News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:49PM (#13999189)
I got big into VR partly because of him, enamored by an interview of him my girl friend pointed me to in 2013. He was young, enthusiastic, idealistic, relatable to me.

Well, as the years wear on he, and oculus itself, has established more of itself from the hacker/open source vision. They’ve made enemies along the way, and many of the reasons people hate him/Oculus I disagree with.

It’s an infant field, they need to fund games to even having reasonable games. Making games have become increasingly expensive. Sure there’s a place for indie devs, but those games don’t draw the mainstreamers VR needs to take off like I, and many others need.

That being said, the things I’ve heard and seen from him make me think he does emobdy the gamergate “tech bro” (and I do use that as a pejorative) make my stomach churn. That I can’t really forgive, and don’t want to support.

The privacy aspects of a Facebook (or google for that matter) owning VR, and getting access to what we physically look at for advertising, is such a gold mine. Totally terrifying. That’s one reason my next system will likely be something like the Vive, inspite of me finding Oculus far more polished and fun to have.

EDIT: Interestingly enough I asked him specifically on an AMA if he planned on staying at Oculus, his answer was an emphatic yes: https://www.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/40ea0x/i_am_p...

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by engx on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:25PM (#13999441)
I don't think a rich 24 year old kid, doing something that was widely considered an attack against the Establishment, is something that is highly unusual or bad.

It doesn't seem fair to forever conflate Palmer with Trump or assume that he completely agrees with him. Maybe his tactics and philosophy are flawed, but I don't think his intentions are. Everyone's so quick to judge, demonize and forever cast people as bad.

He admitted to funding trolling memes to support the current President of the United States? He has to go away forever now, and we all have to pretend not to like him?

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by nxc18 on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:33PM (#13999489)
I definitely agree people deserve second chances and make mistakes. Especially people who are young and have more money than they are accustomed to having.

At the same time, it is really, really hard to look upon this charitably when he was screwing with something with such high stakes. I get that 24-year-old kids don't take much seriously, but for goodness sake don't use your money for political purposes without thinking it through.

Heck, having millions of dollars makes me dislike him kind of like how people don't like Hillary for being successful and having millions. At least Hillary took her position seriously and attempted to look like she was trying to do the right thing, vs Palmer's 'shitpost 4 days, memes r life' bullshit.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by pnathan on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:13PM (#14000157)
> I get that 24-year-old kids don't take much seriously, but for goodness sake don't use your money for political purposes without thinking it through.

Hmmm. Let's look at a slightly different statistic:

> In the U.S. army, something like 75%-80% of newly-commissioned Second Lieutenants are promoted to First Lieutenant (around age 25)

-- http://history.stackexchange.com/questions/7812/why-have-off...

What does a 2nd Lt do?

> Typically the entry-level rank for most Commissioned Officers. Leads platoon-size elements consisting of the platoon SGT and two or more squads (16 to 44 Soldiers).

And shortly will be promoted to 1st Lt...

> A seasoned lieutenant with 18 to 24 months service. Leads more specialized weapons platoons and indirect fire computation centers. As a senior Lieutenant, they are often selected to be the Executive Officer of a company-sized unit (110 to 140 personnel).

Oh. Leads 16-44 soldiers into combat, and shortly will be commanding 110-140 soldiers...

I would like to submit that letting a 24-year old off on account of immaturity is wrong and ignores their clear agency and capability.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by peteretep on Friday March 31, 2017 @01:31AM (#14001354)
The choices a 2LT needs to make -- while having life and death consequences -- are also pretty limited and they've generally spent 3 years at West Point (or 1 year at Sandhurst, etc) being extensively taught how to make those decisions.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by pnathan on Friday March 31, 2017 @11:41AM (#14004913)
Oh yes, quite so.

But the cold truth is that a 2LT is an adult, given adult choices, and adult consequences.

Mr. Luckey is identical in this regard, and if, by the time you're 23, you're not capable of sober decisions- then that is what courts call incompetent to stand trial.

Many examples from contemporary and historical sources could be cited to support my argument: I selected the most sobering difference.

As I remarked above to the grandparent poster, Mr. Luckey should not be exculpated based on age alone - if at all. He was working towards setting up a propaganda group to serve extremist interests.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by T-A on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:46PM (#14000623)
I believe becoming a commissioned US Army officer involves passing a selection process.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by smacktoward on Thursday March 30, 2017 @09:58PM (#14000669)
You would think having $2 billion dropped on one's head by Facebook would too.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by srtjstjsj on Friday March 31, 2017 @12:13AM (#14001121)
It's a selection process for technology, patents, and marketing, not for the person.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by michaelbuddy on Friday March 31, 2017 @08:57AM (#14003193)
Palmer did nothing wrong. Nothing at all. He's totally free, in the United States, to hate on whatever candidate he wants and fund political cartoons against them.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by brandonmenc on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:50PM (#13999618)
> it is really, really hard to look upon this charitably when he was screwing with something with such high stakes

Putting up a childish billboard of questionable strategic value promoting a candidate for president is "screwing with something with such high stakes?" Hyperbole?

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by michaelbuddy on Friday March 31, 2017 @08:59AM (#14003216)
2016 revealed just how thin skinned, conspiratorial and fatalistic the tech community is. Hence the drop in participation around here.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:56PM (#14000032)
I find the implied "boys will be boys" and "people make mistakes" quite unsavory.

Should he be cast out form society? No, but I sure won't support him until I see evidence he disagrees with the most disturbing things associated with Trump: sexism, racism, etc.

We need to hold people accountable instead of making execuses for them.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by mst on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:13PM (#14000160)
Do you also believe anybody who was in favour of the Clinton campaign needs to provide evidence they disagree with silencing sexual assault victims? Because that's definitely a disturbing thing "associated" with her.

Otherwise I feel like you're more interested in partisan political posturing than actually holding people accountable.

(for the record, I despise both Clinton and Trump, but had I been a US voter rather than a UK bystander, I'd've held my nose and voted Clinton on the expectation of that being the lesser of the available evils)

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:30PM (#14000265)
I think directly speaking about sexual assault coupled with many accusations is more damning, and supporters just not caring.

Same with racism against people form Mexico / middle east. Sadly comes down to a matter of scale, at least for me.

This sort of stuff should ruin someone running for president, somehow it didn't matter here.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by peteretep on Friday March 31, 2017 @01:32AM (#14001357)
Hillary wasn't campaigning on a platform of silencing sexual assault victims, but Trump was campaigning on a platform of xenophobia and dog whistles.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by michaelbuddy on Friday March 31, 2017 @09:03AM (#14003249)
All these "phobia" labels get applied to people who just want others to obey the laws. Even intelligent tech minded people just don't seem to understand this.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Friday March 31, 2017 @10:40AM (#14004230)
You do you realize sometimes these people getting elected actually write or enforce the laws? Perhaps even change them, by lets say reducing the number of refugees being taken in.

But to get to the heart of your point "enforcing laws" Legality is in no way equivalent Morality. People use terms like "enforcing laws" as a sort of dog whistle to imply we should not and are not going to be listening to minority voices.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by glenndebacker on Friday March 31, 2017 @03:25AM (#14001795)
Boys that have friendly relationships with people like Milo Yiannopoulos gives me the impressions that they have other reasons than finding "stupid memes" fun.

I think that the kind of people that surrounds you also tells something more of the person in question. And it's not only the figure of Yiannopoulos that is questionable in this particularly case....

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by akhilcacharya on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:50PM (#14000384)
I don't care if Larry Ellison donates to Trump.

I care if he solicits money from a group of virulent internet racists though.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by srtjstjsj on Friday March 31, 2017 @12:14AM (#14001125)
Why? Wouldn't you rather Ellison spend virulent internet racists' money, then spend Java licensee's money?
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by johansch on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:41PM (#13999545)
> It doesn't seem fair to forever conflate Palmer with Trump

It happened about six months ago. That's a lot shorter than "forever". Even in Silicon Valley time...

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by cr0sh on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:01PM (#13999286)
VR is anything but an "infant" field. Maybe today's incarnation, maybe amongst consumers.

But the idea of "gloves and goggles" goes back a long way - with its first real implementation happening by Ivan Sutherland ("Sword of Damocles" and the lesser known "Twinkle Box" for tracking in the late 1960s), then later work done in the 1980s and 90s by NASA, VPL Research, and Jarod Lanier, among others (which started the first VR wave).

If you have an interest in VR now, and you haven't already, you owe it to yourself to check out the history of this fascinating, if still nascent and buggy, field.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by mrbill on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:49PM (#13999988)
My high school senior English class research paper was on VR ... in 1993. Lanier featured heavily as he was one of the "public faces" of the technology back then, with all of the high-dollar stuff coming out of JPL.

I remember buying a Nintendo Powerglove in college and hooking it up to the parallel printer port on a '486 just so we could use it to move around a couch in a virtual room on the screen (in REND386 if I'm remembering things correctly; it's been 21 years).

Anybody else remember the Amiga-based "Dactyl Nightmare" game where you stood in a pod with a goggles helmet on?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6t69mp0ZhE

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by yrro on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:19PM (#13999796)
Horizon: Colonizing Cyberspace is an informative (and nostalgic!) overview of the field in the early 90s.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VuZonQVN4uw

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by kirrent on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:09PM (#13999337)
I got a Rift over a Vive partially because I knew him, or at least knew of him, on the benheck forums back when we were all kids trying to make our own portable consoles. I was always impressed by his work ethic and designs. Enthusiastic, idealistic, and relatable were perfect ways to describe him back then as well.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by girvo on Friday March 31, 2017 @10:25AM (#14004084)
I miss those forums. My portable GameCube never got finished
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by mikewhy on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:00PM (#13999271)
> Interestingly enough I asked him specifically on an AMA if he planned on staying at Oculus, his answer was an emphatic yes

A year ago he said "I don't have plans to do anything else, so no real lamentations!", that seems like less than emphatic yes to me.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by pillowkusis on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:02PM (#13999288)
>He was young (still is) enthusiastic, idealistic, relatable to me.

I would not describe him as idealistic or relatable. He's a self-identified Trump supporter/donator[0] and definitely has some alt-right leanings. Regardless of your politics, I think it's fair to say that someone with his political leanings is not considered "relatable" by a decent portion of Americans.

[0]: http://www.theverge.com/2016/9/23/13025422/palmer-luckey-ocu...

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by drawnwren on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:10PM (#13999349)
It's very odd in 2017 that so many people are being socially disqualified because their political ideology doesn't align with San Francisco's.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by pcwalton on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:09PM (#14000135)
Fortunately, that's not what's happening.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by EpicEng on Friday March 31, 2017 @02:04PM (#14006345)
Eh, with Trump I have to disagree. He has shown time and time again that he is a petty, egotistical sicophant with little regard for humanity in general. He's a documented liar and swindler. I have a hard time giving his supporters the benefit of the doubt and I am certain ly no San Francisco liberal.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by Veratyr on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:12PM (#13999362)
OP specifically said "relatable to me" so the feelings of others aren't particularly relevant and even if they were, enough Americans had a pro-Trump stance that Trump was elected president. I'm assuming your reason for not describing him as "idealistic" is his pro-Trump stance, in which case I'd say he has ideals and is therefore idealistic, his ideals simply don't match yours.

I'm no Trump fan but I think your points are biased and irrelevant.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by ploxiln on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:14PM (#13999373)
Try not to forget that Trump got 46% of the popular vote, to Hillary's 48%. And don't fool yourself, those numbers are comparable.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by cookiecaper on Tuesday April 11, 2017 @10:43AM (#14088247)
Considering that Trump won, it seems supporting Trump is plenty relatable to many Americans (approximately half). It's 50/50 either way.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:04PM (#13999302)
I completely agree. My meaning was he seemed like that to me in 2013, and many others for that matter.

Also he is still young.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by psyc on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:32PM (#13999478)
Oh, a Trump supporter, you say. Well, I'm glad you told us, because now I know the right opinion to have about him.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by dsaw on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:55PM (#13999230)
Can you elaborate on why/how did you find Oculus more polished?

Note : I have a Vive, which I bought after researching both (so I might be biased)

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by dkonofalski on Thursday March 30, 2017 @07:35PM (#13999901)
I'm not the OP, but I have both the Oculus and the Vive and, to me, the Vive is a much better experience. For me, the big issue is that, while the Rift is a bit easier to set up (but not by much), the tracking is just not good enough to get that immersive experience. As soon as you lose tracking once, it throws the whole thing out the window. The Vive's tracking is pretty flawless. The Rift, on the other hand, is finicky and, if you even attempt the room scale setup with touch, you'll feel like someone trying to mess with an analog TV antenna.

With the Rift, I'm initially impressed with it (resolution is better, headset is lighter, etc) but then constantly reminded that this is new tech. With the Vive, it's clunkier and more pixelated (not by much) but I forget completely about all of it when I'm deeply immersed in a game.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by sleepybrett on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:26PM (#14000237)
Tracking might be "resolved" but man three usb3 cameras + the usb3 for the headset, is a hard sell on a lot of systems. Most people who are successfully running 3+ camera roomscale deployments have at least one if not two extra usb3 cards in their machine.

They just made a big mistake going with camera tracking, the lighthouse solution just seems much more scalable.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by meheleventyone on Friday March 31, 2017 @02:35AM (#14001605)
I actually think the opposite. Camera based tracking is the future and the Lighthouse stuff whilst good right now is going to something of a dead end. In the future we're going to be using inside-out tracked headsets which will be highly reliant on camera tech. Even more so for a workable general use AR glasses solution. So perhaps more fiddly to setup now hurting consumer adoption but better in the long term?
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by ehsanu1 on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:15PM (#14000171)
You've got room scale setup with 3 cameras? Note that there were huge problems with the software a couple of releases ago that were recently resolved. Tracking is really smooth and solid right now for me personally on Oculus.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by marricks on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:59PM (#13999255)
I am certainly biased, despite having huge issues with Oculus. My experience is Vive demos and second hand.

Setup was just placing cameras on a desk. I don't need external headphones. Store is curated, which is good and bad. I like trusting games won't give me nausea, or turn off people to VR. In my experience all it takes is one experience for some people to continue repeating "VR causes nausea" for literally 1+ year. My boss is this person, and it's hard to get him to try rift again.

Touch, and seeing my fingers closely mirrored in VR, I find extremely polished and wonderful. Grabbing the first object in VR made me laugh in excitement, first time I did that since seeing Tuscany in CV1.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by baby on Thursday March 30, 2017 @05:58PM (#13999247)
Yup, for having tried both, the Vive is far superior to the Oculus.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by meheleventyone on Friday March 31, 2017 @02:53AM (#14001687)
Not the OP either but I use both extensively at work and haven't paid my own money so subject to less bias in that sense. I've also had a fair run at everything from Cardboard to the Hololens over the last couple of years.

Once setup I find the tracking similar. The main advantage of the Vive is the ability to track a larger space. Outside of arcades this is a bit of a non-issue currently as most users don't have that much space. A lot of users also don't tend to walk around that much or at least more tentatively due to the tether.

The Touch controllers are much better ergonomically and offer more input options. But they are also less non-gamer friendly. The Vive wand suffers from being enormous with badly placed buttons.

Headset wise the Rift is a clear winner right now. It's lighter, has a much better harness and the integrated headphones remove a lot of the faff factor putting it on. Vive is releasing kits that address some of this later in the year.

Store wise Oculus does a better job of surfacing products that will meet consumer expectations. Mostly because there are less hobby projects clogging it up and the exclusive content so far has been good. Then you can still head over to Steam, itch and others to explore more questionable variety.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by conception on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:25PM (#13999444)
From most reviews the Oculus is very plug and play whereas the Vive takes a couple of hours to get all setup and calibrated correctly.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by andybak on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:44PM (#14000335)
> Vive takes a couple of hours to get all setup and calibrated correctly.

More like 20 minutes.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by dahdum on Thursday March 30, 2017 @06:57PM (#13999659)
Oculus doesn't have room scale, and just got touch recently. It's easier to setup something with half the functionality.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by TwoBit on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:47PM (#14000358)
Oculus certainly has some room scale. I use it fine in my 12x12 room. It's otherwise better than the Vive in a lot of ways. Asw, atw, screen door, audio, comfort, clarity across the fov, controllers, apps. The bigger room scale is about the only thing the Vive does better.
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by dahdum on Thursday March 30, 2017 @10:32PM (#14000807)
Oculus needs 3 tracking devices for room scale, and is still smaller and buggier. Games are required to be designed for 180 degrees instead of 360 like the vive. Vive is also getting wireless headset support this quarter (TPcast).

Oculus poured far too much money into paying off developers for exclusive titles than trying to compete on technology, and as far as I can tell are falling further behind.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by TwoBit on Thursday March 30, 2017 @10:58PM (#14000873)
I've read that the wireless options are coming tonRift as well. Why wouldn't they? Oculus just doesn't talk as much publicly. 360 tracking works for me with three sensors. The Rift is less expensive than Vive now too.

It seems like you are cherry picking your facts, which indicates you have technology religion. So no point discussing with you.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by dahdum on Friday March 31, 2017 @12:52AM (#14001241)
I have both....you cherry picked yours too. There is a large difference in experience, and I'm just endlessly annoyed Rift hasn't delivered on their promises, and buy exclusives vs develop tech. I'd say I'm a fair weather fan of either tbh.

I'm sure I came across as more argumentative than I meant to be.

Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by TwoBit on Thursday March 30, 2017 @08:42PM (#14000328)
Why choose a headset (or any product) due to one person who clearly doesn't represent the company and who the company distanced themselves from and have apparently now fired?
Re:Palmer Luckey Leaves Facebook by smt88 on Friday March 31, 2017 @01:35AM (#14001367)
So that the person in question doesn't get any of your money