There really aren't many other alternatives.
I'm all for a Utopian society where nobody needs to encrypt private messages, but so long as there are people in power who feel they need special treatment, then I will continue to demand the same level privacy as them.
It takes too much to reply: "Tell you what, I'm going to educate you better instead". Because you can educate all you want, you will not have results that helps your re-election 4-5 years down the road.
I have a feeling that some top level FBI people are properly informed, but still want this kind of legislation.
The interviewer could explore the impact of online fraud or identity theft or cyber-bullying, and look at how fast these problems have been growing in recent years. Then challenge the advocate of weakened encryption or mass surveillance over why they want to require security vulnerabilities or create huge databases that will make great targets for criminals. If they claim everything would be securely held and strictly for police use or similar, go with Snowden and Wikileaks.
If the advocate brings up their other favourite argument about protecting children, the interviewer could ask whether it's really a good idea to make it easier to intercept private picture messages between teenagers.
They could ask why the government wants measures that would inevitably undermine investigative journalism that holds the government and the police and the security services to account. Then start listing past controversies relating to the behaviour of those groups to demonstrate why that public interest reporting matters.
It's not as if privacy and security advocates only think these things are important because they don't like the government or something. There are real, serious consequences in play several different ways here.
The scary thing is that the difference between the UK and the kind of place we might describe using words like "totalitarian state" is now more about how our laws are used in practice than what the laws actually say. The government and its agents already have very broad powers, our courts have already taken surprisingly illiberal positions when some of those powers have been challenged, and we lack the constitutional checks and balances often found elsewhere, more so if the government uses Brexit as a mechanism to remove those deriving from Europe without replacing them. We're basically just trusting that the government and its agents will be decent people and use the powers they have responsibly at this point, but as we've seen with the likes of Trump, that's a dangerous strategy when you don't know who the government will be in the future.
For example, Australia's Lindt Cafe siege - the guy was already under "24 hour surveillance" by ASIO (Australian Security Intelligence) - which did nothing to prevent the attack. Despite this, AFAIK there was not much blame placed on ASIO. I'm sure there are many other examples. I'm not saying it's an easy problem to solve, just that more surveillance is probably not the answer.
Sure, the attacker is the real culprit, but adding more laws and surveillance will not prevent crazies from doing crazy stuff.
> Dr Barrett placed Monis on anti-psychotic medication after he told her he was under surveillance 24 hours a day from ASIO and Iranian authorities, including in the bathroom of his home. [1]
> Mr Abbott conceded Man Haron Monis was not on a security watchlist, despite his long criminal history and known "infatuation with extremism". [2]
Still, the whole thing demonstrates how useless more surveillance would be.
If they can't even watch someone with a long criminal history and infatuation with extremism, why do they expect us to believe that looking at my dick pics will somehow stop terrorism?
[1] http://www.smh.com.au/nsw/lindt-cafe-siege-inquest-man-haron...
[2] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2014-12-17/sydney-siege3a-could-i...
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn said authorities already had "huge powers". There had to be a balance between the "right to know" and "the right to privacy", he said. [1]
Unfortunately when it came to actually doing something he provided practically no opposition to the Investigatory Powers Act.
It's one reason I left the UK in the first place; not because of facing personal discrimination for being Irish (I did face some but most British people are pragmatic and fair-minded), but because of the whole securitized atmosphere with security cameras everywhere - it was like being in prison.
However, I have little hope of this changing. As far as I can tell the vast majority of people value security over privacy or autonomy, and of course they never think Bad Things are going to happen to them because they're Good People - like the woman in the news the other day who voted for Trump and is now surprised that her husband is being deported even though he's not a 'bad hombre.'
It's unlikely that there will ever be a mass movement for privacy and autonomy, because the genius and failure o democracy is that it's harder to blame your problems on some antipathetic Other - foreign invaders, aristocrats, an elite social class or whatever. Democracy really depends on people thinking about issues, and most people want to be firmly embedded in a social context, perhaps because were a eusocial species. It's hard for them to conceptualize an oppressive state in the same way that it's hard for most people to imagine hating their parents or the people int heir community.
Happily, as far as digital technology is concerned there is not a whole lot the UK government can actually do about the issue, and May's speechifying is more directed at appeasing the drooling tabloid-reading class than it is reflective of any serious policy initiative. the likely effect sit aht operating systems on computing devices sold in the UK won't be allowed to have built-in encryption and the smart set will be using mods of some sort. Pretty much how it was with PGP 25 years ago.
Please don't attribute homicidal political views to insanity. These people don't have schizophrenia, and people with schizophrenia aren't terrorists.
The only difference is in who they answer to.
Murder is unjust killing. Killing civilians to make a point or to cause chaos is, by definition, murder. Let's not equate that with all the legitimate things armed forces are for.
And coalition is also killing civilians for political reasons, more than thousand of them a month ATM. It is obviously calculated. It's just that someone determined murdering perhaps 5-10 thousands civilians is a OK to give power over Mosul back to Iraqi government, and gave it a go.
The Catholic Church is a good example. The fifth commandment is thou shall not murder. And the Catechism clarifies this by saying
> The fifth commandment forbids direct and intentional killing as gravely sinful. The murderer and those who cooperate voluntarily in murder commit a sin that cries out to heaven for vengeance.
Source: http://www.vatican.va/archive/ccc_css/archive/catechism/p3s2...
In international arena, there's no universal law.
Some idiots killed a few thousands Americans, and then some Americans did go on a killing rampage as a revenge, murdering 10s of thousands mostly unrelated people. That's about how it looks from the outside.
Pretty much every single person involved in, say, the Iraq war was indeed a murderer. Most of the battles the West has engaged in since WWII were unjust and ill-founded. The people involved in those wars are murderers.
There's a semantic discussion about whether "lone gunmen" type attacks count as "terrorism", but categorizing motivations in real life as politics or insanity isn't so simple.
The lack of adoption of Chinese services elsewhere has more to do with cultural and technological issues than anything related to censorship.
If I need a communication to be secret, I will encrypt it, and I don't need special software.
Even if posession of encrypted messages without the ability to decrypt carries a 10 year prison sentence?
(Yes, this has serious enforceability problems, but that doesn't mean it can't become law)
https://arstechnica.co.uk/tech-policy/2017/02/justice-naps-m...
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2F978-3-540-77566-...
The "Terrorists" really don't care about the law or the prison sentence behind breaking it.
Law is social code and it runs not on logic but on the belief of a sufficient majority of the public. If technological factors cannot be overcome, social ones can. You are very naive to think that a governmental entity has to care about logic with regard to individual humans, just as ants would be naive to think they could dissuade you from stepping on them when you walk through the garden. The fact that encryption is technically possible under almost any circumstances (even in prison you could conceivably exchange encrypted messages tapped out in morse code through the walls, say) doesn't matter because the calculus of criminal responsibility doesn't depend on some objective process int he way that an encryption algorithm does.
Nerds are very logical, but people in general are not, and appealing to their sense of logic or consistency is dangerous because you cannot rely on them to change their behavior or attitude for cognitive reasons. Organized religion epitomizes this; people may or may not believe in the actuality of an inaccessible personal divinity, but a) the social rewards for professing to do so may vastly outweigh other considerations, and b) the people who do believe will abandon logic before they'll abandon a belief structure that makes them feel good about themselves.
The UK Home Secretary isn't applying for a job in network security or at a tech company. She's telling people what sort of trouble they're going to be in if they insist on deploying or using strong encryption. And since she's in charge of the police, she is capable of making good on those claims. She is perfectly competent - not at the consistent management of information systems, but at wielding political power.
Your idea of winning an argument is a logical demonstration that would be accepted by your peers. A social entity's idea of winning the argument (by social entity I mean an organized collective intelligence, from a village to a superstate) is to simply remove you physically from the field of play. Societies are coordinated in the same manner as insect swarms or other eusocial structures; They are no less distinct for being distributed, and logical arguments have no meaning to them except insofar as they impact the swam's environment, which is not at all the same thing as the environment of the individual swarm members, even the most senior ones.
This is why a 'privacy first' app/platform/protocol will never succeed on those merits alone. The social body can always make arguments against privacy, for exactly the same reason that you don't care about the feelings of any cancerous or invasive cells that spring to life inside your physical body. What's needed are tools that are built to include privacy from the ground up, but whose use case is better speed and functionality, such that people cannot bear to go without the tools they confer an overwhelming economic advantage.
Thus, fax machines were more 'private' than telex machines insofar as fax transmissions were harder to decrypt, plus they could just be plugged into any telephone socket. But if that had been their only advantage they'd have been banned. the overwhelming benefit of a fax machine was that you could just feed a sheet of paper into it - almost any kind of paper - and send it to someone else by pushing a single button. This was a massive time-saver for business - much cheaper and simpler than installing a Telex system, much cheaper and faster than sending documents around by courier, and much more practical than relying on verbal agreements and notes from telephone conversations.
(I'd like to make it clear that fax machines were never designed or marketed to be secure comms channels, but as a purely practical matter they filled that function for many people, and people who still use faxes often do so because they feel somehow more 'secure' than email.)
I think the work of security services have never been easier as it is now thanks to the massive use of social networks and mobile phones, CCTVs everywhere, GEOINT, etc. At least for the Five Eyes.
This too will fail spectacularly.
I hope you're right, but I don't think so.
The next time there is an attack, I don't think there will be an outcry that the all-pervasive surveillance has failed us, only an outcry against the terrorists (who, let's face it, are the real offenders).
One might counter that the scenario I lay out above is not possible. However I would posit that technology enables our capacities to create/preserve and to destroy. However, perhaps stemming from thr laws of thermodynamics, it does seem that our capacities to destroy is always outpacing our capacities to create or preserve, and eventually the gap between these capacities will unsettle the center which cannot hold.
Survival is not a value. Survival is a prerequisite for a lot of other values, but it's not a value in and of itself.
As many people have difficulty grasping what living in a world without privacy would be like, let me propose a different solution: We'll put everyone into solitary confinement, to ensure everyone's survival, as I do not see the value of freedom of movement trumping survival.
Would you agree with that as well? If not, why not?
Also, you might want to realize that surveillance does not ensure that your set of values gets enforced. It's the values of whoever manages to obtain that power, and whose power as a result of the surveillance might be impossible to challenge. The idea that you could create such a power structure and then guarantee that it's going to be used exclusively to prevent that bio weapon from being built and used is extremely naive. You would instead most likely find yourself alive, living in a world that makes you constantly wish for being dead, but thanks to the surveillance unable to kill yourself.
I'm not sure what point you're trying to make, are you saying we need more surveillance to protect us because weapons are becoming easier to produce?
Sure, encryption helps terrorists as well as ordinary citizens but it's my belief that freedom and privacy are more important than that. The work of police and security services has never been easy in a free society, but protecting and upholding that free society is the very essence of the job. Dilution of that freedom is therefore counter to the purpose for which these agencies exist, and so when the government tries to move in that direction we, as citizens, should voice our resistance, and keep voicing it until they understand.