But then I go and try anyway. I'm not even really sure why, but I like doing it.
I will probably never write code as well as John Carmack or compose music as well as John Williams, but that doesn't stop me from trying. And it is fulfilling.
Although some minority of people derive "meaning" from work per se (work = something that you get paid to do), I would say that the vast majority of people can derive meaning from other things. For the vast majority, work is for getting money.
Therefore, there are still lots of things that you can use to derive meaning, such as: raising a family, caring of others, playing music, study different subjects for fun (philosophy, etc.), be part of your local community, do sports, do competition sports (if that fits your style), etc. etc. etc. etc.
Bottom line: do not mix work with quest for meaning...
I think it may be possible that you could be conflating two subtly different things here. Where people currently derive meaning in their lives might not be quite the same as where people have the potential to derive meaning in their lives.
I know a number of people who are, for instance, psychologists, teachers, or social workers. They have chosen to derive meaning in their lives through work. Some of them have also gone on to raise families and care for others, turning sources of potential meaning into sources of active meaning. Thus people can incorporate both current and potential sources of meaning into their lives. Some people opt to dedicate their lives entirely to their current sources of meaning!
Yet, it's perhaps less than maximally wise to conflate someone seeking meaning through their work today with their future in which they might seek meaning through raising children. Meaning does not always operate with expected values.
Every example you gave is a form of work in the general sense of effortful goal-directed activity.
[1] This brings to mind the famous quote: "The map is not the territory"
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Map–territory_relation#.22Th...
There's a difference between working to survive and working because it's enjoyable.
For example, I can work on my mountain bike skills, or I can sit in an office and work on code. One I do because I enjoy it, and one I do to pay my bills.
Computers, automation, and AI will take over the second type, but they won't take over the first type.
I'd actually go so far as to say your definition of work, meaning, and purpose is insulting and harmful to a large number of people. Does anybody really derive meaning and purpose by cleaning toilets, bringing people food, or stocking shelves? Should they? I don't think so.
As long as humans are humans, we'll always want to do something. We'll set ourselves personally meaningful goals and strive to achieve them. That is still work. But that's totally different than organizing your life around involuntarily spending most of it doing things you don't care about so that you can put bread on the table, and so that you have that table in the first place.
Reductive definitions don't seem to contribute much to these kinds of discussion.
[0] http://s.newsweek.com/sites/www.newsweek.com/files/2014/09/2...
Yes, it is; specifically it's a biased filter over a lower-level set of random change processes (which has its own biases) produces a biased-but-random (non-deterministic) changes over time.
We don't have to wonder -- it has already happened: http://the-best-art.computer
> The computer queries the universe and uses an algorithm to objectively calculate the best art for any given moment in time. The human executes the commands.
How is this objectively at all? The artist creates an algo and picks some stuff to query. All the artist does is adding another (subjectively formed) layer to the process.
> The computer's creative process is computational, and therefore unbiased.
:-/
> How do you know it actually produces the "best" art? Good art pulls meaning from the chaos of the universe, and also reflects the artist's unique point of view. The computer rigorously combines these two factors in its programming, optimizing them to produce the best art.
I find this very arrogant to say...
> There's nothing in principle that stops a machine from creating art. Even, better art than any person could do.
I don't think this project would be an example.
The quality of art depends not only on the end result but also on the process. Robot art won't be better unless we like robot artist more than human artists.
There's nothing in principle that stops a machine from creating art. Even, better art than any person could do. So once that happens, where are we left?
Meaning isn't something physical in the universe. Meaning is an emotion. It's what you feel when you're working towards something that you believe has some greater importance. With all opportunity to work towards anything taken away, life will become meaningless by definition, unless humans are left with some pseudo-artificial challenges to push against.
Zookeepers put the animals' food inside a metal box with a small hole, so the animals have to do work to get it out. It's good for the animals to have something to work towards, and they're too dumb to realize they're being manipulated. Maybe that's our future. With WoW and Clash of Clans, etc, sometimes it feels like we're already halfway there.