You can all feel as hopeless and defeated as you like. When it comes down to it nothing in history came easy. With the Advent of the internet it forced the hands of those in power come up with new ways of making us think they are more powerful or have more power.
And unfortunately it works like a charm. A tech revolution would completely undermine the entire worlds markets over night. With the help of HN, it's members and a few months and some serious agenda pushing anything can get done. Problem is you all feel so defeated nobody wants to agree on the same agenda.
Like I said. It works. But we know how now. And with all the brain power on HN it's only a matter of time before they start targeting us. And they already have by passing this and putting that shit head in charge of the FCC.
What about working to elect representatives who will pass privacy legislation?
If they're not corrupt(-ed) before entering office, they most certainly will be through lobbying (aka "generous donations") once they enter office. Exceptions to this rule are certainly rare and seem to only surface ahead of elections and vanish -again- as soon as they are elected.
If even that proves impossible, well, then I guess it would have to come down to violent revolution.
German here. Absolutely believe there's virtually no difference in that regard. Lobbyists write law proposals that end up being the verbatim law.
I remember that in the late 90s through early 2000s, I would regularly see personal sites pop up on my searches through the web, but I'm finding less and less non-commercial content. Either all the search results want to sell me something, or they're optimized to make money off of my clicks.
That's because personal homepages have died off, to be replaced with better replacements - not because Disney and TimeWarner have paid Google to rank their results higher.
For example, Wikipedia (and Wikia) have replaced personal museum websites for all kinds of esoteric information - ditto fansites. For "Prof. Smith's computer science examples webpage" we have GitHub; Reddit has replaced "Links" pages and Webrings, and Google itself has rendered curated directory sites completely obsolete.
The only thing on Geocities and Angelfire/Tripod that Facebook has replaced are those insufferable "The Baker Family Homepage" websites.
Is it really a replacement if it's private and stuck in some walled garden? I don't care about the platform used, I care about the surfacing and availability of non-commercial content.
Try making a significant change or writing a new article without being mired in beaurocracy.
It's not an example of diverse user-generated content any more. For good reason -- it can't be, if it wants to be considered a useful source on anything.
https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/115-2017/h202
Plenty of dots in there to scape, connect, visualize, and disseminate for anyone looking for a fun way to let off some steam.
A big shout out to the reps on both sides of the aisle that had the guts to stand for what's right.
And anyone reading this should take a minute to check the list to see how their rep voted and take action. The easiest thing to do is call your rep and let them know how you feel about their vote (good or bad), but it's even more affective if you share the link with your friends and family outside of your area. Explain to them why this is a bad idea and point out how their representative voted (good or bad) and make a date to check back with them before the next election.
I don't think this is true at all. It certainly won't happen fast enough for most people's liking though.
The best example of this is how Microsoft had no option but to do a 180 on open source once it realized that it was turning into an object of ridicule. (Although Windows 10 shows they still have some ways to go). You are really underestimating how powerful peer respect is amongst geeks.
For example, imagine if someone from Google asked you to come work for them in 2002-2004, and said "Our motto is Dont be evil", and suddenly that became a sort of rallying cry and everyone knew who the target was. Imagine if they said the same thing today - they would be laughed off. And that is a great thing. I would guess most geeks working at the tech giants have some part of them thinking they are doing things which really benefit humanity.
Here is a thread where you can see this in effect, when the person's motives are challenged, they become completely defensive. We want more of that. My prediction is at some point there will be serious internal conflict, which is excellent!
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13868299
Once more people start making a lot of noise about this in the very places that the geeks wish to hang out, they will find themselves with fewer and fewer places to go hang out. And it will then only be a matter of time before there is a large exodus from the top companies to the more obscure companies - those which can't do much damage simply because they are too small.
At that point, both outcomes would be favorable - either things get so bad that the tech giants implode from internal conflict and external competition, or they will change their behavior so that they can continue to attract the developers who actually care about these things.
Or it could go in the exact opposite direction because everyone stops caring, in which case we are all just completely screwed :-)
(1) Companies will become better at deceiving their employees they are not evil, not eliminating small competition, and that they care about privacy and diversity. Many younger devs are as naive as cocker spaniel pups and will easily buy any corporate propaganda.
(2) How will there be an exodus to smaller companies when the giants do their very best to kill competition? Google is known for buying an emerging company in a certain area then quietly shut it down but still keep patents and knowledge for the future, being one prominent example.
(3) People become more and more indifferent every day, I feel, even on HN. I know I am in that group as well. The people who want the internet to be a controlled environment are, as of today, much too powerful and very, VERY persistent. Plus it's not like you can just sue; for a long time now it's not about justice, it's about who has the deeper pockets for lawyers. And that's not you and me.
IMO we're headed for a pretty classic cyberpunk future. I kind of hoped that I will die before that but at the rate things are going... It's pretty scary.
For example here, there is a good example in France there is fdn, an association of very smalls internets providers, they are not companies, but associations,
What if everyone could make an internet provider with no motivation in financial profits...
Maybe it will be a bit more expensive, because it scale less, but trusting you internet provider is priceless.
I understand your sentiment; it sucks.
One can still do stuff that doesn't need net access, computing is a very broad field, not limited to the internet. Or one can search for technological fixes that make it harder to snoop on us ....
Then, everyone else caught up. Now it's just like watching television. A bunch of companies vying to get you to buy something at any cost, and taking that strategy further than they ever did before the internet.
Now, I just want to leave my phone at home and go ride my bike. I rarely feel like developing anything anymore, haven't done a side project in over a year. Whenever I get motivated to do things like that I see shit like this and it just feels hopeless. There's no way to defeat these companies, because they are full of people struggling to get ahead and doing their cog's part in the machine that ultimately does this to us all.