News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Momentum Works by poppingtonic on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @01:28PM (#14035174)
I'm really loving the choice of articles, especially since you're just getting started.

Edit: I'm referring to the journal, not the author.

Re:Why Momentum Works by colah3 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @01:52PM (#14035419)
Thanks! We're just lucky to have authors like Gabe (@gabrielgoh) come to us with incredible articles. :)
Re:Why Momentum Works by stared on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @05:28PM (#14037381)
How to know if an article would fit there? For example, I was thinking about adjusting my http://p.migdal.pl/2017/01/06/king-man-woman-queen-why.html (already with some interactive components) or writing about RoI polling (https://deepsense.io/region-of-interest-pooling-explained/ - by my colleague, but more interactive).

Would it be on-topic? (After changing style accordingly.)

Re:Why Momentum Works by colah3 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:34PM (#14037889)
Please check out our journal policies page: http://distill.pub/journal/

In brief, Distill needs to see three things to publish an article: outstanding communication, advancing the dialogue, and scientific integrity. Distill often works with authors to help them bring their articles up to our standards.

Additionally, as a primary publication, Distill will not republish content already published elsewhere, or publish "translations" of papers where someone rewrites the content of a previous paper. (This relates to advancing the dialogue.)

If you reach out to [email protected], we're happy to discuss pre-submission inquiries about journal scope and related topics.

Re:Why Momentum Works by stared on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @06:49PM (#14037986)
Thank you! Of course I read it, just (as it is a new thing) still guessing what is a good fit, and what isn't.

(For some reason I though that this t-SNE article was published elsewhere. Now I see that it was on Distill, but just before its big start.)

Re:Why Momentum Works by colah3 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:09PM (#14038144)
Yep, we're still clarifying our policies. If you have questions, please email us!

(Distill needs to be extra careful about a lot of this stuff because we're trying to build legitimacy for a kind of work that many people are inclined to not treat as academic contributions. So on some things, like being a primary publication, we may end up taking a more defensive posture than we would in an ideal world.)

Re:Why Momentum Works by stared on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @07:48PM (#14038368)
I wish all the best to this wonderful initiative! (As a side note, my co-advisor dreamt about this style of communication in science (though, in physics): https://physicsnapkins.wordpress.com/2012/04/16/a-personal-d...)

I totally understand that you need to be set high reference level at the very beginning, even if at the cost of being a bit "conservative" (I am not sure if the best word here).

Re:Why Momentum Works by brut on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @02:08PM (#14035598)
I'm curious, did the author write the whole article including figures, or did someone else give life to the figures?

I can see this type of interactive journal becoming very popular in other fields, but not if the author has to create the diagrams him/herself.

Re:Why Momentum Works by gabrielgoh on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @03:58PM (#14036594)
Author here - I've created all the diagrams, though I've received really helpful editorial input from Shan Carter and Chris Olah. If you feel like doing some archeology, you can see for yourself the really ugly drafts in the github history - it isn't pretty!

I think these visualizations are deceptively easy to create. Javascript is a powerful language with many libraries, and in my experience, it just took a few nudges at exactly the right spots from Shan to go from an idea in my head to fully fledged diagram in distill. The tricky part has always been figuring out what to visualize, and if you're a researcher with an clever idea for a visualization, I recommend you reach out to the distill team.

Re:Why Momentum Works by plafl on Wednesday April 05, 2017 @05:40AM (#14040888)
Thank you very much for the article, I'm really enjoying it. I have a few comments:

- When hovering over some notes I see the citations perfectly, but when there is math involved like for example the one about spectral decay the math is not rendered (I'm using Ubuntu, I have tested both in Firefox and Chrome).

- I see you can open issues on github to send corrections. I wonder if there are other channels of communication also to, for example, address problems like the previous one and also to discuss the article.

- I see people like a lot the figures. I think too they are great but what I really love is the writing and the math exposition.

- I think that a default animation for the figures, if they are meant to be manipulated, would be great.

I will say it again: great article. I have bookmarked the journal and I will proceed to read everything published which looks very promising too.

Re:Why Momentum Works by colah3 on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:09PM (#14036688)
As Gabe said, we mostly expect authors to produce diagrams and us to help edit them into outstanding articles. This is one example of the editing:

https://github.com/distillpub/post--momentum/issues/1

We've also had a few designers volunteer to work with researchers on visualization. So, in special cases, we may match-make researchers with designers to produce a great article.

Re:Why Momentum Works by jkimmel on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @02:41PM (#14035932)
Likewise, I'm very impressed with the early article selection. The site itself is beautiful, and interactive figures like the one at the top of this link are incredibly helpful.

Overall -- huge fan!