News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by csomar on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:07PM (#13981207)
I don't know the OP but I think his father is biased. The story is repeated a lot (The Chinese/Indians/Other-Race are cheaper but can't produce the same!) even for Software developers (Indians). In most cases (at least for the software engineering) the problem turns out that the other-race pay was low, and thus attracted low talent. The company probably wanted to cut costs and picked cheap foreign workers that didn't perform.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by Spooky23 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:01PM (#13982691)
It's not a racist thing and your reading it that way reflects a high level of ignorance.

You don't take anyone from anywhere drop them in front of a master tradesman for 12 weeks and have a master tradesman pop out in a few days. The output there is a guy who can probably run the machine and have a limited ability to consistently churn out stuff without understanding the process fully. That's not a reflection of pay, race or talent.

That's usually a big part of the design of the outsourcing arrangement. You train for minimum viable capability. You then just fine the suppliers and eventually you'll get what you need, even if they waste half of the work produced. I've done these with domestic and foreign contractors. It's always the same story. The difference here is that the quality required for tools is higher than end products, and the supplier cannot make money without the high skilled people.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by mistermann on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:56PM (#13982963)
And that high level of difficult to learn skills if tended and protected can yield dividends for generations. Or, one generation can outsource everything including decades of hard learned secrets for a short term boost in earnings by selling for the same price but paying 1/10th the wages so they can cash out millions in stock options.

But then ten years later the workers you trained have now formed their own company and they are the ones making the huge profits, and there's nothing you can do because your country doesn't even have any skills in the field anymore. Now spread this across tens and hundreds of industries.

Sure, we still have software development and other super high tech stuff, but China is figuring much of this out very quickly as well.

I think we'll find out soon enough which country had the better strategy.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:04AM (#13983302)
Agreed.

The defining quote of this idea came from the Morris Chang, CEO of TSMC:

"You Americans measure profitability by a ratio. There’s a problem with that. No banks accept deposits denominated in ratios. The way we measure profitability is in ‘tons of money’. You use the return on assets ratio if cash is scarce. But if there is actually a lot of cash, then that is causing you to economize on something that is abundant."

Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/18/clayton...

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by solatic on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @06:38AM (#13984853)
Not really. The fundamental problem in the economy is the focus on the short term rather than the long term. The economy focuses on the short term because Wall Street focuses on the short term and will invest in firms with similar short term focus.

Ratio-based investment isn't fundamentally short or long term, and the article doesn't persuasively make that argument. The entire point of selling off your assets to improve profit-to-asset ratios is to improve the performance of your assets, so that they can be put in investments which offer better profits. Whether the new investments are short-term investments or long-term investments is a matter of investor preference, not financial science.

In fact, the argument to be made is that companies which "sell off" their human capital are actually in violation of RONA principles, because the company is not ultimately made of dollars and cents but of people and products, and since the company can't really extract more value out of its highly specialized human capital (I.e. by reassigning it to more productive work), it should not reassign that capital elsewhere.

Investment bankers and programmers tend to make the same error: you are less competitive at manipulating your abstraction (whether that be money or high-level languages) if you do not understand how it abstracts away reality. Otherwise, you will constantly be dealing with leaky abstractions.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @10:43AM (#13986674)
I think we're arguing the same thing.

The management people give no shits about the organization as an entity. Their short term outlook is driven by the dumb KPIs that stand in front of their excessive (vs. base) incentive compensation.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by oillio on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:57AM (#13983536)
Awesome article. Thank you.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by JabavuAdams on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:12AM (#13983334)
You're both right, but you specifically phrase this as a training and institutional knowledge problem, without mentioning nationality. You get to the heart of the problem, without the nationality red herring that tends to attract nativists and racists, to the confusion of everyone.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:43PM (#13981935)
That doesn't necessarily make the father biased/racist; but I think you're right about the economic incentives at play. Many of the problems I've encountered with Chinese manufacturing can be traced back to stateside managers/purchasers wanting to relentlessly drive the price down, yet still exert the same kind of QC effort (or less) than they did with their former in-house manufacturing. They (mgmt) failed to recognize a lot of informal QC that might otherwise be lumped in with "work-ethic." They also probably laid off the experienced QC and put a jr level engineer/recent grad "in charge", but with little/no authority to do anything. Meanwhile on the Chinese side, the workers work hard, usually with every effort focused on speed. I remember one specific case where an assembler kept ruining chassis because they wouldn't replace worn screwdrivers for the assemblers. They caused lots of rework simply because the Chinese shop manager was too tight to accept that screwdrivers are consumables.

tl;dr Don't rush to blame the workers, they're usually just doing what they've been told to do.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by Gracana on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @06:56PM (#13981619)
Tool and die making is the height of machining skill, it takes a very good machinist, the right machine, and the right environment. This story doesn't seem unreasonable.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by taivare on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:02PM (#13982064)
Cleveland Oh. was the tool & die capitol of the world those jobs started to leave in the 80's and NAFTA and the Great Recession took the rest especially the small ones in Western Pa. As for Molex the Koch's bought them in 2013 but, I haven't followed where or what they have done with Molex. I have used Molex machines in production they were so well made. When I was a kid Cleveland made everything I remember the pride I felt seeing a dump truck the size of 2 houses ( Euc) roll out of the factory back then. It wasn't my fathers generation Silent (Korea) that sent those jobs out of the country it was the generation that followed them !
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by DashRattlesnake on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @09:50PM (#13982627)
> The company probably wanted to cut costs and picked cheap foreign workers that didn't perform.

The majority of the time, that's the only reason why they're relocating the work. If you have to pay foreign workers equivalent to Americans to get equivalent work, then offshoring is pointless.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by sumedh on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @12:54AM (#13983523)
> If you have to pay foreign workers equivalent to Americans to get equivalent work, then offshoring is pointless.

Not really Google and MS provide their Indian employees working in India above average market rates which are still lower than what the average American gets.

Some other US based companies directly or indirectly pay their Indian employees average or below average Indian IT salary so the best and brightest dont go there.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by gozur88 on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:18PM (#13982768)
If it's that easy to move highly skilled positions to the Far East, how do you explain Germany's prowess in high-end manufacturing? Surely all those jobs should have moved to China by now? It's been two generations since Deng opened the country up to foreign manufacturers.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by mistermann on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @10:59PM (#13982974)
Germans may think beyond next quarters earnings.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by jerven on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:28AM (#13984353)
Its because most of these companies are small and largely family owned. i.e. the owners understand the product, and moving it to china means they would need to move to china as well.

In many ways the difference is that headquarters is next or on top of the factory instead of in a different state.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by rusk on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:06AM (#13984956)
Its because most of these companies are small and largely family owned

Sorry I have to question this .. Bosch, Mercedes, BMW? There are a few notables such as Krupps that were once upon a time family owned but increasingly these companies are owned by global conglomerates.

Yes, these companies do outsource many functions to poorer countries but their centre of gravity is very certainly in Germany.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by rusk on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @07:02AM (#13984945)
Germany also has an amazing pluralistic educational system. Nobody gets left behind. All state-funded, which I guess follows from the high taxes they pay ... "it takes money to make money", as the man says.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by kamaal on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @11:13AM (#13987030)
Forget about high end manufacturing.

I play harmonica, and German made Hohner's are considered to be the best. The only quality competitor is Seydel(Again a German company), or Suzuki(Japanese). I think its the overall culture and seasoning to quality and workmanship your ordinary citizens are used to.

The real deal isn't just High end manufacturing.

I know of a relative of mine who used to buy Grundig and Braun radio/taperecorders/stereos in the 80's. The design and quality still comes across way ahead of its times.

Quality shows in everything you build.

Volumes may be profitable for a while. But with lack of quality you won't be able to build BMW's and Airbus's. The kind of manufacturing that has a future.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by wycx on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @04:37AM (#13984389)
Some is moving to Eastern Europe. Daimler make transmissions and other components in Romania.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by gozur88 on Friday March 31, 2017 @05:11PM (#14008283)
When I say "high-end manufacturing" I'm not really talking about cars. More along the lines of industries that require very, very tight tolerances and exotic materials like tooling or optics.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by jinfiesto on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @08:31PM (#13982217)
I think that there may be some truth to that narrative. I suspect that Chinese/Indian/Other-Race workers that are skilled at an in demand profession simply shop their work where they are paid commensurate with their skill (Probably not cheap.)
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by sho on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @01:56AM (#13983784)
I think there's a lot of truth to that. I've had nothing but bad experiences walking into companies that outsource software to India for cost reasons, and yet I know a number of exceptionally talented Indian software engineers. The difference, of course, is that the talented guys know their worth, and will demand at least above-average compensation. The outsource shops hire down to a price and get pretty much who you'd expect with that practise.

The issue has nothing to do with ethnicity per se, and everything to do with management dreams of hordes of top-notch foreign talent just dying to do high quality work for pennies on the dollar, which in my experience simply doesn't exist.

Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by jinfiesto on Wednesday March 29, 2017 @03:09AM (#13984057)
100% agree. I've had generally negative experiences with work that's been outsourced to Indian shops, but nothing but positive experiences with Indian engineers I've worked with outside that context.
Re:Staying Rich Without Manufacturing Will Be Hard by arkades on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @11:40PM (#13983185)
There's also the question of how the transition is implemented.

My [relative] is [in a tech role] for [large insurer]). They recently laid off all of their in-house tech staff save for her, in favor of outsourcing, and are leaving him to train and guide the entirety of the new staff. Meanwhile, they did absolutely nothing to keep his morale/loyalty, nor to ensure he was incentivized to do this task well. So, unsurprisingly, he's counting the days to retirement and letting the clusterf*s mount.

I'm sure there was a way to handle this that wasn't ludicrously inept; the result, however, will be laid at the feet of the foreign workers that have little training and no access to the now-lost institutional knowledge.