The way I look at it is the spin-down of planets and the heat death of the universe are reduction to extremes arguments about why perpetual motion machines won't work.
That's the very best you could do, in practice any 'perpetual' motion machine that is actually built will do enormously worse, so much worse in fact that I feel pretty confident placing the word between quotes.
The problem with this subject matter is that it brings the kooks out of the woodworks like not much else does (oh, maybe 'over unity energy', en even more absurd concept).
Of course any practical failures are due to insufficient funds or skill, and any theoretical limitations are just that: theoretical.
But so far in spite of there being in excess of a million dollars of prize money awarded for the first perpetual motion machine nothing seems to have passed the first level of testing.
A handheld box that outputs 1kW constantly for 2 billion years is very impossible despite bypassing all those arguments about eventual tidal/orbital/proton decay.
> A handheld box that outputs 1kW constantly for 2 billion years is very impossible despite bypassing all those arguments about eventual tidal/orbital/proton decay.
It is impossible in principle, but if it were possible chances are that it would still not be a perpetual motion machine, likely it would be producing an excess of 1KW and be capped at that much output to mask the eventual running down of whatever power source sat inside the box.
Applying all this to perpetual motion, it does not mean 'straight line unless interfered with', it means 'able to change configuration or acellerate relative to it's own frame of reference'.
Dead objects are dead, whether they are moving respective to Earth or not is not relevant and does not magically make them perpetual motion machines, that's just energy imparted at some point in the past.
Yes, that's what I mean by 'big rocket'.
>It is impossible in principle, but if it were possible chances are that it would still not be a perpetual motion machine, likely it would be producing an excess of 1KW and be capped at that much output to mask the eventual running down of whatever power source sat inside the box.
I meant something that is uncapped and does not run down.
Just because it eventually breaks does not stop it from being a perpetual motion machine. Nobody claiming to have a perpetual motion machine is saying it will never need maintenance. An argument that everything needs maintenance is not enlightening. What matters is whether the energy source is infinite, not whether physical durability is infinite.
> Applying all this to perpetual motion, it does not mean 'straight line unless interfered with', it means 'able to change configuration or acellerate relative to it's own frame of reference'.
> Dead objects are dead, whether they are moving respective to Earth or not is not relevant and does not magically make them perpetual motion machines, that's just energy imparted at some point in the past.
Did you forget that this line of conversation started with "Doesn't inertia guarantee the possibility of linear perpetual motion?" They're not talking about a machine with infinite power, they're talking about a dead perpetual motion non-machine.
Linear perpetual motion isn't.
Dead perpetual motion non-machine is indistinguishable from object at rest. If you don't agree with that you are disagreeing with just about all of physics and any speculation that follows is disconnected from reality as we currently understand it, which leaves a tiny little loophole but not enough to get your hopes up about.
If wishes were horses...
> An argument that everything needs maintenance is not enlightening.
Not everything comes in easy to understand ten word soundbites, any machine needs maintenance due to friction, and as soon as there is friction there is a loss of energy and so the system will run down.
A needle bearing is a really good bearing but it still wears out (and warms up slightly losing some system energy to heat) and will eventually cause your machine to run down.
A big enough flywheel on air bearings could run for a really long time but it too eventually would run down, and air bearings use some energy. Magnetic bearings would work too but would induce a little bit of drag causing some losses to heat.
A current in a superconductor will run for a really long time but - you've guessed it - eventually it will run down. Very low resistance != zero resistance.
Anyway, HN is one of the few forums where scientific discussions are grounded in facts and that makes it a good place to hang out. If you feel that you want 'equal time' for perpetual motion either by redefining the term in such a way that it becomes meaningless or in a way that it no longer qualifies as perpetual motion to begin with I'm fine with that but it makes the discussion rather pointless.
We have the real world, where something can go on nearly-forever but there are no magic energy sources.
We have unicorn world, where there are magic energy sources.
Arguments about friction and air resistance and tidal decay and heat death prove that nearly-forever is not literally-forever.
That's fine, but it doesn't disprove the unicorns.
If we were in unicorn world, our magic energy source would take 100% power input and turn it into 200% output, and even after losses to friction you'd still have 190% left over.
Saying that "eventually the magic device needs parts replaced" is completely true, but that's not what people care about.
When someone says "perpetual motion machine" they're talking about turning 100% power into 200% power. They're not worried about exactly how long it can run without maintenance.
In other words, you're taking 'perpetual' too literally. You're disproving the idea that anything goes forever, but what 'perpetual' actually means here is that it's extracting energy from an infinite source rather than a finite source.
There are no infinite sources of energy, only very very large ones.
> When someone says "perpetual motion machine" they're talking about turning 100% power into 200% power.
No, that's over-unity, a different concept altogether.
Anyway, it's way past my bedtime here (3 am almost), so I have to bow out here, apologies for that, it was an interesting discussion, I'm not sure if I've achieved anything but that's fine with me. FWIW I was active for years on a message board where 'perpetual motion', 'over-unity' and 'zero point energy' came up with great regularity, if you enjoy that sort of thing you might find similar minded folks there, it is called 'fieldlines'.
sleep well & best regards,
Jacques
Yes, in the real world. But thought experiments are different.
> No, that's over-unity, a different concept altogether.
It's a subset. I'm pretty confident that if you have a hundred people define or describe a "perpetual motion machine", almost all of them will talk about pulling energy out of 'nowhere', or turning energy into more energy. And almost none of them will care if parts wear out, as long as those parts aren't supplying the energy. Maybe I'm wrong, but you're the first person I've seen that has taken 'perpetual' literally and to the end of time.
Good night.