Sounds to me like you believe that science proceeds without politics.
> Young scientists are hungry and there not enough positions for them. Every department has that old rockstar or two who doesn't really push the boundaries of science anymore, but takes up available positions. When they retire or die, new people come in who are still young and full of energy.
This process you've described here resembles the political process we observe in government (or any human social system that involves a competitive hierarchy), with the exception that in government the problem of 'taking up available positions' is attenuated by the existence of term limits for most leadership positions.
The question is whether politics and science
are equivalently grounded...
Maybe that's how you most frequently encounter this topic, but it's a gross overstatement to say that's the only question here. Was Planck was motivated by anti-science sentiment when he said that? I suspect not.No one seriously debates whether politics is a factor in science. AFAICT, the the question is entirely to what degree politics influences the progress of science. In my experience, even people with relatively radical views understand this.
My first claim in great grandparent was that the argument that science on progresses when scientists die is used to argue that politics and science are equivalent, that science is reducible to politics. Since we agree that is not so reducible to politics, let us agree that we agree and move on.
None of the major exponents or scholars of this concept of whom I'm aware -- Bohr, Kuhn, Oreskes, and others -- have as their primary motivation any desire to demote or debunk science. If you're going to make that claim, you'll have to substantiate it. You've failed to do so. Twice.
So my argument was underspecified, which led you to believe I was referring to the like of Bohr, Kuhn, Oreskes and other serious thinkers, which I was not.
I'll offer as an excellent case study in development and establishment of new scientific theory, the emergence of plate tectonics (or continental drift theory). Naomi Oreskes, a tireless advocate of real science, and debunker of pseudoscience and disinformation (see Merchants of Doubt) documents the four-century-long battle to establish the concept in her books PLATE TECTONICS: The Insiders’ History of the Modern Theory of the Earth and The Rejection of Continental Drift, along with several further articles on the topic.
https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/naomi-oreskes/pla...
http://www.worldcat.org/title/rejection-of-continental-drift...
Which is basically the norm for a lot of industries. I'm not even sure I mind this sort of thing so long as they are still contributing and producing. I just wish there were enough space for the young folks to do their stuff too.
I will say this though. Young scientists are hungry and there not enough positions for them. Every department has that old rockstar or two who doesn't really push the boundaries of science anymore, but takes up available positions. When they retire or die, new people come in who are still young and full of energy.