News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by jahaja on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:32PM (#13903068)
I think you're giving economics the benefit of the doubt while having a critical eye towards sociology when they're not much different in regards to objectivity and being "soft" sciences. In fact I'm not sure sociology would still have its credibility intact if it were to have as many failures as economics have had just the latest 20 years or so. Somehow economics manages this, which leads me to the next point.

I'm surprised that you're speaking with such certainty without mentioning the rather powerful relationship between economics and finance in a classical "follow the money" trail of thought.

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by 1337biz on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:45PM (#13903137)
> In fact I'm not sure sociology would still have its credibility intact if it were to have as many failures as economics have had just the latest 20 years or so.

We are here back at the fundamental mathification problem. Economists have understood that as long as their formulas look scientific enough, they can influence with their results policy makers et al.. Sociology rarely present their research in terms of the broad and universal truth as the economists do. So while Economists' results look rigorous on paper, reality still proves it often wrong.

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by kome on Saturday March 18, 2017 @06:00PM (#13903735)
That's so true. Economics copies hard science in its methods instead of its ends...
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by eanzenberg on Saturday March 18, 2017 @04:13PM (#13903269)
Please separate fundamental economic research with political economic decision-making. Good economic research improves tries to model real behavior. This doesn't stop politicians from cherry-picking research articles to verify their sometimes incorrect worldviews.

This is analogous to complaining that climate researchers aren't rigorous because some subset of politicians claim it isn't manmade and point to some articles which support their claims.

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by xg15 on Saturday March 18, 2017 @09:34PM (#13904618)
Then where were all the economists that raised alarm bells about the upcoming financial crisis but were silenced by ignorant politicians?
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by dgellow on Sunday March 19, 2017 @12:12AM (#13905133)
You might be interested by the book (or the movie) The Big Short: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Short
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by trendia on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:37PM (#13903105)
> relationship between economics and finance in a classical "follow the money" trail of thought.

What specifically are you claiming?

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by jahaja on Saturday March 18, 2017 @03:48PM (#13903153)
That the study of economics has a strong connection to both capital and power while sociology is more academic/institutional and thus less influential.
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by sdenton4 on Saturday March 18, 2017 @04:07PM (#13903247)
True dat. Economics has a number of reformers, in endless battle with an elite who make their names and fortunes by telling power what it wants to hear (and dressing it up with shamanistic differential equations to give the appearance of credibility).
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by dredmorbius on Saturday March 18, 2017 @10:26PM (#13904807)
This. In spades.

J.K. Galbraith (an economist himself) has claimed largely the same himself, and he's hardly the only one (within the field).

(Update) Some examples: https://unlearningeconomics.wordpress.com/tag/economists/

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by trendia on Saturday March 18, 2017 @04:05PM (#13903232)
Except for Stiglitz, Borjas, Piketty, etc.
Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by cynicalkane on Saturday March 18, 2017 @08:45PM (#13904425)
> I'm not sure sociology would still have its credibility intact if it were to have as many failures as economics

A lot of sociology is unfalsifiable. However, this is a field in which many people still look up to Marx--a sociologist whose predictions were falsified in a rather spectacular way.

Foundational microeconomic theories, however, are easily verified in many everyday cases and frequently used to make money in practice. Furthermore note that we're pretty sure about when the foundations apply and when they don't. Being able to say "I know when this is true" is a very powerful thing. The non-economic side of sociology can't say anything like that.

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by stewbrew on Sunday March 19, 2017 @03:22PM (#13909074)
1. Marx wasn't a sociologist.

2. There are quite a few economists around that would wholeheartedly disagree with your statement that his predictions were falsified.

3. Microeconomic theories are falsified every day in actual interactions. It just doesn't matter.

4. Those who say they know what's true are either ... whatever. They most likely aren't scientists at work.

Re:If Sociologists Had as Much Influence as Economists by TheSpiceIsLife on Sunday March 19, 2017 @12:27AM (#13905180)
I agree with this, they aren't much different.

Economics is a social science.

Economists, like Sociologists, have trouble predicting the future and the past.

The only thing, in my opinion, that separates Economics from Sociology is that for economic activity to take place there's also a hard substance that can be tracked, eg. money, but also other goods or services. Sociology is the social science that focuses on everything else in the field that isn't that. Sociology is Economics poor cousin, as it were.