices and make you a lawyer. To me, it explains why people are more and more polarized, on one side those who accuse the riches of stealing their right to equality (whatever that means), on the other people who grow a big expertise at getting deaf to such claims (and, unfortunately, they tilt towards not listening to any claims regarding rights, even older ones which were reasonable enough to survive the ages, like voting and democracy). Want to protect your democracy? Be reasonable with your claims, rights and expectations.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:41PM (#14135053)
Non-Western cultures and Catholics both have a bias towards large families. As a survival strategy, it often makes perfect sense in those different cultural settings.

>The XXI century is stuck in a wrong expectation that governments are supposed to compensate for your parents' life choices.

No, it's really not. "Choices" are a luxury, not a given.

You need a good education and a personal or family tradition of researching and understanding outcomes to make useful choices. Those are not the default for most families.

Even if that weren't true, governments should not, in fact, compensate anyone for anything. What they should do is perform a cost/benefit analysis and work out which social mitigation strategies provide the best overall returns.

Does it cost less to house the homeless or to keep them on the streets, where they're a drain on all kinds of services?

Simple moralising can't answer that question. Objective, rational, research can. And when you do objective, rational, research, you often find that naive decisions based on simple-minded moralising tend to produces expensive, low-efficiency outcomes.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by tajen on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:01AM (#14137153)
> objective, rational, research

I'm often surprised how "objective, rational, research" can be biased by the author. For example, "objective, rational, research" lead to not demonstrating that women are paid less if they perform equal work (degree, interest in tech, but also number of extra hours at work), but "objective, rational, research"-people regularly and repeatedly refuse to discuss or even listen to such stats, because they're not "objective, rational, research" according to them. So if you leftist people agreed to question your own "objective, rational, research" that shows that leftist people are right, maybe we could hear each other.

Maybe that leads to a world where those who annoy their friends at school have no job when they're an adult. And that's how it should be, even if "objective, rational, research" show that "oh the poor boy he beats up his friends because [insert whatever family reason here]".

Note that I've given thousands to charities and helped minorities until my thirties. Until one of them raped my daughter-in-law. No matter how you try, even if you put them on a highway of priorities above normal people, those are their own top enemy. A bit of fairness towards former-normal people would be nice as well.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by user5994461 on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:56PM (#14135136)
Catholics and western cultures also have a bias toward large familes.

Try going back one or two more generations in your genealogy if you can't see it closer.

Sadly and I hate to break it up. Having 10 children a few generations ago used to go with a very high mortality rate, even in Western Europe.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by munchbunny on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:23PM (#14134953)
Rather than nitpick on the wording, I think you should try to see the underlying point. It's unfortunate phrasing, but the point isn't about how hard you work or whether it's important to have a good work ethic.

I liked this article better, and it conveys more or less the same point as the topic link:

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/10/opinion/how-i-learned-to-...

The problem is that hard work makes a dent, but not a very big one if you don't understand the "game" that you need to play. It's easy to take this for granted if you grow up in an environment with many people who understand it because you learn it by osmosis.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by clock_tower on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:17PM (#14135265)
This is either a nitpick of your post, or a complete agreement with it, but I'm not sure which: "work ethic" or "Protestant ethic", in Weber's original understanding, had three parts: hard work, deferred consumption, and reinvestment. Using "have a good work ethic" to mean "work hard", without the other two elements, is a good way to stay poor -- which is to say, a good way to fail to understand how to play the game, in the way you mention. More accurate sociology would probably mean more upward social mobility.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by munchbunny on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:15PM (#14142475)
I would argue that deferred consumption and reinvestment would help further, but still not necessarily enough.

Jumping into the article that I linked, the author was missing a critical chain of thought: that currently in the United States, the path to an "upward mobile" job generally follows these lines:

1. Get good grades in high school 2. Score high on the SAT (which has to be practiced), then get lots of help writing your college essay 3. Pick an area of study that corresponds with a well-paying occupation, and then get into a college that is solid in that department 4. Leverage the career and alumni network to find a well-paying job, or apply to business/law/medical school.

At each step, you have to prioritize how you spend your limited time and energy. I grew up with parents who understood this point and focused my energy into each step when it was time to do so, so I was very lucky in that sense. I also worked my ass off, but steps 1 through 3 were very much helped along by parental guidance.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by dikdik on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:56PM (#14134776)
I think a better way to frame this is "Hard work barely matters when you work for someone else."

I've been in too many situations and witnessed too many friends and family members that shoot for the moon but are never able to leave Earth as all their extra efforts are usurped by their managers and business owners.

Sure hard work "matters", it can help you get places, but how much does it matter is the question? Does it make 1% difference? 5% difference? 50% difference? I'd bet the difference is <10% compared to someone who does just enough to get by.

I think kids would go furthest of all if we told them "treat yourself as an autonomous being, work hard when you are in a position to realize the benefits of your hard work, otherwise do just enough and save your energy for better days."

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by user5994461 on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:59PM (#14135159)
Well, that's another interesting topic for discussion.

Don't work harder if that will give you no returns. (like unpaid extra hours, going to your company funds or manager bonus for saving the project)

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by kafkaesq on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:05PM (#14134838)
More straw-man crap trying to pitch the ridiculous idea that hard work doesn't matter at all.

Which isn't what the author was saying, of course.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by notacoward on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:15PM (#14134898)
The strawman is yours. The author clearly does not believe or say that hard work doesn't matter at all. That's obvious to anyone who actually read it instead of having a knee-jerk reaction to the title and not even bothering to quote-mine before responding. All he's saying is that hard work is only one factor, and that others must be addressed for that hard work to earn its just reward.
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by mindcrime on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:49PM (#14135094)
That's obvious to anyone who actually read it instead of having a knee-jerk reaction to the title

It's not just this article alone, that's the thing. It's the broader meme that this article aligns with, which denigrates the value of hard work and - IMO - over-emphasizes luck.

That said, if you want quote-mining, here ya go. One that I a wholeheartedly agree with. It just feels a bit tacked on near the end.

We need to do more to double down on improving environments both at home and at school which continuously constrain potential. If the adage that hard work truly matters rings true, then we must do more – at all levels of society – to make it a reality.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by kamaal on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:45AM (#14137295)
>>selling a dangerous idea: that nothing you do matters at all, and, ergo, you might as well do nothing. I mean, if hard work doesn't matter, why bother working hard to begin with, right?

You must work hard and contribute only to a system that is fair.

Its important to starve that system of good contributors which doesn't reward merit.

One of the reason why people immigrate to other countries, or move companies is because of futility of doing anything in their current ecosystem.

Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by oceanghost on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:24AM (#14136472)
“I have seen wicked men and fools, a great many of both; and I believe they both get paid in the end; but the fools first.” - Robert Louis Stevenson, Kidnapped
Re:Telling children 'hard work gets you to the top' is simpl... by anigbrowl on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:22PM (#14134530)
You certainly protest a great deal over something you claim to find boring and pointless.