Re:The Arrival of AI
by zepto on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:39PM
(#13988707)
Art has meaning which is why humans find it interesting. Are you therefore saying that machines can create meaning that is interesting to humans?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Arrival of AI
by notduncansmith on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:41PM
(#13988729)
It's absolutely possible for machines to point out things no human had thought about before.
Is that all meaning is to you? Especially the kind of meaning embodied by art?
Reductive definitions don't seem to contribute much to these kinds of discussion.
I've heard people speak about how they find meaning in nature. If a random process can manage, why not a computer?
You are calling people a random process?
Re:The Arrival of AI
by squeaky-clean on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:04PM
(#13989528)
Nature is the random process.
Natural selection isn't random. Fitness is selected for. Find meaning is probably a fitness ability for humans.
Re:The Arrival of AI
by squeaky-clean on Thursday March 30, 2017 @02:44PM
(#13997856)
This man found a lot of meaning in mountains, rivers, skies and trees [0] and passed it to others. At least the first 3 of those are not made by natural selection.
[0] http://s.newsweek.com/sites/www.newsweek.com/files/2014/09/2...
Re:The Arrival of AI
by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:21PM
(#13990198)
> Natural selection isn't random.
Yes, it is; specifically it's a biased filter over a lower-level set of random change processes (which has its own biases) produces a biased-but-random (non-deterministic) changes over time.
It totally is a random process. It's just not drawing from an uniform distribution. In fact, the process strongly influences the distribution it's drawing from.
Mountains aren't formed by natural selection.
Ok, but the commenter said that people are making the meaning.
That's a painfully stupid question. Machines have already created lots of meaning that's interesting to me, including stuff that couldn't be done without them and unexpected behavior due to some patterns we hadn't previously recognised. There are really too many examples to even get into it.
Your reply would be much better without the first sentence. There is no need to demean or engage in such speech.
The meaning only exists because humans attribute meaning to the input, output and code that creates the output.