I'm pretty sure that was the whole point. Capitalism is not a magical faery solution to everything, it obviously was not working in this industry so they are trying someone new.
I completely agree, but the solution to that is not granting guaranteed profits to an industry. They are already granted a monopoly market with copyright. Why should they also get to skip the entire legal system and having to actually produce a product people want and jump straight to profits?
We're talking about luxury goods, not healthcare.
They still have to compete for profits to get a share, their sales are just worth a little bit extra to offset the cultural benefit of more freely available music. (Eg, for each dollar they take in, they actually get $1.01.)
In the sense you're using "luxury goods", they're still essential to human cultural and psychological well-being, even if not base survival.
Society's interest in the market for arts isn't to just make money, and adjusting the pay structure as part of balancing competing interests (in this case, mandatory free use) is reasonable.
Even people who aren't directly interested in a particular work have an interest in the overarching production of arts.
I think it's a valid alternative model that accommodates a lower transaction cost and higher overall welfare - more people can benefit from consuming art - provided that the income is sufficient to motivate its production. It's certainly not an open and closed case of anarchy; that's just as ridiculous to claim.
The Eurail / Interrail multi-day all-Europe train tickets have a similar mechanism. The basic requirement for travel is that you write your journey into the ticket's itinerary list (a multi-page lined space that you fill in manually); at the end, at your option, you send off the ticket to receive some kind of souvenir. Functionally this acts as a survey of which train trips were taken, so that the money from sales of the tickets can be distributed.
Who cares about due process and the market, just presume everybody is liable and tax them to guarantee profit to an industry? What a complete perversion of basic capitalism and rule of law.
> It'd be nice to see more countries going with solutions like that
It's nice to pay an extra tax to prop up a poorly-run industry?
>>> There will also be an exception for private copying.
While it's not clear precisely what is meant by "private copying", time-shifting was ruled a fair use in the Betamax case, without the need for a levy.