It seems that China's workers can make Macbooks and iPhones with high precision and low tolerances according to Apple's specifications. Were the Molex molds more complicated than that?
In other words, if those specific 15-20 Chinese workers failed, maybe choosing a different set of 20 Chinese employees (or partner manufacturer) would have given the quality desired?
All I can say, is my dad recieved a hell of an offer to return (and so did his buddies). The people he trained all had PhD's from various universities around the globe and were supposedly excellent material science engineers. My dad had a high school education, but was trained/worked for decades in this particular field.
The molds that make every component in a MacBook need to be better than those assembling them. The skill to plug in a keyboard or even run a machine to make a keyboard, is not the same as designing or creating the molds of the keyboard. Apple does all of that (to my knowledge) in the U.S. The reason is likely security of their IP and that they have a critical mass of skilled people here, able to out perform elsewhere. Also, it's easy to ship designs anywhere, not so much material goods.
And plastic parts are more and more reserved for low end product, whereas high end products are all made of metal (think about a plane architecture being made of plastic instead of aluminium: this will not happen soon).
So to be honest about your dad situation: from an industrial point of view I think the people outsourcing your dad's job in China were right: they did loose the know-how on keyboards molds and they do face a problem regarding keyboard quality nowadays, but that value gained in outsourcing low end parts was invested in machining technologies with very local jobs garanteed for a long industrial time.
I'm sorry about your dad situation in that systemic change, and I'm glad he managed to move to another field, but what's at stake here is really what a was proposed in a parent comment: 'manual' labour being replaced with automation (and human tragedies involved unfortunately...).
Actually the trend is towards carbon fiber (reinforced plastic) laid out on a mold https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUp9Yl6-QBM
The heavy-duty first-range aeronautic suppliers are all into machining and assembling aluminium (and other metals) parts for boeing/airbus.
You don't take anyone from anywhere drop them in front of a master tradesman for 12 weeks and have a master tradesman pop out in a few days. The output there is a guy who can probably run the machine and have a limited ability to consistently churn out stuff without understanding the process fully. That's not a reflection of pay, race or talent.
That's usually a big part of the design of the outsourcing arrangement. You train for minimum viable capability. You then just fine the suppliers and eventually you'll get what you need, even if they waste half of the work produced. I've done these with domestic and foreign contractors. It's always the same story. The difference here is that the quality required for tools is higher than end products, and the supplier cannot make money without the high skilled people.
But then ten years later the workers you trained have now formed their own company and they are the ones making the huge profits, and there's nothing you can do because your country doesn't even have any skills in the field anymore. Now spread this across tens and hundreds of industries.
Sure, we still have software development and other super high tech stuff, but China is figuring much of this out very quickly as well.
I think we'll find out soon enough which country had the better strategy.
The defining quote of this idea came from the Morris Chang, CEO of TSMC:
"You Americans measure profitability by a ratio. There’s a problem with that. No banks accept deposits denominated in ratios. The way we measure profitability is in ‘tons of money’. You use the return on assets ratio if cash is scarce. But if there is actually a lot of cash, then that is causing you to economize on something that is abundant."
Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/18/clayton...
Ratio-based investment isn't fundamentally short or long term, and the article doesn't persuasively make that argument. The entire point of selling off your assets to improve profit-to-asset ratios is to improve the performance of your assets, so that they can be put in investments which offer better profits. Whether the new investments are short-term investments or long-term investments is a matter of investor preference, not financial science.
In fact, the argument to be made is that companies which "sell off" their human capital are actually in violation of RONA principles, because the company is not ultimately made of dollars and cents but of people and products, and since the company can't really extract more value out of its highly specialized human capital (I.e. by reassigning it to more productive work), it should not reassign that capital elsewhere.
Investment bankers and programmers tend to make the same error: you are less competitive at manipulating your abstraction (whether that be money or high-level languages) if you do not understand how it abstracts away reality. Otherwise, you will constantly be dealing with leaky abstractions.
The management people give no shits about the organization as an entity. Their short term outlook is driven by the dumb KPIs that stand in front of their excessive (vs. base) incentive compensation.
tl;dr Don't rush to blame the workers, they're usually just doing what they've been told to do.
The majority of the time, that's the only reason why they're relocating the work. If you have to pay foreign workers equivalent to Americans to get equivalent work, then offshoring is pointless.
Not really Google and MS provide their Indian employees working in India above average market rates which are still lower than what the average American gets.
Some other US based companies directly or indirectly pay their Indian employees average or below average Indian IT salary so the best and brightest dont go there.
In many ways the difference is that headquarters is next or on top of the factory instead of in a different state.
Sorry I have to question this .. Bosch, Mercedes, BMW? There are a few notables such as Krupps that were once upon a time family owned but increasingly these companies are owned by global conglomerates.
Yes, these companies do outsource many functions to poorer countries but their centre of gravity is very certainly in Germany.
I play harmonica, and German made Hohner's are considered to be the best. The only quality competitor is Seydel(Again a German company), or Suzuki(Japanese). I think its the overall culture and seasoning to quality and workmanship your ordinary citizens are used to.
The real deal isn't just High end manufacturing.
I know of a relative of mine who used to buy Grundig and Braun radio/taperecorders/stereos in the 80's. The design and quality still comes across way ahead of its times.
Quality shows in everything you build.
Volumes may be profitable for a while. But with lack of quality you won't be able to build BMW's and Airbus's. The kind of manufacturing that has a future.
The issue has nothing to do with ethnicity per se, and everything to do with management dreams of hordes of top-notch foreign talent just dying to do high quality work for pennies on the dollar, which in my experience simply doesn't exist.
My [relative] is [in a tech role] for [large insurer]). They recently laid off all of their in-house tech staff save for her, in favor of outsourcing, and are leaving him to train and guide the entirety of the new staff. Meanwhile, they did absolutely nothing to keep his morale/loyalty, nor to ensure he was incentivized to do this task well. So, unsurprisingly, he's counting the days to retirement and letting the clusterf*s mount.
I'm sure there was a way to handle this that wasn't ludicrously inept; the result, however, will be laid at the feet of the foreign workers that have little training and no access to the now-lost institutional knowledge.
On the surface, you have to manage extra things like shipping and imports. Under the hood, quality control and partner selection are MUCH more in-depth and difficult processes. If you're not working with someone who already has relationships built, and/or if you're not willing to be very hands-on with the process, from what I've been told you're unlikely to get high-quality, low-cost parts.
I can definitely imagine someone who is used to dealing with manufacturing in the US having a lot of issues adjusting to the way business is done in China if they didn't know what they were getting themselves into.
[1]: http://mashable.com/2016/06/17/apple-china-knockoffs/#j5Nyhh...
[2]: http://www.businessinsider.com/inside-fake-chinese-apple-sto...
[3]: https://qz.com/771727/chinas-factories-in-shenzhen-can-copy-...
In outsourcing situations where you replace a highly-skilled and highly-paid worker with a low paid one in another country, you often get predictably bad results. Is it a cultural difference? Is it because of the compensation? Or just the attitudes of the companies involved on both sides and the kind of people they hire? I think like any complex issue, there's no one answer, but that last point sounds particularly convincing.
Look at SF, every company competes in that market for software engineers because that's where the talent is.
It's actually a concept explored by the book "The Talent Code", and even explains why so many people from puerto rico (by population) are so amazing at baseball. Everyone plays, everyone looks up to it, and everyone makes everyone else better.
No, they bring the "talent" (God, I hate this word and what it carries) from everywhere across the country and abroad. They is no tesseract fuelled talent generator device hidden below SF.
Isn't Apple's high-precision manufacturing highly automated to a level of expense that no one else would try? IIRC, they have acres of automated CNC mills churning out MacBook cases.
Apple's manufacturing operation is so unique that it's not generalizable.
Source: http://atomicdelights.com/blog/why-your-next-iphone-wont-be-...
thought I read it somewhere that china is literally the only country in the world right now that can do that at scale and change specs as rapidly as apple wants them to.
Probably not, and therefore the manufacturer was looking for rock-bottom prices, and thereby got what they paid for.
Foxconn didn't start building millions of iPhones. They started with thousands of other products. Same thing happened with Dell. They financed factories for Asus to build laptops and walked away from nearly new plants in the US not long ago for mostly tax and accounting reasons.
China can, actually.
We've had molds made for the smallworks.com products in both China and locally (Austin, TX)
These molds, due to the desire to interface with LEGO products, have to produce products that are both "higly cosmetic" as well as dealing with the extreme tolerances of LEGO's system.
It's about 1/3 the price to make the molds in China. Due to shipping and import duties, it's about the same price to run production in the US as in China.
Or even ball-bearings: http://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/a20837/german-chi...
Most of China’s industrial robots are made by Germany, the US, and Japan. The Chinese are hopeless at precision engineering.
Thing is, Craftsman quality went to shit because Sears decided to compete solely on price. Apex/Danaher are plenty capable of turning out high quality tools in both their American and overseas plants (they own Armstrong, GearWrench, and Xcelite). They're also capable of producing shit tools for Sears. Turns out though that other companies (ex: Harbor Freight) can product comparable, if not superior, products for a lower cost.
You'll find random brands you've never heard of that are "made in USA" and built to military spec. I think most military tools are required to be made domestically. The quality is amazing and prices low.
So many presuppositions here that don't really support a future of a specialized American worker.
China has weak to nonexistent intellectual property LAWS, and their Antitrust law was enacted just in 2008!
Improvements in the general economy still result in a plethora of skilled workers across the entire planet, or in much greater quantity than the market needs.
Today? Yes it is possible to renege on free trade treaties and close borders to pretend the uniqueness of a highly skilled American is inherent to quality goods, but these are not absolutes and can't be extrapolated into these impending economic dilemmas.
Anyways, he basically trained his replacement(s) before they laid off a large portion of his machine shop. He trained probably 15 - 20 Chinese over the course of a few years. In the end, as expected, they laid him off. Fast forward 10 years and they had to bring a lot of the tool making back.
Turns out the Chinese either had worse quality control or poorer skill, but they simply couldn't produce at the same level. You only need a few molds for a production line, but each needs to be near perfect. The Chinese couldn't do it. And even when they did / could, the intellectual property was often stolen, so competitors would pop up and customers would get pissed.
You're correct automation is needed. However, so is high quality standards, higher education, higher moral codes / higher pay to keep people honest. The fact is, you can't really find skilled labor elsewhere easily (they want the same as the US wages). That's why the US's number one export is education, and probably why every company still fights over software engineers and really every STEM field.
Unfortunately for manufacturing, the fight is over. When they tried to bring the tool making back there were very few people still doing it. Every single one of my dad's friends (including my dad) had moved on to other jobs. The fact is, all that tribal knowledgewas passed down from master to apprentice was lost. After they laid off the masters, there was/is no one left to really continue.
Personally, I view this as a loss of critical mass and now our skills are likely no better than anywhere else, at least for tool making.
I think this is a warning for every business. Sometimes it's worth paying the price to keep talent. Companies like Google, Apple, et al, know this. Hopefully, that will keep tech and a lot of the other large US companies from losing their way.