I don't agree with this. Obviously, if a bystander's property was damaged, this would be true, however, the idea of being paid for a "disruption" is silly. It's called life and it's full of annoyances. I'd argue the people angling for compensation because they're annoyed probably fall into the jerk and freeloader category more than someone who is willing to forgo reimbursement for his damaged property in order to warn the public about a potential pitfall.
http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/quiet+enjoymen...
Look, I get what you're saying and where you're coming from, and in theory, it sounds reasonable, but in practice (real life) it just doesn't happen that way.
If by doing so causes noise, and the circumstances are unreasonable (e.g. woodworking through the night), a claim could certainly be made under nuisance. An injunction to cease the unreasonable behaviour (e.g. only allowing noise to be made during certain hours) would be the primary remedy, but monetary damages for, e.g., loss of sleep are also possible.
It is up to the person that wants to Airbnb her/his place to make sure the people who are taking residence in her/his property are decent. It is not Airbnb who attracts the jerks and freeloaders.
With that said, their handling of this scenario (assuming everything that has been said in the article linked is true) was not good.
Could be related to the fact that those are not covered by the AirBnB guarantee:
What’s not protected?
The Host Guarantee should not be considered a replacement
or stand-in for homeowners or renters insurance. The Host
Guarantee does not protect:
cash and securities
pets
personal liability
shared or common areashttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuisance_in_English_law#Privat...
In addition, I find it interesting that the host is only sending a bill for $8000. It seems as if he is only trying to get paid for his damages and not even considering the damage and disruption to his neighbors (who unlike the host are wholly blameless in this manner). It seems AirBnb attracts the jerks and freeloaders.