News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by zipwitch on Sunday April 16, 2017 @03:21PM (#14127050)
The big problem with hiring older workers is that they're better at knowing what they're actually worth. They also tend to avoid personal sacrifices (mainly time and health) that are of net benefit to the company but not to themselves.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Sunday April 16, 2017 @09:56PM (#14128762)
As an employer I do not care how old you are or if you know your "true" worth or not. All I care about is how you are going to contribute to my bottom line with the minimum of fuss. If you can do this at 100 I will hire you.

My experience is older workers are much better (and more productive) than young workers if you can provide them a stable work environment. If the nature of your business is such that this is impossible, then most older workers will struggle and blame the boss for everything. This does not make for a fun time if you are the manager.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by mistermann on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:43PM (#14128907)
If only all people with hiring responsibility were devoted to the bottom line of the business, as opposed to the bottom line of their personal careers.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Sunday April 16, 2017 @11:03PM (#14128977)
Well I have a massive advantage in being the sole owner as well as boss of my business. This does tend to change your perspective on what is important.

You do raise why most manager are not so devoted to the bottom line - it is not their business. Who do you hire - the older employee that will make the business a ton of money, or the young employee who will do as they are told and make the manager's life easy?

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by mistermann on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:04AM (#14129305)
In my experience, not only is it not their business, many middle managers are actively hostile to anyone who is working in the the best interests of the business, as that interferes with their ability to extract value from the business and put it into their own pockets in various different ways.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:24AM (#14130690)
Yes the principle-agent problem has yet to be solved [1]. I wish I had a solution other than keeping the company small and the shareholders involved as managers.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal–agent_problem

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by Arizhel on Monday April 17, 2017 @02:55PM (#14133436)
Wouldn't having regular communications between workers and the manager's boss help here? If the manager's boss is only hearing from the managers directly below him, obviously he's going to get a skewed perspective.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by doug1001 on Monday April 17, 2017 @08:38AM (#14130501)
what do you mean by "stable work environment"? Regardless of how you've defined it, according to your definition, it's something that is (at lest sometimes) beyond the control of management ("If the nature of your business is such that this is impossible....").

are you saying that it's your experience that older workers tend to "blame everything" on the manager--even when particular instability is beyond the manager's control?

i should think the more experience one has, the more likely they are to understand the source of a given impact on their work and the more patient they are likely to be--ie, they've seen it before, and don't take it personally.

at the same time, if indeed the instability is in fact the manager's fault, then i suspect one with more experience is more likely to identify that fact and bring it to the manager's attention.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:20AM (#14130673)
I am saying that people who are struggling in their job blame their boss as the cause. If you put a person into a job that is beyond them they will find an external factor to blame. In my experience this is most commonly management. This is something both young and old do.

While I am not claiming to be a perfect boss (far from it), most of the causes of rapid change my employees have faced are external factors totally outside my control. Small companies are by their nature prone to being buffeted by outside forces. It makes things exciting, if not predictable.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by talmand on Monday April 17, 2017 @09:52AM (#14130845)
Maybe the reason they are struggling in their job is because of the boss? Such as "If you put a person into a job that is beyond them..."?

In my experience if there are external forces beyond the manager's control causing problems for the workers, then the cause is likely someone further up the chain than the manager. Eventually you have to reach someone that is responsible for what happens inside the company.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Monday April 17, 2017 @05:25PM (#14134548)
Yes the boss has to take responsibility for putting a person into a job they are unsuitable for - I have done this thinking I could put smart and hard working older people into jobs that required a lot of context switching. I take full responsibility for the result.

My only defence is I was young and inexperienced. I thought I was being smart by hiring the people other businesses discriminate against. I did at least learn.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by phd514 on Monday April 17, 2017 @08:35PM (#14135638)
It's unclear to me that all the variables have been accounted for in a way that justifies the conclusion that younger workers handle high context switching better than older workers. It's entirely possible that younger workers are simply unaware that frequent context switching is very inefficient so they simply uncomplainingly though inefficiently plod forward in such situations. Sure, that makes for less immediate negative feedback to their immediate managers, but it also makes for less long-term value for the company. As a middle-aged employee, I am at least somewhat more aware of the situations in which I am highly productive and the situations in which I am less productive. When the latter types of situations are more prevalent without good reason, I raise those as problems to my manager since he or his managers should be aware of them. In my experience, my managers have appreciated my proactive feedback rather than my silently plodding through inefficient cycles of work. Perhaps there are situations where the latter is preferable, but I have not encountered them.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by danieltillett on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:02AM (#14136386)
All I can go on is my personal experience which was putting older workers into jobs that have inherently high rates of context switching didn’t do well, while younger workers doing the same job thrived.

I agree with you that there maybe other confounding variables and that there are certainly older workers that are able to thrive in such jobs, just my experience makes me wary. I am also wary of putting younger workers into positions where sustained focus is required. Ultimately neither old nor young workers are bad, they just have different strengths and weaknesses and you need to match the best person to the job.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by talmand on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:19AM (#14138987)
>> they just have different strengths and weaknesses and you need to match the best person to the job

No need to say more.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by Broken_Hippo on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:53PM (#14128544)
Maybe the problem is that employers try to hire the young workers at a cheap rate instead of actually giving them a decent wage. Perhaps the problem is that we expect folks to sacrifice so much for a job when we should be able to provide a place that gives balance, including time off work and reasonable hours, instead of abusing the young workers. Perhaps this is a problem with skewed perspective.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by downrightmike on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:50PM (#14128929)
Just remove the word "perhaps" and stop beating around the bush.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by Broken_Hippo on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:57PM (#14128959)
I had considered that as an afterthought, but was/am honestly too lazy (and tipsy) to bother changing it.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by Thrillington on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:45PM (#14127412)
That sounds more like a systemic problem where companies profitability is put forward as an excuse for anti-social behavior.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by lj3 on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:51PM (#14127439)
> anti-social behavior

You say anti-social behavior. The courts say 'maximizing shareholder value'.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by mitchty on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:09PM (#14127831)
> You say anti-social behavior. The courts say 'maximizing shareholder value'.

Do they now? https://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by coldtea on Sunday April 16, 2017 @06:05PM (#14127803)
The courts also said that for slavery. They are not some be-all end-all argument.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by maxxxxx on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:06PM (#14128358)
"The courts say 'maximizing shareholder value'."

there is no legal requirement to maximize shareholder value. That's just a myth.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by SomeStupidPoint on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:31PM (#14128441)
Even if there was, it wouldn't automatically follow that you needed to maximize short-term value rather than long-term value.

Many of the things put forward as "maximizing shareholder value" are talking about short-term value, and do so at the expense of long-term value.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by eveningcoffee on Sunday April 16, 2017 @07:53PM (#14128306)
Do you think that this is what honest you wants to say about the situation?
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by branchless on Sunday April 16, 2017 @08:35PM (#14128462)
It just amazes me people can't see this. Workers produce value, their labour is the product. The difference between the value produced and the cost of labour is the profit.

Paying labour as little as possible is capitalism. Competition between companies means there is no choice other than to seek to maximize this.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by laughfactory on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:50AM (#14129417)
Well, as an economist, you're close, but not quite there. In truth, in the US, what we've had for a long time is NOT capitalism. It is what you get when you start with capitalism and then add in centuries of rent seeking behavior. Ultimately, at best, what we have is crony capitalism, where corporations and institutions (including labor unions and the government) lobby (aka "rent seek") for preferential treatment under law.

Crucially, I'd argue that we don't get fair capitalistic pricing of labor when there is asymmetric information in the market: Employers pay for access to salary data so they know how much you are worth (approximately), but you have no such knowledge (though this is better than it used to be with services like Glassdoor and Paysa and Salary.com). You're guessing as to the supply and demand for your skill set. Add in the common practice of requiring past salary history to be submitted as part of the application process, and you've got a recipe for suboptimal outcomes, at least on the employee side of the labor equation. If your price gets set below your market value early in your career, it may remain permanently below your actual value because employers often adopt policies which only allow for paying a candidate 10% (or some arbitrary number) more than their last position. This can happen because you underestimate your value initially, or price yourself according to the local market and then move to another market later (say from Salt Lake City to San Diego), or you're out of the labor force for some time (like mothers or fathers who spend them first couple years at home with their new child). The smart candidates will insist on keeping their compensation history confidential (I.e., not sharing it with potential employers), and pass on those organizations who insist that the data be shared. Force them to tell you how much your skill set is worth to them. I've used this strategy to move to a new employer with a 68% increase in compensation. I've also passed on opportunities which required compensation history to be submitted before an offer would be issued. Hopefully legislation will be enacted to make this unnecessary in the future and employers will simply be banned from asking for such data.

Plus, there's a host of policy-related distortions which I won't go into, but basically, no, what we have is not a free market, and not capitalism. What we have is a mess.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by JauntTrooper on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:12PM (#14135230)
You would think there would be plenty of demand from job-seekers to get accurate salary info.

How much would you pay to get an HR professional to give you an accurate quote, backed by solid data, on what your compensation should be at your next job interview? $250? $400? And if they could advise you in salary negotiations? Would you pay a % of the increase they help you get?

I bet there's a real business opportunity here.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by branchless on Monday April 17, 2017 @07:49AM (#14130320)
Interesting that the one reply that wasn't completely dismissive, in the economics hell-hole that is hacker news, was from an economist.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by lj3 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @09:15AM (#14138526)
Funny. What I got from his response is that you're still wrong. He just said it in a nicer way than the rest of us.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 16, 2017 @09:53PM (#14128750)
No. I hate capitalism but this is not how economics works. Please, get a textbook or two (Barron's publishes some excellent revision guides that are well-written and cheap on a variety of business subjects, including economics), and study it for a year or two.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by branchless on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:31PM (#14128869)
I disagree.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by capisce on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:01PM (#14128781)
Exactly, it's one of the coordination problems inherent in a free market economy. It can be ameliorated or patched through regulation, unionizing, or solved indirectly through industry shifts causing increased labor bargaining power in a given sector. Although the trend doesn't seem to be heading in the direction of increased demand for labor.
Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by mistermann on Sunday April 16, 2017 @10:47PM (#14128919)
> Paying labour as little as possible is capitalism.

Overly simplistic, and incorrect.

Re:Older Workers Challenge Firms’ Aggressive Pursuit of the ... by esoterica on Monday April 17, 2017 @01:21AM (#14129339)
Well if they can't get hired then it sounds like they don't know what they're actually worth, do they.