Re:Has Li-battery genius John Goodenough done it again? Coll...
by Dylan16807 on Monday March 20, 2017 @10:09PM
(#13919286)
> There are no infinite sources of energy, only very very large ones.
Yes, in the real world. But thought experiments are different.
> No, that's over-unity, a different concept altogether.
It's a subset. I'm pretty confident that if you have a hundred people define or describe a "perpetual motion machine", almost all of them will talk about pulling energy out of 'nowhere', or turning energy into more energy. And almost none of them will care if parts wear out, as long as those parts aren't supplying the energy. Maybe I'm wrong, but you're the first person I've seen that has taken 'perpetual' literally and to the end of time.
Yes, in the real world. But thought experiments are different.
> No, that's over-unity, a different concept altogether.
It's a subset. I'm pretty confident that if you have a hundred people define or describe a "perpetual motion machine", almost all of them will talk about pulling energy out of 'nowhere', or turning energy into more energy. And almost none of them will care if parts wear out, as long as those parts aren't supplying the energy. Maybe I'm wrong, but you're the first person I've seen that has taken 'perpetual' literally and to the end of time.
Good night.