News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by sidlls on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @11:47AM (#13923251)
Your comment is being downvoted for a number of reasons. I'd like to use it as soapbox for a moment.

One reason I left academia was the constant cycle of grant funding proposals followed by a flurry of publication followed by more proposals. These proposals often carried some requirement for language that, in my view, was a direct response to a certain kind of taxpayer, in order to justify on some tangible level the "need" for the research to be funded.

Basic science, and theoretical research alike deserve far more funding than they get. That a significant portion of our country views the funding model we have for scientific discovery as "beg[ging]" is one of the greatest failures we have as a culture.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by cestith on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:54PM (#13924532)
Oh, some of it does come down to almost begging. It shouldn't, because funding discovery is important. People doing long hours of hard work for the common good shouldn't have to beg for funding. Then again, we shouldn't have to beg for school lunches or housing for military vets either but look at social media right now.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by TheGRS on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @03:46PM (#13925525)
I think on a philosophical level everyone should be able to justify their work at any time. But on a practical level this can be distracting to the people doing the work and it gets us into the begging/funding/publishing cycle we're stuck in now. Maybe the reward system just needs to be changed.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by zerebubuth on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:00PM (#13924044)
How much of that attitude do you think is due to a cultural shared failure to value basic science and theoretical research, and how much is due to a failure to communicate the benefits of such activities?

I think it's quite possible that when people hear "it's complicated" or "we won't see practical applications for a decade", they wonder whether it's money well-spent. Especially if funding for things which have an immediate impact (e.g: healthcare, schools) is perceived as desperately lacking.

It seems to me that the joy of discovering and understanding the universe does not get communicated to the general public, and that's a failing of those who are asking that the general public fund their research (whether individual scientists or funding bodies such as EPSRC).

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by ams6110 on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @04:35PM (#13925981)
Also I think that popular media accounts of some ridiculous-sounding research that got funding tends to get extrapolated (by at least some folks) to a characterization all taxpayer-funded research. One example I remember hearing about a few years ago was a study of how cocaine affects the sexual behavior of Japanese Quail. A lot of people hear about that sort of thing and question why their money is being spent on such useless-sounding research.

And I imagine a fair number of people who are just working to get by don't see much point in the study of escoteric particle physics either. Never going to affect their lives.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by sidlls on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:05PM (#13924622)
I can't disagree that there is a failure​ of communication as you note. Or at least a deficiency.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by UweSchmidt on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:57PM (#13925099)
Good comment.

Just curious, just how much funding should basic science and theoretical research get, exactly?

[dead]
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:10PM (#13924134)
What's the market value of General Relativity and the Standard Model? Where can I buy shares in them? What's the ROI this week?
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by jamesdwilson on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:17PM (#13924199)
Ask SpaceX, General Electric, and the thousands of other companies that rely heavily on science.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by nananonymous on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:37PM (#13924408)
That's the problem. They can't answer that question and neither can the market. The market is great at assigning value to things based on scarcity and demand, but there will never be scarcity of the Navier-Stokes equations because they can just be copied and shared so the market is useless for saying what they're worth.

And before a discovery is made literally nobody knows how it might change the world. I somehow doubt a thousand investors could have better predicted the future value of the transistor any better than the handful of electrical engineers working on that frontier.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by jamesdwilson on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @01:41PM (#13924433)
but companies such as cocacola, and well, many many others, are researching things all the time for discoveries that benefit their company.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by nananonymous on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:13PM (#13924695)
That's great for solving known problems, like maybe Coke could estimate that reducing turbulence in their pipes in Warehouse ABC would save them a half million dollars a year. Then they can set aside money, maybe insure the project against failure, the insurance company has some idea what to charge them for such a policy, and so on.

But when Einstein was working on Relativity nobody could have foreseen what it would make possible. In that case the discovery was made and then eventually the business sector found a way to sell it, decades afterwards. Today we know what GPS makes possible so we know what it's worth, but in 1905 there was basically no market value for it.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by jamesdwilson on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:31PM (#13924846)
good points, thank you
[dead]
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by dwaltrip on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @05:44PM (#13926545)
Your comments would be more positively received if you acknowledged the minority position your views represent, and take that into consideration when trying to make points to others.

Many people support large amounts of free market activity and decentralized economic agency, but most people believe that only relying on this model of human organization will bring significant harm to society.

Very few people consider the idea of "taxation is theft" to be even remotely reasonable.

Thus there is a fairly large gap for you to bridge when trying to make points that rely on such principles.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by nananonymous on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:02PM (#13924595)
I have a hard time seeing taxation as always theft. In a democratic society the public either is or was part of the decision on whether or not to fund things like the LHC. If society agrees to pay for it then by definition there's no coercion.

I think the LHC has over a dozen participating countries, each of which volunteered to be part of it. Ideally there should be checks and balances making sure a project of this scale is free from corruption.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by jamesdwilson on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:16PM (#13924714)
if tax isn't theft, then the free market will decide to do the same thing..
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @03:41PM (#13925488)
Neither theft nor markets exist without property rights. And to have property rights you need a legal system, you need democratic institutions, law makers, an executive branch that enforces your legal rights, etc.

That costs money. It requires the work and agreement of others. You are not entitled to that for free and without entering into any sort of negotiation that involves give and take.

Your demand for protection against that thing you call "theft" is essentially a demand for the existence of a system of government, and that requires taxes. Therefore the claim that taxes are theft contradicts itself.

Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by contravariant on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @03:32PM (#13925421)
It did.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by braymundo on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:04PM (#13924613)
This should be interesting for the "tax is theft" crowd: http://lesswrong.com/lw/e95/the_noncentral_fallacy_the_worst...
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by sidlls on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:06PM (#13924631)
These companies rely heavily on science that has in some part, usually some large part, been funded by government funded research programs.
Re:CERN experiment discovers five new particles by jamesdwilson on Tuesday March 21, 2017 @02:32PM (#13924853)
that is not an argument that it is needed