News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by Upvoter33 on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:32AM (#13858668)
that is a sweet way to fail. don't blame her, though. there is only one real solution to this problem, unfortunately: much higher taxes once you start raking in absurd dollars. odds of that happening in US in near future: low.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by ksherlock on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:44PM (#13860983)
In 1993, there was a legislative attempt to limit CEO pay by capping the deductibility at $1 million (the company could pay more but it would not be tax deductible as a payroll expense). That $1 million number was the average CEO compensation at large firms, which ought to tell you all you need to know about the effectiveness.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by dottedmag on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:43AM (#13858783)
Don't you think CEO compensations will be even higher to compensate for higher taxes?
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by toomuchtodo on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:47AM (#13858812)
You're going to burn through company coffers quickly if the top tax rate is 90% at some income threshold around 7 figures ($1-9 million/year).

Precedent: http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/nov/...

"In 1944-45, during World War II, couples making more than $200,000 faced an all-time high of 94 percent. Sanders said income tax rates under Eisenhower were as high as 90 percent. A look through the records shows that top earners in the eight years of Eisenhower's presidency paid a top income tax rate of 91 percent."

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by nonbel on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:01PM (#13858958)
How many people actually payed that tax rather than finding some loophole though? I remember looking this up a few years ago and almost nothing was collected from that tax bracket... too lazy to check again now.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by richardwhiuk on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:09PM (#13859053)
The idea we should abandon a tax policy because people find loopholes seems absurd.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by nonbel on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:40PM (#13859450)
I don't think these loopholes are "found", it is more that tax policy was meant to be a feel-good measure that sounds good (to some people) after a cursory inspection but doesn't actually accomplish what is claimed.

edit: and I realize I originally used the word "found"

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by 086421357909764 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:55PM (#13860433)
I would argue requiring people to pay a disproportionate share of their income is absurd too.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by ar15saveslives on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:41PM (#13859464)
The idea of taking 90% tax is absurd too.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by Stratoscope on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:53PM (#13860407)
I'm actually in a tax bracket right now that is well over 100%. In fact, this particular tax can be as much as 12 million percent.

I got caught in this when I turned 65 and signed up for Medicare Parts B and D.

This tax is the Income Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA). The IRMAA tax is applied in increasing levels as your income goes over certain amounts. But it's not a marginal tax like income tax brackets where the higher rate applies only to your income over the bracket, and the tax rate doesn't change for income below that.

Instead, the IRMAA tax takes a hard jump of $1216/year as soon as your income goes one penny over the line. That one penny of additional income costs you $1216 in IRMAA tax. In other words, the tax on that penny is 12 million percent.

In my case, it wasn't quite so bad. I'm about $1800 over one of the IRMAA income levels. So that $1800 cost me $1216 in IRMAA tax, but I still have to pay federal and state income taxes on the extra $1800. Add it all up, and the total tax on that income is over 100%.

It is a strange thing, and I say downright evil, that my take-home pay goes down when my gross income goes up.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by richardwhiuk on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:49PM (#13861035)
That's an pointless way of expressing the percentage of taxation, and will inevitably lead to > 100% taxation, but that's not a useful way of looking at it.

Imagine an income tax model where everything less than $200k was untaxed, and everything above $200k is taxed at 20%, and tax is always rounded down towards the next cent value.

Thus $200.04 pays 0 tax, and $200.05 pays 1 cent tax. That 1 cent is '100% taxed', but given that would exist no matter what values you choose, it's not a helpful way of describing the taxation.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by 086421357909764 on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:56PM (#13860455)
It's very strange and I would argue it decreases your incentive for making more, which in turn generates growth in the economy based on spend.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by c0nducktr on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:53PM (#13859615)
I don't feel that it is. It's a marginal tax rate, not a flat 90%.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by candiodari on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:44PM (#13860274)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_33#Origin

So what I mean is that last time they had high marginal income tax rates holding shares would simply entitle you to a number of benefits, a famous one of which is Disney's Club 33. Lots of things were available though. Yachts, ski cabins, ... Needless to say, zero tax was paid on this.

So good luck with that 90% tax rate. Not going to happen.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by st3v3r on Monday March 13, 2017 @02:17PM (#13860703)
The idea of some of these salaries, relative to what normal people make, is even more absurd.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by ar15saveslives on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:15PM (#13863457)
Why? If A agrees to pay B "absurd" salary, it's mutual interest, isn't it? Otherwise A would find someone for 0.01x for the same job - no?

What is your salary, btw? 60k for sitting in cubicle and browsing reddit is absurd for the rest 6-7e9 people, that live outside of our lucky wealthy western world.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by valuearb on Tuesday March 14, 2017 @02:13PM (#13869970)
There were massive deductions, no one ever paid 90%
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by nugget on Monday March 13, 2017 @11:51AM (#13858854)
A job is the means by which you convert human capital to financial capital. If taxes are raised on direct compensation, this conversion becomes less efficient. Talented executives would likely exploit opportunities to earn stock at artificially low valuations. You can do this by joining startups or private companies who typically have more flexibility with valuations. This could make public companies relatively less attractive to talent, and they could suffer as a result. To the extent that retail investors and pension funds have more access to public companies than private companies or startups, they could suffer as well.

If you theoretically limited all compensation then you would distort the market in other ways - beyond a certain amount of cash and stock compensation (taxed at confiscatory rates), I would start to optimize for things like multiple secretaries, nepotism, a massive office, and other items which wouldn't necessarily help the business.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by neogodless on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:34PM (#13859377)
"You get what you incentivize."

If you want efficient production, you don't tax production. You tax consumption. While I may personally think million dollar paychecks are silly, and that the value created doesn't align with the compensation, I'm not convinced that increasing taxes along with income (i.e. loosely correlated with production) is the way to go. Instead, tax consumption.

In other words, if you're going to get taxed all to hell to buy a pointless yacht and $250 million homes, you might not want to do that, quite as much, so you might not care as much about making an extra $20 million, so you might not negotiate such an obscene paycheck. (Maybe you'd even care more about the value you bring to the table and the humans in the picture.)

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by mybrid on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:46PM (#13859531)
History tells a different story. When the income tax was first implemented it was not long ere any income over one million dollars was 100% taxed. During Eisenhower's two-terms in the 1950s the top tax bracket was 75%. It is interesting to consider that when the modern conservative wants to return to the American prosperity of the 1950s if, like you, conservatives would be willing to return to Eiesenhower's tax brackets and tax production.

A better historical argument can be made that America should have never switched from a dividends approach to the stock market during the late 1970s. Our current system rewards quarterly gains for long term losses and this has lead to the various bubbles. I can easily argue we should return to Eisehower tax brackets and also a dividends approach to stock market gains and in doing so history is on my side.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by opo on Monday March 13, 2017 @03:59PM (#13861776)
There is a huge difference between top marginal rates and actual effective tax rates. Since 1950, federal taxes have consumed 17 to 20 percent of GDP in taxes. Most economists are opposed to very high marginal tax rates though due to the inefficiencies they introduce - compensation being moved to non-salary, money wasted on CPAs, lawyers and lobbying congress for special deductions, dead weight losses for economic activity that isn't done, etc.

Currently the effective rates are fairly close to the past for high wage earners, lower for low wage earners.

>...In 1958, approximately two million filers (4.4% of all taxpayers) earned the $12,000 or more for married couples needed to face marginal rates as high as 30%. These Americans paid about 35% of all income taxes. And now? In 2010, 3.9 million taxpayers (2.75% of all taxpayers) were subjected to rates that were 33% or higher. These Americans—many of whom would hardly call themselves wealthy—reported an adjusted gross income of $209,000 or higher, and they paid 49.7% of all income taxes.

>In contrast, the share of taxes paid by the bottom two-thirds of taxpayers has fallen dramatically over the same period. In 1958, these Americans accounted for 41.3% of adjusted gross income and paid 29% of all federal taxes. By 2010, their share of adjusted gross income had fallen to 22.5%. But their share of taxes paid fell far more dramatically—to 6.7%. The 77% decline represents the single biggest difference in the way the tax burden is shared in this country since the late 1950s.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241278873247051045781516....

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by crdoconnor on Monday March 13, 2017 @07:22PM (#13863505)
"There is a huge difference between top marginal rates and actual effective tax rates. Since 1950, federal taxes have consumed 17 to 20 percent of GDP in taxes. Most economists are opposed to very high marginal tax rates though due to the inefficiencies they introduce"

Most economists who say that are responding to incentives.

It's a rare economist who would admit in the same breath that this 'inefficiency' coincided (not coincidentally either) with the highest growth rate in recent American history.

Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by neogodless on Monday March 13, 2017 @01:00PM (#13859736)
That is interesting. I don't know if "what worked then will work now," but I'm definitely not sure of any theories about taxation! Human behavior and motivation continue to surprise us. Of course, arm chair philosophy about taxation is unfortunately ineffective in affecting policy change!
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by thrownblown on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:41PM (#13859463)
And if you want to start a yacht building economy, remove those taxes on yachts and those with the means will buy your country's yachts.
Re:Mayer $23M golden parachute as Yahoo names post-Verizon d... by setum on Monday March 13, 2017 @12:12PM (#13859080)
Ah, another bureaucratic solution. As if these work? Companies will start buying their CEO luxury apartments, yacht, etc...

BTW this has been tried before: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenue_Act_of_1942

It was then, that the employers started giving free insurance to get around wage cap, and seedlings for present healthcare mess were planted.

https://www.ebri.org/publications/facts/index.cfm?fa=0302fac...