News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by smilliken on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @04:16PM (#1396029)
Apple obviously wasn't interested in Lala's users, and I don't expect they were interested in code, so was it a talent acquisition or did Apple just do this to remove a competitor to future online music services?

Edit: spelling

Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by lurch_mojoff on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @04:38PM (#1396082)
Regardless of the merits of Lala's service, I highly doubt that the biggest music retailer in the U.S. had a reason to be afraid of any competition from them. Certainly not reason enough to be forced to buy them. Apple are infamously frugal when it comes to M&A, so this must be either "buying technology" or "buying talent". I guess we'll see which once the iTunes "cloud" service is launched.
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by Volscio on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @04:47PM (#1396108)
What if it doesn't launch?
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by jk8 on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @04:55PM (#1396124)
lala.com will not relaunch. Talent or technology will be integrated into iTunes and the consumers will get a something new.
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by alanstorm on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @05:06PM (#1396162)
When Apple bought Lala they did more than remove a future competitor. They removed a platform from the board that was making Flash (Lala used a flash interface) a relevant technology for some users. The also removed Google's best music search partner from the board. Both of the previous were potential channels where Apple could lose sales.

This is just tinfoil hat speculation, I don't have anything to back it up. However, this is the way that high level, powerful executives and a certain class of start-up founder think about markets.

Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by 27182818284 on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @05:52PM (#1396268)
>They removed a platform from the board that was making Flash (Lala used a flash interface) a relevant technology for some users.

That is a little out there, isn't it? It would be like buying a small company because their servers used GNU/Linux instead of OS X. If they were targeting places that made Flash "a relevant technology for some users," wouldn't they target Pandora, Farmville, graphic design schools that teach freshman Flash, etc?

Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by alanstorm on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @06:12PM (#1396317)
Oh, I acknowledge it's out there (ergo the tinfoil hat comment). However, to your specific examples: Pandora already agreed/decided to build an iPad/iPhone application, Zynga (creators of Farmville are in a financial position to turn down Apple's overtures, plus Zynga's business model/content is a bit of a poison pill. Going after graphic design schools would be political suicide, so it's off the table.
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by jstevens85 on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @06:24PM (#1396338)
Lala submitted an iPhone app for approval just before they were bought.

http://techcrunch.com/2009/10/28/its-almost-here-exclusive-v...

Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by alanstorm on Wednesday June 02, 2010 @12:26AM (#1397091)
One that was (unless I'm mistaken) never released.
Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by tzs on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @10:56PM (#1396887)
There was at least one report (I think it was here on HN) that said Apple had planned to have a replacement service up by now, but they ran into trouble negotiating licenses. The report said that Lala's licenses were not transferrable on an acquisition.

Non-transferrable licenses are quite believable, if the record companies considered Lala an experiment to test the waters. They'd put safeguards in to make sure that the licenses didn't end up at some place like Apple, so they (the record companies) can decide the pace of growth of this kind of service.

Note that if you check the date of the acquisition, and the date of the close of the service, it's something very close to six months, which sounds like the kind of grace period that would be plausible to allow for shut down of the non-transferable licenses.

Re:Lala shut down by Apple last night, May 31st by smilliken on Tuesday June 01, 2010 @08:06PM (#1396553)
It didn't occur to me earlier, but Lala actually has a few patents: http://www.google.com/patents?q=%22la+la+media%22&btnG=S...

Particularly, "Network Based Digital Rights Management System" (http://www.google.com/patents/about?id=esKwAAAAEBAJ&dq=%...) could be valuable for Apple.