News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrb on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @03:51PM (#14036539)
Android is open source and has a permissive license. Fundamentally this means Google cannot prevent manufacturers like Samsung from shipping insecure phones receiving infrequent software updates. I am curious as to what you think Google "should" do? Make Android closed source like iOS and ship it as binary blobs and a license forcing manufacturers to ship sw updates exactly when Google says to do so? You think phone manufacturers would agree to that? They would promptly fork off the last open source Android and rarely take Google's subsequent updates.

If you want a phone with top-notch security, buy a Google phone which is guaranteed, by Google, to come with 3 years of monthly security updates.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by joelthelion on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:32PM (#14036908)
> If you want a phone with top-notch security, buy a Google phone which is guaranteed, by Google, to come with 3 years of monthly security updates.

I find it amazing that supporting a $1000 phone for 3 years is considered excellent. It's not very sustainable to make several billion new smartphones every 3 years...

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrb on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:51PM (#14037084)
Pixel starts at $650 not $1000.

But I agree that $500+ phones (Google AND Apple) should IMHO be security-supported for 5 years. It would be better for all of us.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by eggnet on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:11PM (#14038520)
The OP didn't say that the Pixel starts at $1000.

A 128GB Pixel XL with device protection is $968 US before tax and still has the same 3 year support as the entry level Pixel.

The fact is Google sells a $1000 phone with 3 years of support. They also sell less expensive variants with 3 years of support.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by akoster on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:29PM (#14039453)
$500+ iPhone 5 (2012) user checking in here, currently into the 5th year of updating to the latest (most patched) OS version. I wish android had something like this.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrb on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @02:16AM (#14040094)
Like I said elsewhere Apple is not always that good. If you bought the iPhone 4S on September 9, 2014 right before it was discontinued, the last iOS update it received was 9.3.5 on August 25, 2016. Just 2 years of support...
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by Kurtz79 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:18AM (#14041495)
That's kind of unfair, the iPhone 4S was released on September 2011, so it was supported 5 years since release. It went through 5 (!) major releases of iOS, from 5.0 to 9.3.5.

If you buy a phone that you know is already going to be obsoleted soon (it's not like Apple makes its release schedule a mystery), you should assume it will have less support than the latest model.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by ericzawo on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:50PM (#14039513)
How's it run though?
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by kuschku on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:50PM (#14037992)
Pixel starts at over $900 in Europe.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by vinay427 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @03:40PM (#14044919)
This includes a significant VAT that varies by country, so the price isn't comparable to the listed US price which excludes any applicable sales taxes. That being said, the consumer is still paying nearly $1000 USD for their device with the hidden tax.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by srcmap on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @02:05AM (#14040054)
Google can create a new "Android Security Update Guarantee" services - for phone vendors.

When phone vendors releases a phone, they can deposit the vendors custom binaries/source in google servers.

Google will maintain and release security updates for vendors for X number of years for Y amount of $$$/Year.

The phone vendors can snap a "Android Security Update Guarantee by Google until year ZZZZ" logo/label on the phone.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by signal11 on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:23AM (#14041537)
Back when phones were mostly sold via carriers ("new phone every 2 years"), I suspect OEMs wouldn't want it because updates would almost guarantee no updates for the duration that the phone was supported by Google.

In a plateauing market where more customers buy their own phones, it could be a differentiating factor. As an iPhone user I buy an unlocked phone every 3 years or so, updates are therefore important to me -- but clearly not to enough of the Android market right now.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by Natanael_L on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @05:51AM (#14040919)
Would be too expensive to justify, unless you want the patches to be barebones with minimal testing
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by pasbesoin on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:37PM (#14036952)
Some of us tried that, right after Google's Motorola acquisition. Didn't work out so well for us. (It was the only "Google" option at the time for those of us who needed to be on Verizon for their network specifics.)

Right now, I'm on a Nexus 5x that works on Verizon while not officially supported. Verizon network, without the Verizon crapware and retarded (as in, delayed or never delivered) security updates. I might move to the Pixel 2, when it comes out. Even then, I'll buy it directly from Google and forego the Verizon crapware-and-delay leash.

Samsung seems to have a renewed commitment to timely updates, and the moxie to pressure U.S. carriers to pass them on -- somewhat.

Other than that, I'd advise most of my friends to stay away from Android on U.S. carriers. It continues to be a shitstorm. My friends with Apple remain mostly simply happy and unstressed. I'm not particularly fond of "walled gardens." But for a lot of people, it's "just a phone" and they want it to "just work."

My point regarding Google itself: They bought Motorola and had Motorola thence promising timely updates for a reasonable period of time. Didn't happen.

I trust Google to do what it perceives to be in its best interest. Including updating its own phones for PR reasons. Beyond that, just like the newer products they launch or buy and then often kill a year later, it's a crapshoot.

P.S. Like others are expressing, Google's a big place with many pieces. As to the topic of the OP, I'm glad Project Zero continues to have support and is doing what it's doing. And that it has the muscle and inertia of Google behind it, to weather the political and legal shitstorm attendant with the mess that is is IS/IT security, these days.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by wtallis on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @03:55PM (#14036567)
Google has substantial leverage with the Android trademarks and the Play store ecosystem.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by srcmap on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:55AM (#14040002)
In windows 10, I use procexp (from sysinternals) with totalvirus check enable.

Basically, it allows all the running .exe programs signatures be checked at once with 56+ virus checking websites and results shows up in the GUI of procexp.

No wasting of CPU cycles to scan every files in the system, typical < 3 seconds to check all the running programs - Light up green/red in GUI.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnPtuTbqzd4&t=3s

Love to see google do something similar to this in Android.

It is very trivial for Google to dev, deploy these kind of tools/REST API/website. If this is deploy in billions + Android phones, Google should be able to detected/collected/analyze new/potential malwares instantly.

Known good programs with valid signatures - do nothing.

Unknown programs sig - setup special container and monitors app behavior - collect the binaries if needed.

Also, I think google should be able to separate the Google control portions of AOSP from the 3rd party vendors systems drivers/utilities and allow them to be upgrade separately.

I used to work on porting the AOSP on cell/tablet SOC before. It is doable.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by adrianN on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @08:21AM (#14041525)
I don't think that, in the grand scheme of things, anti virus programs are really helping. Once you have the machine compromised, hiding from a scan isn't terribly difficult.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by GrinningFool on Thursday April 06, 2017 @02:47PM (#14053379)
> No wasting of CPU cycles to scan every files in the system, typical < 3 seconds to check all the running programs - Light up green/red in GUI.

THis sounds good, but it can take much less than 3 seconds to compromise user-space data and ship it off.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by collinmanderson on Friday April 07, 2017 @09:49AM (#14059585)
totalvirus -> VirusTotal
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by tastythrowaway2 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:13PM (#14037728)
This. Parent post doesn't realize this basic architectural advantage that should be leveraged.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by kalleboo on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @11:34PM (#14039473)
What they should do is what Microsoft did - make hardware drivers independent from the OS version. I don't need Dell to recompile the NT Kernel for me every patch Tuesday.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrmondo on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:13AM (#14039844)
Because the Microsoft driver ecosystem is in a good state...
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by pcwalton on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:13PM (#14036734)
> They would promptly fork off the last open source Android and rarely take Google's subsequent updates.

And thereby lose access to the Play Store?

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by tonyztan on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:00PM (#14038062)
Amazon Kindle fires don't have Play Store. Manufacturers could set up their own app stores like Amazon did.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by ReverseCold on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:27PM (#14038248)
Amazon is the only one who could possibly pull that off. Everyone else needs the play store.

Amazon would probably let them use their store though...

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by kbenson on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:33PM (#14038276)
> Amazon is the only one who could possibly pull that off. Everyone else needs the play store.

Samsung alone has more market share (by device) than Apple.[1] Samsung could probably do it, but it would be bumpy.

> Amazon would probably let them use their store though...

Maybe not without major concessions. Amazon subsidizes a lot of apps in their store because of their add serving architecture.

1: http://www.idc.com/promo/smartphone-market-share/vendor

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by escap on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @09:33PM (#14038940)
There is no Google Play store in China.

It might come though http://www.androidpolice.com/2017/02/06/no-really-this-time-...

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by kartickv on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @10:12PM (#14039111)
Maybe change the license to one that requires manufacturers provide security patches for three years, except for non-profits? Entities that release only software, like a modding community, would be exempt.

Yes, this won't be "open-source", but it will be open enough, in that you can still read the source code, modify it, ship a phone without Google's permission, and so on.

The free for all model we have isn't working.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by peterwwillis on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:59PM (#14037146)
If Microsoft had required Dell, HP, Lenovo, Samsung, Toshiba, Acer, Asus, etc all to provide free operating system upgrades on your PC every time there was a Microsoft security hole, Windows would have been deader than dirt years ago.

Google gets away with this because it is "free", so the refrain is "you can't complain if it's free". Google could go the same route Microsoft did, but it chooses not to.

Phone manufacturers would be happy to have binary blob updates for free - but it would never happen. Google would have to custom-build, test, and certify every binary blob for every piece of hardware, which is an unjustifiable cost.

If you want a phone with top-notch security, buy an Apple phone. They're supported longer, they fix their security bugs promptly, and they honestly have a better model for their OS anyway. (disclaimer: I hate Apple)

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by cwyers on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:07PM (#14037685)
> If Microsoft had required Dell, HP, Lenovo, Samsung, Toshiba, Acer, Asus, etc all to provide free operating system upgrades on your PC every time there was a Microsoft security hole, Windows would have been deader than dirt years ago.

What? Double what? Microsoft doesn't require this because they don't require they have a stable driver ABI, so Microsoft can ship updates to Microsoft code without requiring that device manufacturers ship updated drivers to go with.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by zrm on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:29PM (#14038259)
And so we come to the root of the problem.

Either Android/Linux needs a stable driver ABI, or somehow (looking at you Google) the hardware vendors have to be convinced to release driver source.

Last weekend I installed the latest Debian on a Pentium II from 1997. What madness that I can't install the latest Android on a three year old phone?

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by kogepathic on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @12:46AM (#14039724)
> What madness that I can't install the latest Android on a three year old phone?

Unfortunately I think this falls to Linus and the kernel developers.

The ARM portions of the kernel are a fucking dumpster fire of epic proportions.

Because every SoC vendor can bolt on different components, there is a truckload of one off code in the kernel to handle every variation of an SoC a vendor makes. Couple this with the fact that there are very few rules governing where and how vendors connect external devices via IO, and you have code for specific boards to ensure they work.

It's simply not maintainable. Many ARM boards ship with heavily patched kernels, which while having their source code released, will never be merged into the mainline kernel because of lack of effort by the manufacturer or simply the kludgy nature of the code offending the good senses of kernel developers.

Where Google can help is by preventing manufacturers from shipping a device with Android unless their kernel changes have been accepted to mainline Linux. This is the only way to ensure support for multiple years.

Actually, that will only help devices which have Google Play Services. Since Android is open source Chinese manufacturers can just release their own builds based off AOSP which don't include Google Play Services and then Google has absolutely no recourse.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by fulafel on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @01:24AM (#14039887)
Kernel ABI is not the dominant part of the problem.

The stagefright debacle didn't have anything to do with the kernel or Linux ABIs. libstagefight is Android's own userspace library.

Quadrooter was kind of related to ABIs in that it was inside Qualcomm's driver, but it would still have been trivial for vendors to just pop in a patched driver from Qualcomm and release a software update. They do all have systems ready for making software updates, since phones ~always get OTAs early in their lifetimes. A stable kernel ABI (so all vendors could have samed the same binary of the fixed driver) would not have made this significantly easier.

The main problem is lack of product liability cases due to lack of high profile really bad things happening (malicious worm epidemic etc). If consumers demanded (and won) their money back from phone vendors due to security incidents, diligence wrt updates would get written into contracts between operators, phone vendors, SoC providers etc and it would work.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrb on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:00PM (#14037167)
"They're supported longer"

In general yes, but not always. Security updates may stop as soon as 2 years after purchase: the iPhone 4S was discontinued on September 9, 2014, and the last iOS for it is 9.3.5 released on August 25, 2016.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by peterwwillis on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:13PM (#14037263)
The Galaxy Nexus was released at the same time as the 4S, and its last supported OS was Jelly Bean (4.3). The last update for this OS, 4.3.1, was released in October 2013. It was not supported after this.

So the iPhone 4S, which you use as an example of a lack of support, was supported for three years longer than the comparable Android.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by mrb on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:45PM (#14037511)
Yes the Galaxy Nexus was terrible in that respect. But it doesn't change my main point which is that: Apple security updates may stop as soon as 2 years after purchase. And the last example of this was 8 months ago when 4S support ended.

By contrast the Galaxy Nexus support ended 3.5 years ago and is no longer representative of Google support's policy which is now longer.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by shrewduser on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:56PM (#14037605)
the galaxy nexus was a special case where shortly after it was released TI pulled out of the SoC making business all together. no other nexus suffered the same fate as that phone.

so your statement that iphone gets more support than the equivalent nexus is spurious at best.

Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by j_s on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:36PM (#14037897)
I assume Dell, HP, Lenovo, Samsung, Toshiba, Acer, Asus, etc all have plenty of vulnerabilities in their homegrown drivers, many of which remain unpatched. Fortunately these are small enough market segments that they don't get much attention from the bad guys.
Re:Over the Air: Exploiting Broadcom’s Wi-Fi Stack by biafra on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @07:26AM (#14041259)
Better because I have to ask for Apples permission to install applications on it?