News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by YCAU on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:14PM (#14038171)
The effects were cool, but I wish they hadn't randomly remixed elements from the franchise with a story that directly goes against the themes of the original. Then ending was diametrically opposed to the ending of the original. While I think the effects were great, the intellectual treatment reminds me of the knife throwing scene in the Starship Troopers adaptation...
Re:Ghost in the Shell by crdb on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:54PM (#14038740)
> the knife throwing scene in the Starship Troopers adaptation

That was on purpose. Verhoeven allegedly didn't read the book (which I doubt) and set out to create a parody of it. The movie is ridiculous because it is supposed to be ridiculous, mocking the US military as dumb hicks (enlisted AND leadership), its culture and its purpose as "fascist" and pointless, in 1997, at the tail end of a relatively peaceful period with no major conflicts for the US.

I suspect the scene [2] is a reference to the book chapter where a soldier is executed for mutiny, which Heinlein uses to demonstrate why a wartime military has strict discipline and which Verhoeven openly mocks (indeed Zim's speech about why infantry is needed in the nuclear age [1] in the book answers the same question as the movie scene).

I have not watched the new Ghost in the Shell but I doubt the director set out to ridicule the original, so the spirit of your remark still stands.

[1] https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Starship_Troopers#Chapter_5

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNhYJgDdCu4

Re:Ghost in the Shell by Jare on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @10:57PM (#14039309)
> mocking the US military

See, I have never agreed with this interpretation. I think Verhoeven is mocking society at large and how we celebrate appearances and shallowness rather than appreciate independence and quality of thought. There's plenty of vitriol for everyone and everything, of course, but to me the movie is driven by the idea that society is happy to be sheeped around by lies and propaganda. In contrast, the military is a place where stupidity (yours or someone else's) has consequences.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by inopinatus on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:20AM (#14041521)
I remember listening to the movie commentary track on the DVD release. It really was quite hilarious, the interplay between Verhoeven -- making thunderingly clear his assertion "war makes fascists of us all" and making it very evident the film is an ironic political statement and a parody of WW2 propaganda, vs the film's soft-spoken screenplay writer (also co-writer of "Robocop") Edward Neumeier, who is sometimes desperately trying to walk back the director's vitriolic attacks on anyone dumb enough to like the film at face value. Most enjoyable, and Neumeier loses that battle.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by Jare on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:14AM (#14042209)
Darn, I bought the DVD when it came out as a two-sided disc (!) with no commentary. And now I... er... how does one get DVD movie commentaries / featurettes in this day and age?
Re:Ghost in the Shell by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @10:06PM (#14039085)
> Verhoeven allegedly didn't read the book (which I doubt) and set out to create a parody of it.

He didn't set out to create a parody of the book, he set out to create a parody of the message he interpreted the book to have without reading it (and accepting that he didn't read the book is the only interpretation of the facts that does not amount to calling Verhoeven an idiot -- well, in his interpretation of the book of the book, at least.)

> The movie is ridiculous because it is supposed to be ridiculous

The movie is ridiculous on many levels, only the most trivial of them apparently intentional. (It is probably not, for instance, intended to be ridiculous as a parody of, or even response to, the written work.)

Re:Ghost in the Shell by desas on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @02:24AM (#14040123)
Verhoeven had the idea for the story wanting to make a satire of the fascist side of American society. Later someone pointed out the plot similarities to Starship Troopers and so they optioned that and made some tweaks to the script to match. It's why there's no powered armour for example. Verhoeven only read the first two chapters of the book before condemning it as boring and right wing.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by aedron on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:42AM (#14041639)
That's the same conclusion I came to when attempting to read Heinlein. Does it go deeper than that?
Re:Ghost in the Shell by randallsquared on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:00AM (#14041742)
ST does go deeper than that. More broadly, the rest of Heinlein ranges so widely across the mainstream political spectrum that it would be easy to pick 20% of it to paint a picture of Heinlein as far-right, far-left, libertarian, or apolitical. It used to be widely held that this was a chronological shift in his attitudes from the 1930s to 1980s, but that seems not to be the case, now: he just chose which of his non-mainstream views to showcase in any given work.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @09:48AM (#14042039)
I'm not sure you can really call the views espoused by any of Heinlein's viewpoint characters Heinlein's own views; there are a few common themes, but there are so many conflicts between them (or even within the same character) that, except where they directly line up with his nonfiction advocacy, it's probably better to take the view that Heinlein's work is often exploring alternate political approaches rather than acting as polemic for them.

It's also perhaps worth noting, in the context of ST, that the "service is optional, but required for citizenship" model was presented prior to the all-volunteer military at a time when each of the last several generations had been subject to at least one large-scale draft, and the US (and most of the rest of the world) had a system where service was tied to citizenship but (well, for men at least) mandatory on demand, universal in practice, and quite often deadly.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by FullMtlAlcoholc on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:57PM (#14039544)
As I said above, it is definitely intentional. It has the same style as the original Robocop
Re:Ghost in the Shell by ghaff on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @10:51PM (#14039277)
As both an overall fan of Heinlein and of his Starship Troopers book, perhaps I'm in the minority in that I also liked the movie.

That said, I don't take it too seriously which arguably misses any intended satirical point. As you say, to the degree that I found the movie more amusing than serious satirical commentary on Heinlein it may well have failed in its purpose.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by andreyk on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:33PM (#14038278)
Interesting. As a big fan of the original and to a lesser extent the show, I actually liked and was impressed by how deftly they combined and remixed elements from different incarnations of Ghost In The Shell. Many seem to criticize this adaptation for not exploring the same themes or reaching the same conclusions as the original, but I was pleasantly surprised they did something new and did not just try to replicate the original. It's different, but to me also seems to be very much 'in the spirit' of the source material.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by YCAU on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:20PM (#14038571)
That's what's confusing to me. Why recreate so many scenes if they're trying to tell a new story? Why use Kuze's name and some details of his backstory, but put him in the place of the Puppetmaster with a wholly new theme to explore? Why is it important that Batou not have his fancy eyes until halfway in, rather than many years before, or if you're changing it anyway, why have them at all?

If they made an original story with the same setting and characters, I might have liked it more. But it seemed like they just included some iconic scenes from the original to draw in the fanbase and gave a bait and switch with something new, and conclusions I found much less profound and interesting. I found it... lazy. Like the writers didn't respect the original, and just said "what do we have to make up to get from set piece remake 1 to set piece remake 2?" "oh hey let's use this name I heard from way later on in the story because IDK." Again I must compare it to the slipshod work of the Starship Troopers adaptation. Certainly nowhere near as bad (I do think this movie was good in some respects), but they made many of the same mistakes in terms of reusing and deviating from source material (Why did you make X change? Ignorance, rule of cool, deliberate tone shift? It's unclear.).

Oh, and she blinked. ;)

Re:Ghost in the Shell by Corrado on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:54AM (#14041701)
I really liken it to the script writers playing the telephone game[0] about GiTS and it's history. The things you point out, as well as not explaining/introducing anyone really bugged me. I guess Pazu and Borma were there somewhere, and Togusa had some screen time but you didn't really know who he was. Saito finally made an appearance near the end of the film as was on-screen for 10s of seconds. And why did everyone speak english except for Aramaki?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_whispers

Re:Ghost in the Shell by mathewsanders on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:59PM (#14038771)
I've just been googling to remind myself of themes in the other movies and films and realised that with the dogs that Batou feeds they also pulled the Basset Hound from the GITS: Innocence movie
Re:Ghost in the Shell by FullMtlAlcoholc on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @10:37AM (#14042375)
> Many seem to criticize this adaptation for not exploring the same themes or reaching the same conclusions as the original

It didn't need do that. It could've told a totally different story and been set in Rio and it would've been fine if the script wasn't in Hollywood formula 101. I saw this movie before and it was called Robocop. And the dialogue was beyond awful. Arrival took a chance and assumed that the audience wasn't intellectually sterile. Pacific Rim (which I love btw) and its intentionally bad plot was better.

The whitewashing bothers me not so much that the Major needed to be Asian per se. It's that Hollywood just doesn't think an asian person can be a lead in a movie that doesn't have kung fu in it.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by glup on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:19PM (#14038568)
As someone who liked the shows (esp. 2nd Gig) and thought the original was meh, I thought the new movie was US cultural appropriation and bleaching at its worst. I'd be very sad if I had sold the rights and seen a science fiction ecosystem obliterated in that way.

It's worth noting that there are multiple subtitle tracks and dubs out there for the show; the good ones are pretty steeped in literary and sociological theory and have strong post-colonial / anti-capitalist / transhumanist themes. Characters deliver awesome rambling monologues on topics that would no way make it onto US network television.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by rangibaby on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:03PM (#14038792)
> I'd be very sad if I had sold the rights and seen a science fiction ecosystem obliterated in that way

Dragonball Evolution was such a massive turd that it got the original creator of the series to return to it after 20ish years and make "real" movies.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by mgarfias on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:08PM (#14038500)
I loved it.

Also, my wife who was never able to grasp the original movie "got" this immediately.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by lazzlazzlazz on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:15PM (#14038546)
That's because the new one was essentially simplified to the level of a Robocop cliché. It was really embarrassing to see how limited movie producers believe our imaginations are.

The original Ghost in the Shell is still difficult for many to grasp because the core theme around the essential features of identity are not yet culturally available to everyone.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by mgarfias on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:19PM (#14038566)
I didn't get that at all. Both still ask what it means to be human. This just asked it in a slightly different way that made it more accessible.

Mostly her beefs with the original was be lack of things that explain what's going on. This movie made those things more accssible.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by YCAU on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:35PM (#14038653)
But that's the thing. They mixed up so many elements from the original movie and series it doesn't ask the same questions at all. Here we have two people whose brains were put into bodies and reprogrammed. This is not the case with the original, where you have a different mind of sorts that doesn't actually need a body and isn't bound to a brain. And at the climax, the answer to "join me" was "yes", but this movie had a "no".
Re:Ghost in the Shell by notgood on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:36PM (#14038950)
She probably said "no" in order to be able to make further sequels movies with the same top-selling actress (whatever her name is), not due some deep philosophical decision.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by Whitestrake on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @02:41AM (#14040203)
That appears to be an objectionable decision in and of itself, if I understand the argument of the person you've replied to.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by lolive on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @03:53AM (#14040482)
She had already transcended in Lucy. Once is enough...
Re:Ghost in the Shell by mgarfias on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:40PM (#14038674)
Eh, I didn’t find it that big of a deal. That is, it didn’t ruin the movie for me.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by mathewsanders on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:54PM (#14038738)
The 'no' surprised me so much I laughed
Re:Ghost in the Shell by notgood on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:30PM (#14038930)
Bah; I wasn't able to grasp Serial Experiments Lain but I wouldn't change it one single thing; I prefer something that tries to challenge my intellect that a plot simpler than a rom-comedy; there is already too much of the latter anyway.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by FullMtlAlcoholc on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:56PM (#14039537)
I thought Starship Troopers was a great movie. It was a satire in the same style as the original Robocop.

Verhoven did not share in Heinlein's militaristic vision of the future where only citizens are granted the right to vote. The movie so blatantly portrayed humans as fascist that Neil Patrick Harris was wearing an SS uniform.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by casion on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:16PM (#14043723)
Could you explain your reference to the "knife throwing scene in the Starship Troopers adaptation..."

I am familiar with the scene, but I don't understand why you are bringing it up.

Re:Ghost in the Shell by douche on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:49AM (#14041670)
Now there's a book that deserves a half-way decent reboot movie. Or maybe go with Armor instead.
Re:Ghost in the Shell by equalunique on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:47PM (#14038991)
Correct. The ending WAS diametrically opposed to the original.