You've just described a very common type of non-technical user.
As GP said, users got a very obvious warning. It's not like there was a 1000-word long essay greyed out which contained the words "oh and this is all public" in a random location. This isn't about how technical users are, it's just a user error that anyone could make. I would be extremely surprised if you told me that, for example, there are less than a hundred Google Docs with sensitive information that are publicly viewable. In fact, I would probably call anyone above the age of 20 a liar if they said that during their entire life they had never, ever shared something they didn't mean to share. Even when it comes to things we're very familiar with, like our own mouths, we sometimes share more than we intend to.
I think generally non-technical users are just pretty diverse, and I'd wager there's more non-readers than readers...
That said, in this case, I'm not sure what more MS can do beyond simply not offering this service.
Work in tech support, can confirm
It is very clear, to you. To me. To other people? The evidence doesn't support that claim.
So again: was it clear enough? Apparently not.
You can argue about this as long as you want, but interpretation of an interface is not complete until you get the context. Ours is that of someone who's either looking for it, or aware of the possibility of its existence.
If you're neither, perhaps you'd need to be able to see other people's documents as well. Perhaps you need a big ol' warning sign with tick-boxes before you dismiss it.
Maybe the default should be hidden, and sharing made optional. I realise this doesn't make much sense for a "sharing" feature, but maybe it's been labelled wrong. "Sharing" doesn't necessarily (read: "by definition") mean "everyone in the whole world can browse your stuff".
So imo, two parties to blame.
Yes. It's the user's own fault.
No. It's not clear enough.
I'm not sure that's clear? The headline says "hundreds" of sensitive documents are on there. How many documents are on there total?
Please upload a document to host publicly for anyone on the internet.
As for the design here - how about a big red banner with "by ticking here this document will be available to the public and can be found through search engines" or similar?
While they should be able to react quickly, I'm also sure that they have to switch to "able to react quickly mode", and won't always be ready to launch missiles at the push of a single button!
People often assume a level of security at work that doesn't match reality.
Apparently, for a document uploading service, this case shows an example that's below the acceptable rate.
See it this way; you don't want someone to accidentally trigger a nuclear bomb even once. However you probably don't care that a knife sometimes cuts a finger.
Acceptable defect rate is the defect rate that does not result in an Ars article pointing out the defect rate of your product.
A big one was the meaning of "everyone" in OneDrive. Many people thought that it meant "everyone on my team", and posted all sorts of wacky stuff.
No one in my building uses one drive, no one asked for one drive but Microsoft keeps trying to shove it down our throats. It feels like an anti-pattern like the forced windows 10 "upgrade" for home users.
According to word I have Office 365 ProPlus version - I note there is no option to save to docs.com.
I encounter many co-workers though who like to do things "the old way" and just email copies of documents around and then spend time merging them back together instead of sending a link to their OneDrive. Just more files for me to juggle on my computer. No thanks.
Partly because I need to access stuff offline so prefer to have a local copy. For example if I have to take my laptop travelling with between sites I may not have access to a internet connection.
Your right that a large part is familiarity - we use Sharepoint (which I also hate) to share documents between teams rather than email.
You missed the serious suckabe. 3 years ago you could put the sync client on a fresh install of Windows 8 and do nothing with it and it would break itself.
Assuming a particular number of users are going to be too stupid, careless or rushed to set the privacy option, I think I'd err on the side of caution. What's worse: Not having the document available to all, but accessible by the link? or having the document available to all and the link unwittingly?
It is of course the users fault, but that doesn't mean the devs can't take extra steps when a flaw is pointed out.
Some people would benefit from more safety features but nobody wants to ride in a car with a full roll cage and a helmet.
Funny you should bring up auto safety when we've now got at least 4-6, and sometimes as many as 13 airbags in the average new car despite the fact they'll often never be used, and all because of the drivers. Certainly lane departure and collision avoidance systems aren't there for the people using vehicles properly.
"Public on the web Anyone can find it on the web. Search engines will find the doc, giving it a larger audience."
It's not unambiguous. It's very clear. The only way you can't tell what it's doing is if you just pay no attention whatsoever to what you're doing. It's not the default sharing method from either Office 365 (web, traditional or Android/iOS) or OneDrive. You have to opt into using it at all at an IT department level if you have a corporate Office 365 department. You really just can't stop users from footgunning themselves when they're on the open Internet.