News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:02AM (#14129917)
For context, the current government is composed of a center-left party supported by two "far-left" parties, which have the majority despite the center-right party having come out on top in number of votes. The bill comes from one of the far-left parties (Left Block).

That said, it's fairly mild: only says one can't use DRM to prevent users from enjoying their legal rights, and there's no penalty, except that the DRM breakers won't get fined by our (EU-mandated) anti-circumvention laws, if I'm reading it correctly. And they haven't revoked the bill passed by the previous right-wing government, which forced ISPs to block access to a bunch of "piracy" related sites (TPB, Kickass, etc).

Also, the private copying exception that they mention (and which already existed) doesn't come from free: we have an extra tax on storage devices that gets pooled into a fund to "compensate" authors for that exception.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by fao_ on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:53AM (#14130331)
> we have an extra tax on storage devices that gets pooled into a fund to "compensate" authors for that exception.

That's... a surprisingly (and refreshingly) pragmatic way to deal with that percieved problem, to be honest. It'd be nice to see more countries going with solutions like that, rather than the old "Do as I say or I'll beat you over the head"

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pdkl95 on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:07AM (#14130616)
>> an extra tax on storage

Who cares about due process and the market, just presume everybody is liable and tax them to guarantee profit to an industry? What a complete perversion of basic capitalism and rule of law.

> It'd be nice to see more countries going with solutions like that

It's nice to pay an extra tax to prop up a poorly-run industry?

>>> There will also be an exception for private copying.

While it's not clear precisely what is meant by "private copying", time-shifting was ruled a fair use in the Betamax case, without the need for a levy.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by lightbyte on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:17AM (#14130658)
>a complete perversion of basic capitalism

I'm pretty sure that was the whole point. Capitalism is not a magical faery solution to everything, it obviously was not working in this industry so they are trying someone new.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pdkl95 on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:31AM (#14130732)
> Capitalism is not a magical faery solution to everything,

I completely agree, but the solution to that is not granting guaranteed profits to an industry. They are already granted a monopoly market with copyright. Why should they also get to skip the entire legal system and having to actually produce a product people want and jump straight to profits?

We're talking about luxury goods, not healthcare.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by SomeStupidPoint on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:36AM (#14131149)
If the fund is distributed according to sales, how does any of that apply?

They still have to compete for profits to get a share, their sales are just worth a little bit extra to offset the cultural benefit of more freely available music. (Eg, for each dollar they take in, they actually get $1.01.)

In the sense you're using "luxury goods", they're still essential to human cultural and psychological well-being, even if not base survival.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pedrocr on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:06AM (#14131396)
So why don't they just raise their prices to 1.01 and not take money from people who have no interest in their content?
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:27PM (#14142065)
It baffles me there is anyone who would argue against this position.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by SomeStupidPoint on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:13PM (#14132017)
Because it's a societal level adjustment to an existing market distortion -- ie, adjusting the market incentives to work better with existing laws and regulations.

Society's interest in the market for arts isn't to just make money, and adjusting the pay structure as part of balancing competing interests (in this case, mandatory free use) is reasonable.

Even people who aren't directly interested in a particular work have an interest in the overarching production of arts.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by realusername on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:24AM (#14130692)
Like DRM is not a perversion of basic free market anyway... (and you are mixing capitalism and free market which are not synonyms).
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by dnautics on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:18AM (#14131508)
Assuming circumvention methods aren't prohibited by law, How is DRM a perversion of the free market?
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by fao_ on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:36PM (#14133283)
Under the DCMA copyright act, they are prohibited. What you're saying here is "If the situation were different, how would your argument work".
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:07PM (#14133974)
DRM exists outside of the US, you know.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by barrkel on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:46AM (#14130805)
You'd have to supplement it with a survey, to find out what how much of what should go where.

I think it's a valid alternative model that accommodates a lower transaction cost and higher overall welfare - more people can benefit from consuming art - provided that the income is sufficient to motivate its production. It's certainly not an open and closed case of anarchy; that's just as ridiculous to claim.

The Eurail / Interrail multi-day all-Europe train tickets have a similar mechanism. The basic requirement for travel is that you write your journey into the ticket's itinerary list (a multi-page lined space that you fill in manually); at the end, at your option, you send off the ticket to receive some kind of souvenir. Functionally this acts as a survey of which train trips were taken, so that the money from sales of the tickets can be distributed.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by freeflight on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:26AM (#14131587)
>That's... a surprisingly (and refreshingly) pragmatic way to deal with that percieved problem, to be honest.

It's a solution to nothing and can easily turn into a bloated bureaucratic nightmare like in Germany. A private copying levy exists, regardless of that, there's a thriving business sector of lawyers sending out bulk cease&desist letters for the most absurd of copyright infringements.

Along with that come a number of "collecting societies" like GEMA (music), VG Wort (literature) or VG Bild-Kunst (video/art) which are responsible for collecting all kinds of levies and paying them out to the respective "artists", IF artists actually claim their share of the money.

In reality, these are bloated organizations where most of the collected money goes to the board of directors, of which most only sit in that position as some kind of political retirement plan/favor.

GEMA is the reason why many popular music videos on YouTube have been straight up blocked in Germany, they are also quite infamous for issuing admonishings to kindergartens and schools for singing/copying copyrighted christmas/birthday song texts.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEMA_(German_organization)

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by germanier on Monday April 17, 2017 @03:35PM (#14133758)
> most of the collected money goes to the board of directors

Administrative costs of those societies are somewhere between 5% and 15%. The rest goes to the creators.

> board of directors, of which most only sit in that position as some kind of political retirement plan/favor

I just scanned a few biographies and it didn't look like anything out of the ordinary. They are elected by the members of those societies and not appointed by politicians.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by freeflight on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:04PM (#14133957)
>Administrative costs of those societies are somewhere between 5% and 15%. The rest goes to the creators.

That's the theory, in practice many members have to pay in more than they get out because they have to pay fees to GEMA even when playing their own works.

>I just scanned a few biographies and it didn't look like anything out of the ordinary.

For 17 years the CEO used to be Reinhold Kreile, a CSU politician, and lawyer for copyright. He wasn't the first and he ain't the last, it's part of the political culture in Germany.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by germanier on Monday April 17, 2017 @06:15PM (#14134897)
I'm not claiming everything is perfect with those societies (that would be far from the truth). But both assertions that most of the collected money goes to the board of directors and most of those are there because of a political favor are simply not true even when taken as a hyperbole.

> many members have to pay in more than they get out

That their payment table needs some work is out of question. However, membership is entirely voluntary. If someone is a member and pays more in than they get out there has to be some other value they get of it or they would not be a member.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by freeflight on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @06:25AM (#14137599)
>However, membership is entirely voluntary.

Voluntary being a pretty funny word in that regard considering that according to GEMA rules all works are to be under their trust by default, unless proven otherwise.

>If someone is a member and pays more in than they get out there has to be some other value they get of it or they would not be a member.

Once you are a member and can't publish any of your works, wich you registered with GEMA, under any other licenses, so what good is leaving gonna do anybody when they still lost the rights to publish their own works?

Ain't helping that the German patent office has been preventing the legitimization of alternative organizations, putting GEMA in a de facto monopoly position. It's a prime example of overbearing bureaucracy gone totally wrong and as such shouldn't surprise anybody that there've already been over 1800 petitions against GEMA.

It's an organization that's supposed to act in the best interest of the artists it's representing, but still tried to fight off the digitalization of the music market until 2007, it's an organization that sends out bills for singings songs to kindergartens and retirement homes. Seriously, take a step back and think about that and tell me this ain't totally absurd.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by Silhouette on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:01AM (#14130904)
That's... a surprisingly (and refreshingly) pragmatic way to deal with that percieved problem

Unfortunately, it usually results in collecting money based on people buying recordable media, regardless of what material they're going to record on that media, and redirecting that money to large, high-profile content providers, also regardless of whose material was actually recorded. In short, smaller content providers and the citizens who are enjoying that content (or using the recordable media for other purposes entirely) are being systematically ripped off.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by freehunter on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:16AM (#14131006)
But it basically gives you carte blanche to pirate as much as you want. I mean, you already paid for every album and movie that exists, you might as well take advantage of it.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by Silhouette on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:33AM (#14131116)
No it doesn't, because typically you still have to have some legal copy in the first place before private copying rules apply. The levy is about making extra copies.

The biggest problem with this is that if you have a blanket private copying exception to copyright and you also remove the rules about TPMs and anti-circumvention provisions, which is what seems to be proposed in Portugal, then you eliminate any business model more nuanced than selling a permanent copy of a work to each individual customer. No more pay-per-view, no more streaming libraries, no more volume sales or group plans, and no more much lower prices for customers who preferred some of these models to paying full price for a permanent purchase of everything.

Many people on both the production and consumption sides could lose out under such a scheme if it was compulsory, while if it could be overridden contractually then surely everyone's terms would just be updated to do exactly that, and then the new scheme probably wouldn't change much in practice.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by hedora on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:04AM (#14131370)
You are assuming that, without DRM, everyone would use netflix to download all the content, then cancel their subscriptions.

I doubt this would actually happen. Netflix beat out piracy because it is convenient. People that want to pirate netflix content already do (by sharing accounts).

When the music industry abandoned DRM it wasn't a big disaster. I don't see why video would be different.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by Silhouette on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:48AM (#14131765)
I doubt this would actually happen.

As someone with experience running somewhat similar services, I can promise you it does happen. Most customers seem to be honest, but the lengths that a significant minority will go to in order to take advantage of any access or exploit the system are almost unbelievable, and the excuses or arguments they make if you call them on it often read like parody.

When the music industry abandoned DRM it wasn't a big disaster. I don't see why video would be different.

One possibility you might like to consider is that music singles can typically be sold at sub-dollar prices, making an impulse purchase is highly likely, without undermining the commercial viability of the sector. Depending on the nature of the work, the same economics won't necessarily apply to other types of material.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:29AM (#14131091)
Well, no, not legally, at least. You can only copy stuff you already own.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by freehunter on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:28AM (#14131610)
That's interesting. I'm not sure on Portuguese law, but at least in the US it's completely legal to copy stuff you already own. The RIAA and MPAA claim it's not, but it is as long as you don't break the DRM that was originally included on the disc. So unless the law in Portugal doesn't include this fair-use clause, you're paying a tax on media to pay companies for something that is already completely legal.

Again, I don't know Portuguese law, so it may be completely different.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by Silhouette on Monday April 17, 2017 @12:01PM (#14131897)
The US fair use laws are probably the most liberal anywhere in the world when it comes to excluding some acts from copyright protection (at least within those places where copyright is a serious legal proposition in the first place). I don't know anywhere else that uses generic, test-based standards rather than identifying specific acts to be excluded. This has been a long-standing point of contention, because whether the US's fair use regime fully complies with its international obligations under the major treaties is questionable.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pdpi on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:08AM (#14130957)
> That's... a surprisingly (and refreshingly) pragmatic way to deal with that percieved problem, to be honest.

Until you realise that it means the HDDs in your servers pay a piracy tax.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:02AM (#14131349)
No, such companies can get a declaration exempting them from the tax, which they can then show at the time of purchase.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by zepto on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:52PM (#14133408)
What about your personal laptop if you only use it for programming?
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @04:12PM (#14134003)
Nope, just "collective persons" (no individuals).
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @08:00AM (#14130362)
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pedrocr on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:55AM (#14130860)
It's not that common and it wouldn't make it any less of a travesty. It's like taxing all furniture on the off chance you'll use it to store your vinyl records. And like with furniture an increasing majority of your media is used to store your own content (e.g., the video of your kid from your brand new 4K camera) so this isn't even directionally correct.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by icebraining on Monday April 17, 2017 @10:37AM (#14131157)
It's a tax, not a payment. Sure, there's some attempt to target it at people who can actually enjoy that right (can't copy stuff if you have nowhere to copy it to), but it's not supposed to be an exchange for use.
Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by pedrocr on Monday April 17, 2017 @11:05AM (#14131379)
We already have a tax for content authors, this is supposed to be much more targeted. Instead all it does is make local electronics retailers even less competitive when compared to the online players.

This is also a travesty because you're supposedly being taxed for the privilege of enjoying something you are already paying for. In reality it's even worse because this is only relevant to extract money from those who are not buying your content. The ones who are buying your content already have a pricing relationship with you where more or less money can be exchanged for more or less service.

At the end of the day this was just a way for entrenched interests to extract money from the population that wouldn't normally be given to them because they don't produce content that interests them.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by kakarot on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:08PM (#14141896)
Seems like a perfect candidate for flexing out the nasty investor-state arbitration policies that large companies have been trying to pass through recent international trade agreement proposals.

It would be easy to argue that Portugal is forcing them to lose profit because they are not allowed to collect fines for "unauthorized" circumvention.

Re:Portugal Pushes Law to Partially Ban DRM, Allow Circumven... by marcosdumay on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:03AM (#14130603)
> That said, it's fairly mild: only says one can't use DRM to prevent users from enjoying their legal rights, and there's no penalty, except that the DRM breakers won't get fined by our (EU-mandated) anti-circumvention laws

This is sufficient for creating a market for DRM breakers. It's basically the same situation we have at Brazil, you can just take your stuff to a store and have someone remove DRM from stuff you own.