News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by mattbee on Sunday March 26, 2017 @06:59AM (#13960137)
Amber Rudd is the UK's Home Secretary not just any minister.

"We need to make sure that our intelligence services have the ability to get into situations like encrypted Whatsapp."

She has said she is "calling in" technology companies this week to try to "deliver a solution".

Marr asks if they refuse to do that, will you legislate to force them to change? She's not drawn on that.

Interview is here:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b08l62r7/the-andrew-mar... [from 45:18]

I understood that UK IP Bill already mean that she already has the ability to e.g. demand a backdoored version of Whatsapp be sent to a target device, but that's not covered in the interview.

https://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/11/30/investigatory_power...

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by FungalRaincloud on Sunday March 26, 2017 @11:05AM (#13961127)
The thing that concerns me about this perspective that everyday use of encryption is bad is that it makes no damn sense. Pandora's box is opened; if you force software solutions to backdoor their technology, someone will just step up who doesn't care about your laws. There are no global treaties on software development, and we aren't going to be signing any such thing any day soon. Even if we could force something like that down the throats of every country on Earth, the knowledge exists, and anyone can roll out their own solution with a high-school level understanding of the topic.

It's absurd to think this can be resolved through legislation or cajoling companies into cooperation. But what really bothers me about this whole issue is that we already have laws in place that handle this situation, at least in the USA. In the USA, if you refuse to hand over an encryption key (or can't) and are being compelled to by a court, you can and will be held in contempt of court, and possibly convicted of destruction of evidence. The only thing that forcing people to backdoor their crypto does is allow government entities to investigate people without having sufficient evidence to compel them to give up their keys, and destroy the marketability of large scale, centralized end-to-end encryption solutions.

I mean, you could make the argument that end-to-end encryption restricts the ability to wiretap people, sure, but a wiretap warrant should require a decent amount of evidence, and at that point, there are most likely other options.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by sergior on Sunday March 26, 2017 @02:33PM (#13962284)
People can simply send random binary data to keep authorities busy.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by FungalRaincloud on Sunday March 26, 2017 @03:32PM (#13962667)
That would be somewhat entertaining, and reminds me of someone I read about years ago who was accidentally added to a watchlist, and no one was willing to remove him, so he started generating as much data as he could, just to keep them busy. I can't find a link, sadly.

I don't think it's a good solution, though. This is going to sound like an argument that you hear about privacy by people who don't understand why privacy matters, but I think on this issue, it holds a little more truth: To be honest, I think the people who are likely to care to do this are people who are advocates for privacy and are tech savvy, and people who have something to hide. I don't think it's terribly difficult, with the resources the global Intelligence Community has to build a profile and dump people into those two buckets with a fair degree of accuracy. Everyone who's not generating random garbage data would still be observable, so it wouldn't really change much outside of the group that's acting. But for those acting, suddenly there's a red flag that they can look for, and then when they see it, start building a profile to figure out if you're a tech person with an interest in privacy, or someone doing something they don't want seen, and act accordingly. In the mean time, we waste time generating garbage instead of just using good enough encryption, and making it so easy to use that people don't even have to know they're using it.

Now, if we could somehow implant babies with a chip that causes them to generate random noise (something babies are already pretty good at, mind you) from birth, that might be worth something. There's no profile building if the noise is just something that humans make by being alive.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by NetStrikeForce on Sunday March 26, 2017 @07:26AM (#13960225)
UK's best shot at surviving Brexit is become stronger on value added industries. They have a very good head start over any other EU country in IT and in some research areas.

Amber Rudd seems hell bent on destroying their only chance.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by prodmerc on Sunday March 26, 2017 @08:10AM (#13960369)
They all are intent on crippling any chance the UK has at becoming stronger in high tech industries.

I'm so sick of getting "this is an adult resource and you can't view it" anytime I search for information about a drug (pharmaceutical, not just "weed LSD and lols").

Great fucking way to encourage your future chemists. Maybe ban keywords like JavaScript, PHP and SQL while at it, them's the powerful drugs maaan.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by OJFord on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:03AM (#13960561)
> I'm so sick of getting "this is an adult resource and you can't view it" anytime I search for information

Switch ISP, or contact your current one to disable this. They don't all do it by default, or at all.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by jen20 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:32AM (#13960693)
As far as I'm aware all new accounts in the U.K. do this unless you call to have it disabled (and give personal information). I mean, how else would you protect the children...
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by k-mcgrady on Sunday March 26, 2017 @11:35AM (#13961281)
>> As far as I'm aware all new accounts in the U.K. do this unless you call to have it disabled (and give personal information).

Usually you can have it disabled while you sign up (and they usually ask if you want it). As for giving personal info - they're you're ISP. They have your name, address, billing details, have done a credit check...what else are they going to ask for that you haven't already supplied?

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by jen20 on Thursday March 30, 2017 @03:30AM (#13993586)
I can buy a 'burner' SIM when landing at Heathrow without giving any information - paying in cash. However, to disable the content filter requires giving up personal information.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by IanCal on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:39AM (#13960720)
I think all mobile providers do, but the filters are not required on all ISPs, only the big 7 IIRC.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by timthorn on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:06AM (#13960835)
You can find MVNOs without filtering, such as Andrews & Arnold
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by collyw on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:55AM (#13961076)
I was going to suggest them as well. My boss used to use them back when I was in the UK ten years ago and now I would definitely pay the extra for what they provide. Unfortunately I am in Spain now and the choice of ISP's is far more limited.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by mike-cardwell on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:50AM (#13961047)
Andrews & Arnold is unfortunately many times more expensive than the more "mainstream" ISPs. Much cheaper to get a Sky/Virgin connection, and then route all your traffic off their networks over a VPN to a cheap couple of quid VPS per month.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by blibble on Sunday March 26, 2017 @11:54AM (#13961364)
they aren't "many times more expensive"

compare BT[1] (£44.99 for 12 months, then £53.99) with AAISP[2] (£45)

once you add on "a couple of quid VPS a month", you could even go for the AAISP 1TB package at £60/month

[1]: https://www.productsandservices.bt.com/products/broadband-pa...

[2]: http://www.aaisp.net.uk/broadband-home1.html

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by timthorn on Sunday March 26, 2017 @04:27PM (#13963070)
My point was more about them offering a mobile service - many here know of them as a good ISP, but it is less well known that they offer the same quality of Internet access via mobile.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by IanCal on Tuesday March 28, 2017 @07:44AM (#13975753)
I certainly fall into that bucket. Thanks for the note, I had no idea they did mobile stuff too.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by bartread on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:27AM (#13960923)
Or use a VPN service.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by DanBC on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:18AM (#13960630)
> "this is an adult resource and you can't view it"

Those filters, if they're ISP supplied, are optional. You can turn them off.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by k-mcgrady on Sunday March 26, 2017 @11:34AM (#13961273)
It's completely optional, turn it off. It also tends to only be mobile networks that do that kind of filtering by default, ISP's ask you when you sign up if you want 'parental controls' or not.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by clort on Sunday March 26, 2017 @02:20PM (#13962203)
Funnily enough, I just signed up to 3 mobile broadband last week, and I was pleasantly surprised that I didn't have to call and get it turned off (always have before)
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by JCDenton2052 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:09AM (#13960585)
One word, my friend: VPN.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by atmosx on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:28AM (#13960675)
> One word, my friend: VPN.

A VPN is a way to circumvent surveillance but make no mistake: We must press with all our power for legislation which guarantees privacy, all over the world. This is a battle that in the long run, we can't win with tech. We need to become more privacy-aware.

"Those who surrender freedom for security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one."

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by brokenmachine on Sunday March 26, 2017 @08:20PM (#13964214)
+1. I agree with this.

With the current trend, how long until VPNs are made illegal? "For the children!"

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by noja on Sunday March 26, 2017 @01:17PM (#13961809)
To circumvent bad policy like encryption... Use encryption?
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by danmaz74 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:37AM (#13960714)
Being ahead of all other EU countries in some field can be something significant while they're inside the EU, in those cases when an investment or purchase needs to be made inside the EU for any reason. But when they're out, what difference does that make?
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by NetStrikeForce on Sunday March 26, 2017 @02:59PM (#13962448)
My point is that in case British businesses have to overcome barriers (e.g. tariffs), their best bet at not going bankrupt is selling non-physical goods and services with as much added value as possible. That implies high technology and investment in research.

Non-physical so selling to America, Africa or Asia is as cheap as selling to Europe and added value to absorb the new cost of doing businesses (in case the UK does not remain in the Single Market).

If e22 encryption is outlawed in the UK, their businesses would be less trusted (harder to sell expensive things) and will be at the mercy of other countries' intelligence and espionage services.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by nicky0 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @01:09PM (#13961769)
It's not like relations with other European countries will immediately cease on leaving the EU.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by danmaz74 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @02:48PM (#13962374)
That's not what I meant or wish. But it's a (for me sad) fact that at that point the expression "compared to the other EU countries" won't have any sense anymore. And if May will go with hard Brexit, as many predict, it will even become easier to trade with eg Canada than with the UK.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by nicky0 on Monday March 27, 2017 @06:20AM (#13966419)
You can say "compared to the other European countries" instead. It has the bonus of being more inclusive! No longer will your statement exclude Norway, Switzerland etc.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by danmaz74 on Monday March 27, 2017 @07:24AM (#13966743)
Depending on context, this comparison may or may not make sense. Keep in mind that Norway and Switzerland are both part of the single market, which the UK will probably opt out of (as it would require the free movement of workers).
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by Symbiote on Sunday March 26, 2017 @07:14AM (#13960182)
From [1], linked elsewhere in this discussion, and referring to a failed plot in India:

"The Hindi-speaking handler guiding the men in Hyderabad also insisted on using a kaleidoscope of encrypted messaging applications, with Mr. Yazdani instructed to hop between apps so that even if one message history was discovered and cracked, it would reveal only a portion of their handiwork."

"the handler taught Mr. Yazdani how to use the Tails operating system, which is contained on a USB stick and allows a user to boot up a computer from the external device and use it without leaving a trace on the hard drive."

Even if the British government is successful with WhatsApp, can they do much against free, open source tools?

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/04/world/asia/isis-messaging...

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by zzzcpan on Sunday March 26, 2017 @07:28AM (#13960232)
"Even if the British government is successful with WhatsApp, can they do much against free, open source tools?"

Why would they care about open source tools and niche use of encryption? Of course they don't. They are after mass surveillance and use fear of terrorism to push for it. It's very logical of them.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by dawnerd on Sunday March 26, 2017 @08:32AM (#13960434)
I feel countries will ultimately make it a crime to use any non approved encryption.
Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by Stranger43 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @09:56AM (#13960796)
The UK actually tried to enforce key escrow as far back and 1999(http://www.cyber-rights.org/crypto/ukpolicy.htm). But backed down due to conflicts with EU law.

It's not entirely by accident that the UK current ramp up of legalized government surveillance coincide with Brexit, as the UK doesn't actually have a democratic constitution limiting government surveillance outside of the ECHR treaty they signed as a prerequisite for joining the EU/EEC.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by stordoff on Sunday March 26, 2017 @12:13PM (#13961452)
> ECHR treaty they signed as a prerequisite for joining the EU/EEC

The UK signed the ECHR in 1950 (and were involved in writing it); the EEC did not exist until 1957.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by Stranger43 on Sunday March 26, 2017 @03:11PM (#13962513)
thanks for correcting my sometimes failing memory though the reality is more complex then that everything ECHR related was defined by 1950, as the active component of the ECHR did not come into existence until 1959 and was not acknowledged as superior court by the UK prior to the UK joining the EU.

The court http://www.coe.int/t/democracy/migration/bodies/echr_en.asp is what makes the ECHR significantly more effective then the unenforceable UN Declaration of Human Rights signed in 1948 only came into effect in 1859 and was only explicitly acknowledged as superior in British law with the still controversial Human rights act of 1998 https://www.supremecourt.uk/about/the-supreme-court-and-euro....

The fact that EU membership demand actual rather then pretend ECHR compliance is a fairly big deal in the anti-EU Tory circles currently running the show in the UK and some of them seem to presume that leaving the EU will absolve the UK of any duty to submit to the ECHR court http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/01/26/theresa-may-prepa... even though I am sure they think otherwise in Strasbourg.

but you are correct in stating that officially the ECHR came into dejura effect in 1950 under the Council of Europe where the UK unlike for the ECSC(1951) and the EEC(1957) was a founding member, but it's worth nothing here that the Council of Europe is a far more toothless organization(like the UN) then either the ECSC and the EEC.

Edit: fixed links

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by leggomylibro on Sunday March 26, 2017 @10:41AM (#13960995)
That's the beauty of it; even with their more restrictive measures and massively increased surveillance, they won't make a significant dent in these sorts of attacks.

So they'll never run out of reasons to push further. Hooray.

Re:UK Home Secretary says encryption on messaging services i... by doctorshady on Sunday March 26, 2017 @03:34PM (#13962686)
I'm surprised I haven't heard the IP bill mentioned other than here in this whole matter. Why all the fanfare? Especially if it's something they can already just do quietly; the public controversy from that law has mostly passed over.