News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by Frqy3 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @05:13AM (#14016517)
From an economic viewpoint, this also means that the brand value of the articles remains with the masthead rather than the individual authors. This commodifies the authors and makes then more fungible.

Being The Economist, I am sure they are aware of this.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by Nokinside on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:01AM (#14016840)
The Economist has so good quality that I don't think they consider their writers fungible.

The Economist has so good reputation that just being one of the 75 staff journalists creates lasting value for the journalist. Other journals find it important to mention that X.X was previously writing for The Economist.

The Economist is just one of the handful magazines worth of subscribing.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by Chathamization on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:58AM (#14017594)
I've never found the quality of articles in The Economist to be particularly good. They're often very broad summaries of a situation lacking any particular depth, combined with a fairly banal analysis that seems to restate the current consensus opinion. The analysis can be pretty wrong, particularly for stories that are less talked about in the West (one where it's harder to simply summarize the current consensus opinion).

The do seem to have a fairly wide breadth. But given a particular topic, I'm likely to learn much more from an in depth article from most mainstream sources than from an article in the economist.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by FabHK on Sunday April 02, 2017 @01:04PM (#14017864)
It's funny, I sort of agree with your description, but entirely disagree with your judgement. What you describe is in my view enormously valuable.

For a given article, I often think: Well, that's a pretty accurate description of the situation, the main points of contention, and some opinionated conclusion (maybe with a divergent viewpoint thrown in, but not always).

Sure, it's often some young kids from Oxford's PPE (Philosophy, Politics, Economics) programme writing the articles, but they've learned a bit at school and they have access to the best experts. That's what makes it so valuable in my view. I would not call it "banal", but then, I don't necessarily want great originality in my newspaper either.

And, mind you, the articles are typically just one page. That's a pretty good achievement for one page: get the best expert's condensed opinion on a topic.

As an equivalent, think about any info sec topic, and imagine someone sitting down with tpacek for an hour and then writing a one-page article about it. Even if they have not much clue about the topic, the article might be pretty informative, particularly for one page. Yeah, you can go and read hacker news for months or read Schneier's blog and books and the info sec stuff in depths - but most readers of The Economist don't have the time for that.

Providing a concise, informed overview (and view) on a broad array of important topics is what The Economist is good at.

Lastly, while I rant, they do have longer articles ("Briefings") and thematic clusters of articles ("Specials"), which give deeper insight.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by remarkEon on Sunday April 02, 2017 @01:00PM (#14017846)
When I want to wet my finger and stick it up and see which way the wind is blowing, I'll read The Economist for that week. If you go into it with that mindset it's less easy to hate on it, but harder to see why it's held up as a pantheon of Journalism.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by goldenkey on Monday April 03, 2017 @04:50PM (#14027016)
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by AJ007 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:17PM (#14017654)
I agree that they summarize the current consensus opinion. Cancelled my subscription years ago and rarely read a few articles once and a while. I prefer reading articles where the author's conflicts of interest are clearly disclosed.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by FabHK on Sunday April 02, 2017 @01:06PM (#14017875)
Not sure what you mean - The Economist is often opinionated, but they lay out their arguments and don't hide their agenda. I find it much more palatable than the "he said, she said" or "opinions diverge on the shape of the earth" type journalism.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by taneq on Monday April 03, 2017 @06:44AM (#14021827)
I highly doubt they consider their writers interchangeable with writers from the rest of the marketplace. However, if the writers themselves are anonymous, all social capital (reputation, respect, etc.) generated by the article goes to The Economist. This maximizes The Economist's brand while also removing any chance of a writer building up their own brand on the site and then taking some of the reader base with them.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by gwern on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:23AM (#14017476)
On the other hand, there is no such thing as a free lunch (if there was in this case and this policy was so great for the Economist, why don't all publications whatsoever insist on anonymity?), and all journalists who might work for the Economist are well-aware of this editorial policy; so they have to pay the price either in offering higher salaries to compensate for the lack of brand-building, or accept fewer/worse hires.

It's a curious policy and highly unusual, so I have to wonder if it's a good idea at all. The usual arguments for anonymity online seem to only questionably apply here. There's a lot to be said for people writing under their own names - accountability, for one thing.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by nabla9 on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:42PM (#14017761)
Very few other papers are in the same position as the Economist. They have brand that has exceptionally good reputation.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by heisenbit on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:53PM (#14017810)
"There’s only two ways I know of to make money: bundling and unbundling." https://hbr.org/2014/06/how-to-succeed-in-business-by-bundli...

We have seen the great unbundling of content. TV stations, cable channels, publishing houses, newspapers were giving way to blogs, you-tube etc..

Recently I start wondering whether the pendulum is swinging back. Netflix, Medium and in particular the recent discussion of distribution networks for ads which provide funding for the long tail.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by clamprecht on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:12PM (#14017644)
By the same token, the authors were also aware of this before taking their job with the Economist.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by devoply on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:36AM (#14016684)
Not just that, should the author not have the choice as if they wish to remain anonymous, choose a pseudo name, etc. The choice is simply not there.

> The main reason for anonymity, however, is a belief that what is written is more important than who writes it.

Important for whom? The writers? The readers? The advertisers? The company?

The readers could care less. The company probably and maybe the advertisers. It's more or less saying that we speak as one voice rather than many diverse voices. So I guess it also implies very strong editorial control. Which means it's the voice of the owners and its advertisers than voice of a diverse set of writers.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by bardworx on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:06AM (#14016749)
From my understanding, economist is owned by their employees, and a holding company[0]. The holding company has no voting shares and the employees have total editorial freedom.

So it's voice is actually of the writers first and foremost. It's really kinda cool considering that they're one of the most successful print meadow companies in an age when most are struggling.[1]

[0]http://www.economistgroup.com/results_and_governance/ownersh...

[1]http://www.economistgroup.com/results_and_governance/results...

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by manquer on Sunday April 02, 2017 @07:32AM (#14016786)
It is not clear anywhere how much is actually owned by staff. A share owners include families like Rothschild.. B includes Exor which recently bought from Pearson . Both groups control 7&6 board seats respectively..
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by Nadya on Sunday April 02, 2017 @02:48PM (#14018387)
>Important for whom? The writers? The readers? The advertisers? The company?

>The readers could care less.

On the contrary - many people with entirely valid points have been told to go pound sand because of their "distasteful views" in completely unrelated topics. The readers very much do take note if the writer is Stephen Hawking or Alex Jones. They don't care as much if it is Stephen Hawking writing on personal hair product or Alex Jones doing a history article on chewing gum. "Hawking is probably right and Jones is probably wrong." without even reading what they have to say, based on nothing but who they are.

Anonymity detaches preconceived notions from the article. Instead of instantly dismissing any points - no matter how valid - because of who said them the points can stand or fall on their own merit. Bad arguments are bad arguments - no matter who says them. Likewise for good arguments. But people's personal biases will accept bad arguments from people who often say things they agree with and dismiss good arguments from people who say things they often disagree with.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by clamprecht on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:14PM (#14017649)
The choice is in taking the job as a writer for the Economist.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by elastic_church on Sunday April 02, 2017 @11:39AM (#14017526)
It avoids ad hominem attacks over decent independent research.

Maybe you don't want to read Peter Theil's view of how the tech sector will change in America even if it was a spot on analysis

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by ue_ on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:07AM (#14016629)
In a weak sense, the authors are commodified no matter what, just as any other worker is. As a proletarian, he must sell his labour-time (by the hour, week, month, year...) on the market to the bourgeoisie, his labour-time being the only thing he can sell, in order to make enough to survive.

The rest of the time when they are not at work, the authors 'recharge' in order to ready for more work and to keep motivation for working. In this way, the worker's entire life during the course of employment 'belongs' to the employer; in fact arguably the time when the worker is most valuable to the employer is when he is maintainig himself, just as the employer must maintain a machine from wear and tear, the worker is able to maintain himself from wear and tear and the employer doesn't have to pay a dime more for it.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by vostok on Sunday April 02, 2017 @06:10AM (#14016633)
I don't think that's true for authors who are not anonymous.

I used to read Matt Levine when he wrote for Dealbreaker. I now read him on Bloomberg and rarely visit Dealbreaker.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by eru on Friday April 14, 2017 @03:36PM (#14116637)
It is somewhat ironic to analyse The Economist's labour relations in Marxists terms.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by HappyTypist on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:12AM (#14016861)
Of course, the worker can choose to put a portion of their income into assets that generate income, and build wealth.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by ue_ on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:37AM (#14016926)
It's good if some workers are fortunate enough to be able to do this while working for wages, though many do not have such an option either by the need to support a family, paying off debt or the wage is not great enough to be able to invest any of it.

One's wealth has little relevance to the theory of worker exploitation, alienation and commodity fetishism. You can be a rich worker but still be exploited in the Marxian sense. You can be poor but still be an exploiter. One's wealth has little to do with the relationship to the means of production, unless that wealth comes in the form of private property upon which wage labour can be employed.

The fact is that "pulling up by the boostraps" is not an option for many people, and if it were it does little to stop systemic poverty, destitution and the need to sell labour-time very cheaply.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by HappyTypist on Sunday April 02, 2017 @08:56AM (#14016976)
What do you propose to fix this system?
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by nagvx on Sunday April 02, 2017 @09:46AM (#14017145)
This is a comment that seems to pop up quite a lot in discussions of the capitalist status-quo. (Often in a more confrontational manner, unfortunately.) I want to point out that having a solution is not a prerequisite to talking about the problem - if that is what you were implying - that is getting things backwards.
Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by baddox on Sunday April 02, 2017 @12:06PM (#14017624)
That's certainly true, although it would be helpful to offer some suggestions or somehow try to convince the audience that there might be political alternatives.

If a reader believes that the current system is the best system possible, than these politically-charged complaints sound as futile as politically-charged complaints about being unable to exceed the speed of light.

Re:Why are The Economist’s writers anonymous? by ue_ on Sunday April 02, 2017 @10:50AM (#14017357)
Abolishing wage labour, which I believe can only be done via putting the means of production and land capital (i.e in totality private property) in control of and ownership of the workers (i.e all the workers) collectively. The creation of direct democracy councils (with delegates subject to instant recall) each with completely voluntary participation. No council rules over any other council. The workers use the collectively owned machinery and resources, and take home the product. Those who do not work get nothing, unless having prior entered into agreement with a council for charity. Workers may form groups in which each person's products are 'pooled'; the distribution of these is decided democratically, for example workers may agree to give 10% of their product, or the whole surplus product to the elderly or infirm. Though this is just an example.

Managerial positions are of course kept (as managers are wage labourers too), the only difference is that there isn't someone at the top to collect surplus labour.

This is otherwise known as anarcho-Communism, or some variant of social anarchism. I am reading into communalism too (Bookchin) and the question of how those in service jobs can own their labour is an interesting one, I'm not aware of the current research on that.