News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by jacquesm on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:05PM (#14111795)
> My MacBook Pro requires about 1/6 the electricity of my 2007 Desktop

Apples to Oranges though (or Apples, but still). The comparison should be a laptop from 2007. I ran a house on solar electricity and windpower back then, my laptop was about 35 Watts according to the e-meter connected to it, my present day laptop is roughly the same.

Laptops have always been substantially more efficient than desktops.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by caseysoftware on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:12PM (#14112036)
> Laptops have always been substantially more efficient than desktops.

Yes but a decade+ ago, they weren't a replacement for a desktop, so you ended up having both. Now even mid end laptops (or "low end" Macs) are totally feasible as replacements.

I bought my last desktop in 2010 and I can't imagine buying another one.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by noir_lord on Friday April 14, 2017 @05:23AM (#14113422)
> I bought my last desktop in 2010 and I can't imagine buying another one.

I still do 95% of my development on a desktop, I just can't see ever not doing that, I'm older now and a good desk, good chair, 3 big screens takes up enough space that a tower isn't taking up much more space.

That and I can put hardware into a PC for half the price of a Macbook Pro that will absolute annihilate the laptop on performance.

Portability and power efficiency does impose a constraint.

For me the trade off of having two machines is worth it rather than having one machine that is permanently hobbled by been designed for a use case I rarely use makes no sense.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by ProblemFactory on Friday April 14, 2017 @10:02AM (#14114474)
> I'm older now and a good desk, good chair, 3 big screens takes up enough space that a tower isn't taking up much more space.

I do the same, 95% of my development with a Macbook Pro with 2 big screens, keyboard and mouse attached. Don't even touch or move it on most days.

A desktop would be much cheaper - but I would still need a decent laptop for the 5% time when I'm not at my desk, so the savings aren't that much any more. And keeping development environments, VMs, config files, keyboard layouts, etc syncronized on two separate computers is too much extra work.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by noir_lord on Friday April 14, 2017 @10:20AM (#14114590)
I have an oldish but fairly beefy Vostro that does in a pinch, keeping things synchronised isn't that hard in practice since the vagrant files and project files all live in git but yeah there is some overhead but I have that anyway since I have a desktop at the office and at home.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by tempay on Friday April 14, 2017 @11:25AM (#14114982)
> keeping things synchronised isn't that hard in practice

I disagree, I think how difficult it is to keep things synced varies significantly between users. Sure, its easy if your work is consistent and you're disciplined but if you find yourself switching between very different projects frequently the overhead of syncing machines and setting up software repeatedly can become significant.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by noir_lord on Friday April 14, 2017 @02:04PM (#14115971)
> frequently the overhead of syncing machines and setting up software repeatedly can become significant.

It takes some discipline.

I run a small consultancy/agency, in any given week I'm switching between 3-5 projects (and odd bug fixes to others).

I've automated my entire workflow with vagrant and ansible.

I have

    /projects/<client>/<codename>/site (pr /app)
    /projects/<client>/<codename>/vagrant
    /projects/<client>/<codename>/<others>
Each client gets a "team" in bitbucket and orchestration becomes no harder than

git pull && vagrant up.

It works great on projects that have a simple structure (webserver/db) and projects that have complex configurations with ES/Redis as well.

The trick is to always treat configuration as code and never make manual changes to a VM (or more correctly, always make a manual change then a change to configuration code).

As an entirely added side benefit I can pull a project from two years ago down and be up in a fraction of the time without polluting my host OS.

Even when that project is currently on 14.04 with particular weird dependencies (exactly this version of wkhtmltopdf etc).

Longer term I'll probably look at docker or something but vagrant/ansible has worked out great (some projects aren't even using ansible, just a bash script).

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by NoGravitas on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:05AM (#14114196)
Fair enough, but... my 2010 desktop was a lot more energy efficient than my 2005 desktop. And my 2017 desktop is probably going to be made from what are effectively laptop parts in a brick the size of a large hardback, with the power supply external like a laptop.

So while most people are moving to laptop-only, even us hold-outs are seeing more energy efficiency in desktops.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by posguy on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:52PM (#14112204)
The power states and performance per watt have gone way up too, in 2007 power gating CPUs was not commonplace, and Intel was just starting to optimize for performance per watt (especially in the low power laptop/tablet market).

What vendors have done is provide computers with the same power envelope, but much more performance so they may do your calculations @ 35 watts, and then immediately cut all power to large swaths of the CPU so as to curtail power use by at least a few watts, if not 10 watts (depends on your CPU).

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by Kenji on Friday April 14, 2017 @05:28AM (#14113434)
>Yes but a decade+ ago, they weren't a replacement for a desktop, so you ended up having both. Now even mid end laptops (or "low end" Macs) are totally feasible as replacements.

You obviously don't play video games, do CAD or video stuff or develop and compile large software. My desktop is never replaced by my laptop.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by vertex-four on Friday April 14, 2017 @06:37AM (#14113646)
Video games run perfectly reasonably for a casual player, and even some low-level competitive players, on a mid-spec laptop. Not everybody demands that the latest Crytek game run at 60fps on extra-high settings 100% of the time. Aside from that - most people don't do those things either. A laptop is totally feasible as a replacement for the 99.99% of people who could also get away with a 5 year old desktop.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by kbart on Friday April 14, 2017 @08:58AM (#14114169)
I'm not much of a gamer, but still find tiny screen and keyboard limiting gaming experience more than graphic settings.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by NoGravitas on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:06AM (#14114201)
Right, but most of the laptop-only people will dock their laptop at a desk with a big screen and keyboard.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by caseysoftware on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:49AM (#14114404)
Yes, when I plug in at home, I plug my laptop into a pair of 22" screens, a simple sound system, and a keyboard.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by Kenji on Friday April 14, 2017 @11:54AM (#14115168)
Have fun putting a 180W, 30cm long graphics card into your Laptop to play a new game on low-medium settings at a stable framerate.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by sirtaj on Friday April 14, 2017 @12:42PM (#14115464)
Why not? eGPU dock prices have come down significantly in the last few months.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by outworlder on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:41PM (#14111902)
True, however desktops are getting more efficient, too. You can have an impressive amount of computing power (GPU and CPU) with a couple hundred watts.

Just a couple of years ago I had a 800w PSU to be able to run modern games. Now I have a mini-ITX machine with a 450w power supply with a lot of room to grow. I'd estimate actual power usage to be 50-60% the nominal capacity at peak.

It's hard to compete with a laptop in power consumption, of course. My CPU's TDP is higher than 35w. It's an I3, so Intel says 51W TDP. It will still run circles around the laptop's cpu.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by fnj on Friday April 14, 2017 @06:44AM (#14113667)
> desktops are getting more efficient, too. You can have an impressive amount of computing power (GPU and CPU) with a couple hundred watts.

Jeeze, my desktop, a full socket 1150 Core i3, is under 100 watts. Heck, I have a file server with twelve 3.5" hard drives and a 4 core socket 1150 Xeon that draws under 200 watts with everything spinning.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by kbart on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:01AM (#14114182)
Powerful GPU alone can draw 200-300 W of power.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by jacquesm on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:19PM (#14112061)
The big competitor really is AWS, especially with their multi-gpu instances. For gamers not really an option to have their GPUs at the end of a wire but for a lot of other applications it makes good sense.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by Arizhel on Friday April 14, 2017 @01:12AM (#14112812)
>The comparison should be a laptop from 2007.

>Laptops have always been substantially more efficient than desktops.

No, they haven't; not on a MIPS/Watt basis. A laptop-to-desktop comparison is entirely valid. I use a laptop now, and a desktop in the past; I do the same work, and I get better performance out of my modern laptop. I even have dual 24" monitors on the laptop (docking station).

Demanding a comparison between desktops of the mid-2000s and desktops of now is like demanding a comparison between the fuel consumption of a Corvette from the 1980s and one from now, instead of recognizing that I can buy an economy car now that gets better performance than the 1980s Corvette while also getting much better fuel economy. If you're comparing on the basis of performance and capability, you don't need to stay with the same class of device, because capabilities and performance have changed so much over time.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by wutbrodo on Friday April 14, 2017 @02:35AM (#14112996)
> The comparison should be a laptop from 2007.

Why? When we're talking about overall usage, functional replacements are far more relevant than direct device-category to device-category comparisons. In much the same way, the fact that my mom has replaced her desktop with a tablet is the directly relevant comparison for my mom's "electricity usage due to personal computing".

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by djrogers on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:51PM (#14111947)
> Apples to Oranges though (or Apples, but still). The comparison should be a laptop from 2007

Nope, in 2007 a lot of people used and needed desktops that are more than satisfied by the available computing power on a laptop today. It's only an apples-oranges comparison if everyone were still using desktops, which is not the case.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by seanmcdirmid on Thursday April 13, 2017 @11:19PM (#14112517)
In 2007, even more people had their needs met by laptops. Heck, there were people in 2002 who went laptop full time. Anyone looking closely enough in 2000 could see the writing on the wall.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by mbreese on Friday April 14, 2017 @12:58AM (#14112776)
I bought my last desktop in 1996. After that, I switched over to using a docked laptop as a replacement in 2000.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by DiabloD3 on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:18PM (#14111822)
I used to have the same argument... until I realized modern laptops can be desktop replacements (without being those gigantic bricktop "mobile/portable workstations").

Just slap a full sized monitor and a keyboard+mouse, and its more capable as a thin desktop (ala iMac) than the actual thing, and when you want to leave, just unplug all that shit and leave.

The only call for full sized desktops is people like me, where cramming in full sized GPUs, more than one drive, and 32+GB of RAM is required.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by outworlder on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:42PM (#14111912)
> The only call for full sized desktops is people like me, where cramming in full sized GPUs, more than one drive, and 32+GB of RAM is required.

That, or when you need more CPU horsepower than what a laptop will provide. Even if it is not thermal throttled, if it is not a big laptop, odds are it is using a very low power part.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by posguy on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:56PM (#14112216)
Definitely, heat dissipation and power envelope limitations on laptops are still a major issue, but with power gating coming standard on most chips and very aggressive p states, average power usage is down by double digit margins on your average CPU over the last decade.

This is very beneficial for servers and workstations too, as it keeps your power bill much lower, and makes it not financially viable to stick around on 8+ year old hardware, where it draws 250 watts for half the performance of a year or two old system, that will pull 60 watts minimum, and while topping out at 250 watts, will like average around 70 watts or so, saving you about $180 a year at $0.12/kwh.

Edit: Missed a zero, reworded last sentence.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by douche on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:45PM (#14111928)
They don't make true mac desktop replacements anymore. My gf has an old, old, 17" MacBook. There are no equivalents for a modern upgrade.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by jonnathanson on Friday April 14, 2017 @09:21AM (#14114285)
I have a 2007 17" MBP, fully loaded for its time, that was still giving me great service as a classic gaming machine (via Bootcamp) as recently as six months ago. In its prime it was essentially a true desktop replacement for most work activity. Sadly, it's about ready to give up the ghost. There are fewer and fewer use cases I can justify squeezing out of it these days. But what a hell of a decade it's given me.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by noir_lord on Friday April 14, 2017 @05:26AM (#14113427)
I have a Vostro 3750 I don't want to replace as it has a 17" screen (though only 1600x900) and a full sized keyboard (with numpad).

If they gave me a modern version at 3200x1800 with a decent i5 I'd be buying another.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by Scoundreller on Thursday April 13, 2017 @09:23PM (#14112084)
and $$$ for reasonable resolution, let alone dpi.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by jacquesm on Thursday April 13, 2017 @08:27PM (#14111857)
> The only call for full sized desktops is people like me, where cramming in full sized GPUs, more than one drive, and 32+GB of RAM is required.

That's exactly why I'm still stuck on a desktop.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by Cerium on Friday April 14, 2017 @12:28AM (#14112699)
Stuck? I love my desktop. When I am not at my desk I use remote desktop to access my desktop.
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by hannob on Friday April 14, 2017 @05:38AM (#14113466)
> Apples to Oranges though (or Apples, but still). The comparison should be a laptop from 2007. I ran a house on solar electricity and windpower back then, my laptop was about 35 Watts according to the e-meter connected to it, my present day laptop is roughly the same.

No, it shouldn't. Many people use laptops today for the things they used Desktops in the past.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by gaius on Friday April 14, 2017 @04:34AM (#14113296)
To put that 35W into perspective, my old SGI workstation has a 750W PSU...
Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by kelnos on Thursday April 13, 2017 @10:01PM (#14112241)
I permanently turned off my last desktop around 2007, and have been using a laptop exclusively since. I had a media PC I built under my TV, and I shut that off permanently around 2010, replacing it with a Google TV device that I later stopped using. Nowadays I have a laptop (no external monitor, even), a reasonably low-powered NAS, and a ChromeCast, and that covers my computing/media needs at home.

In that time I also went from a CRT TV to a plasma, and at some point in the next year or so I'll probably swap that out for a (lower power) OLED TV or similar.

(As an aside, 35W for a laptop today seems excessive. Assuming PowerTop is accurate, my laptop is using 9W right now. While charging it's undoubtedly using more, but even plugged in while fully charged, with less of the power-saving features enabled, 35W seems a bit high.)

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by jacquesm on Thursday April 13, 2017 @10:08PM (#14112268)
> with less of the power-saving features enabled, 35W seems a bit high

That's wall plug consumption, and a pretty beefy laptop, i7, high res screen, as much RAM as it will hold and a large (spinning) disk (Lenovo T540p).

Even totally idle it is still around 20W.

Re:The De-Electrification of the U.S. Economy by fnj on Friday April 14, 2017 @06:39AM (#14113654)
> Laptops have always been substantially more efficient than desktops.

Not when you compare like to like. You should be comparing those feeble laptops with NUCs.